IT Central Station is now PeerSpot: Here's why

How does Network Detection and Response (NDR) Differ from SIEM?

Rony_Sklar - PeerSpot reviewer
Community Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)

Hello community, 

What are the differences between how NDR and SIEM work? 

What are the pros and cons of each? Is it necessary to have both types of tools?

PeerSpot user
77 Answers

William Munroe - PeerSpot reviewer

The answers are all solid. 

I would add that NDR tools do not look just at network traffic. Most of the vendors have realized that the cloud is now part of the network and are intaking and analyzing AWS, Google, and MS cloud information looking for risks and threats. 

I would also add that many mid and small-sized companies either outsource or do not run a SIEM because they are complex and require security analyst resources they often cannot afford.  

Many will run EDR and NDR on-premise or outsource the entire stack to an MSSP and MDR vendor.

Angela Heindl-Schober - PeerSpot reviewer

"SIEM's are incredibly fixable technology platforms that can be used within your environment to discover advanced threats and to fill gaps in coverage for other tools. In theory, you could replicate a lot of EDR use cases in a SIEM by forwarding all endpoint data and building your own searches and data models but it wouldn't be cost- or operational-effective. This is why we have EDR tools. 

The same goes for NDR. While many organisations have attempted to solve NDR use cases with their SIEM tools but have had limited success and are quite cost-prohibitive to build and maintain these solutions. Networks threats are getting more complex and more widespread and organisations need to invest in specialist tools like NDR that provide insights into the threats within your network rather than solutions that just allow you to search on raw data. While most organisations will more than likely require a SIEM to fill some edge cases in their technology stack more often than not organisations save in both upfront and ongoing costs by investing in a strong NDR solution before investing in a SIEM". 

Lindsay Mieth - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5Real User

Your SIEM should receive and process traffic generated by your NDR as well as events from your endpoint protection systems, server event logs, infrastructure device logs and cloud services logs then be able to correlate these data points to highlight suspicious patterns or anomalies.  The SIEMs can then send commands to perimeter and point systems in certain cases to interrupt such activity or just alert to them.

Jairo Willian Pereira - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5LeaderboardReal User

SIEM aggregates data from multiple systems (like an EDR solution, IDS/IPs etc.) and analyze that data to catch abnormal behavior or potential cyberattacks. SIEM tools offer a central place to collect events and alerts, security data from network devices, servers, domain controllers and more. In a simple way, EDR may be a just another "sensor-type" and "SIEM" stores, normalizes, aggregates, and applies analytics to that data to discover trends, detect threats, and enable organizations to investigate any alerts.

DK Shrivastava - PeerSpot reviewer

NDR is just analysis of network behaviour and forms a part of SIEM strategy. it can only detect anomaly in network traffic flow . SIEM takes logs of network flow also.

Nicholas Arraje - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 20Vendor

NDR and SIEM are two different types of tools used by security professionals.  

You don't need a SIEM to run an NDR solution or vice versa. Larger organizations or mature organizations tend to have both in addition to other tools like EDR and SOAR. 

Today's NDR's are typically designed to provide network visibility and detection across your entire network (East-West, North-South) and yes the network is no longer just your on-prem environment. It also includes your Cloud environment as most NDR solutions support AWS, Azure, and GCP.  

NDR tools can generate PCAP data, network log and metadata, and alert data all of which can be consumed by a SIEM.  

SIEMs in many organizations are the log aggregation tools and data laking solutions for the security team. For small organizations that just want NDR, most solutions offer their own UI and don't require a SIEM. 

For those organizations that already have a SIEM, the NDR is one of the most valuable tools to generate forensic data. 

You can learn more about NDR solutions from Bricata's ebook on "What to look for in an NDR". 

Sanghoon Jang - PeerSpot reviewer

NDR generate source events from network traffic.
SIEM gethering one or more as well as NDR events AND correlation analysis.
So company need both system

Buyer's Guide
Security Information and Event Management (SIEM)
June 2022
Find out what your peers are saying about Splunk, IBM, Microsoft and others in Security Information and Event Management (SIEM). Updated: June 2022.
610,190 professionals have used our research since 2012.