Coming October 25: PeerSpot Awards will be announced! Learn more
2014-12-09T10:25:00Z
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Content at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
  • 33
  • 99

When evaluating Security Information and Event Management (SIEM), what aspect do you think is the most important feature to look for?

One of our community members wrote that what's important is  "compatibility with diverse sources, including the ability to adapt to unknown ones, performance, and the ability to do multi-level correlation."

What do you think?

See other excellent answers below.

Let the community know what you think. Share your opinions now!

36
PeerSpot user
36 Answers
MS
Security Consultant at Verizon Communications
Real User
2018-06-05T20:30:21Z
05 June 18

Based on my experience with SIEM, 7 years I worked with ArcSight on a daily basis.
I would say that there are 3 mains points.

1) Objectives
What you would like to do with the SIEM.
What you have to achieve?
This is very important.

If you just need a solution to manage your logs and make searches for incident investigation.
I will use Splunk

If you need to build security monitoring use case with automatic notification
I will use ArcSight or QRadar.

2) Perimeter to monitor
What is the size of the infra to monitor?
How many AD users?
How many logs per day
Which logs to collect?
How many different vendors or logs type

If you have a big environment to monitor
You have no other choice to choose ArcSight
If it less QRadar could be used.

3) Security Team
Who will work with the SIEM?
This is highly critical because if you don't have a dedicated team with specific skills I will not recommend ArcSight because it is very complex and custom use is not enough documented.
You need an Expert on site to be able to use this tool correctly and efficiently to increase usefulness.
QRadar is less complex but for sure it will be less flexible.

If you want to use other SIEM solution or open source, you need to answer first to the 3 above points then you need to check if the solution can be able to collect, process, parse and categorize the logs you have to choose for your Use Cases
You have to verify how to build correlation, what are the limits
You have to check if you can build automatic notification
You have to check the evolution, what will be the new features
You have to ask the roadmap.
You shouldn't choose something that won't be developed anymore.
It is a lot of resources and time to build a SOC in using a SIEM
To configure the SIEM Infra completely
It is wrong to say that you can migrate easily to another solution. Completely wrong.

The last point, you need to verify the documentation and the support.
Very important for bugs, issues or important missing features.

I hope this answer will help you.
You can contact me if you have a precise question.

Siddhant Mishra - PeerSpot reviewer
Cyber Security Consultant at NETMONASTERY Inc.
Consultant
2019-05-03T07:07:56Z
03 May 19

When it comes to "features to look for in a SIEM" the answer is not simple and straightforward - as the saying goes: "one size fits all" doesn't work in this case.

Many infosec experts would argue that when it comes to security implementations, having a SIEM in place is the only way to go. That’s because a traditional SIEM, without fail, significantly increases visibility into vulnerabilities. However, these platforms still struggle with collecting and correlating logs in siloed data stores (the various security point solutions throughout the enterprise) which is an overkill when it comes to providing an enterprise-wide insight to security teams. Here are some resources that you might explore to better evaluate as per your cybersecurity requirements:

Resources you might find useful:

> Ebook - Why you need a next-gen SIEM - http://bit.ly/2UZxwHn

> Blog - How to make the most of your next-gen SIEM - http://bit.ly/2UTzcC8

Sasha Velednitsky - PeerSpot reviewer
VP of Business Development at a tech company with 11-50 employees
Real User
2018-06-05T22:12:33Z
05 June 18

Reducing false positives.

JR
System Engineer at a government with 51-200 employees
User
2018-06-05T20:13:11Z
05 June 18

Ease of deployment and building dashboards for people to use. Usability is a big issue for me. No product is good unless people can use it. I like out of the box dashboards. I also like to deploy from a central console. The issue of storage and parsing can be solved thru systems engineering. Some products, splunk does have a nice ability to fragment the logs into chunks, I think the call them coolers, so you can partition the data off for backup and recover plus parsing. Not sure if SolarWinds LEM offers this. I like the SolarWinds LEM out of the box dashboards.

it_user324942 - PeerSpot reviewer
Network admin/security at a government with 1,001-5,000 employees
Real User
2018-06-04T13:22:33Z
04 June 18

Ability to quickly extract information when required (forensic). The ease at which you can integrate your devices which are logging(agnostic) . Ability of the device to capture all your required logging and maintain it for a reasonable time frame (capacity).

PeerSpot user
Sr. Network Admin at a wholesaler/distributor with 1,001-5,000 employees
Vendor
2015-10-20T22:24:11Z
20 October 15

Real-time threat analysing and reporting capabilities

Find out what your peers are saying about Splunk, IBM, Microsoft and others in Security Information and Event Management (SIEM). Updated: September 2022.
633,572 professionals have used our research since 2012.
RG
CEO with 11-50 employees
Real User
2018-06-05T07:09:31Z
05 June 18

Well, actually very much to say.

To boil it down:

First:
- What’s the scope of your responsibility? If all IT operations, most can be achieved.
Core:
- Standard adapters: To configure log parsers and to care for updates is a kind of work to be avoided.
- Predefined correlations (multi-level) that you may adapt. Doing all that work yourself is quite much. More and more anomaly detection gets mature as a complementing, general concept. Good, if the vendor has such a module under development.
- Performance
Then:
- Coverage: Who many other tools are needed? Try to get one that does the job for log centralisation and alarming and audit trails and console tracking and…
- Flexible UI and alarming concept. Ability to trigger and evaluate immediate, automated actions (mostly in case in intruders detection…).

PeerSpot user
Head - Information Security at a comms service provider with 1,001-5,000 employees
User
2018-06-05T06:53:25Z
05 June 18

Ability to perform Advanced Context Correlation is one of the key parameter.

it_user813318 - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior I.T. Consultant at Rad-Infosec IT Consultation
Real User
2018-06-05T06:25:54Z
05 June 18

I think the best SIEM should enable users to easily setup alarm triggers based specific log, also vendor list of logs that should be monitored would be very helpful, I have seen some SIEM products are very powerful but need an expert to setup triggers, at the end of the day monitoring is the main job of SIEM

PeerSpot user
Sr Lead Solutions Architect at Booz Allen Hamilton
Real User
2018-06-04T20:12:05Z
04 June 18

To me, the answer to 'what aspect do you think is the most important to look for?' is RESULTS. Does the system (be it self-managed or MSSP) give you what you need? Cost aside, if it doesn't provide you the information or capabilities to let you be successful in obtaining your business outcomes, then it's a waste of money. Even if the system costs only $1 and you spend a lot of time either figuring it out or trying to get it to behave the way you want/need, then that costs too much! Forget all of the other nonsense, focus on the business outcomes and user experience, and you will get to the right tool. THEN you can look at the different tools that meet the criteria. (Just my $.02)

PeerSpot user
Senior IT Security Operations at a pharma/biotech company with 10,001+ employees
Vendor
2018-06-04T16:35:31Z
04 June 18

Data On boarding and usability of the tool is the most important thing. It has to be an easy tool to manage every day and of course, data onboarding has to be also an easy part of the process, even with unknown data sources.

David Kee CISSP CRISC CISA - PeerSpot reviewer
Sr. Architect/Sr. Security Strategist at a healthcare company with 10,001+ employees
Real User
2018-06-04T15:51:34Z
04 June 18

Dynamic interface for log/event collection; elastic storage; intuitive rule generation; api support for orchestration and threat intelligence integration; dashboard support for KRIs.

2018-06-04T15:22:19Z
04 June 18

Here is my take:

1. Integration to several log sources

2. Ease of access and deployment

3. User, Behavioral and network analysis

4. Ability to compress logs (Compression ratio)

5. Detailed reporting for Regulatory Compliance requirement

6. Security Intelligence capability

7. Database retention

it_user711273 - PeerSpot reviewer
Consultant
User
2018-06-04T12:49:39Z
04 June 18

I believe the most important consideration are 1) deployment model which should be in a distributed environment where there will be Logger, Reporting, Processor & the console because if there all in one it can create database issue after some point of time, 2) Asset discovery and Inventory, 3) Network visibility & Netflow information. (When we are considering SIEM we will be concentrating on Server, network, FW etc. nobody thinking about the client machine ; so if you dont have any IDS/IPS then you have no control and visibility on user machine so to get this we should consider to collect real time flow information from LAN Coreswitch, MPLS link flow information, Internet link flow information or VPN link flow information etc ), 3) Flexible reporting and various export (CSV or PDF)option to prepare report or pull out alerts information also alert notification, 4) Check for correlation rule (Event Based, Rule Based, Anomaly Based, Risk Based)availability in the SIEM toolset, 5) Incorporate with Service desk ticketing tool support, and integrating with Nessus/NMAP in to the SIEM portal to perform on demand scan on target, 6) Multiple dissimilar type of log colletion and correlation etc.

PeerSpot user
Business Development Manager- Threat Management Services at Insight Enterprises, Inc.
Real User
2018-04-18T19:43:54Z
18 April 18

Prebuilt content that is easily and intuitively integrated into my environment.

PeerSpot user
Senior Consultant at Redrock IT & Security Solutions
Consultant
2018-03-28T14:33:13Z
28 March 18

The biggest cost for most SIEM products is labor.

2018-02-28T08:08:16Z
28 February 18

Real time monitoring and reporting, protection, system realibility

PeerSpot user
IT Security Analyst at a tech vendor with 51-200 employees
Real User
2017-02-11T07:24:55Z
11 February 17

performance, workflow integration and reporting

it_user328515 - PeerSpot reviewer
Consultant
Vendor
2015-10-14T20:49:38Z
14 October 15

Combine information from several sources do intelligent queries on it and all within an easy to use environment

it_user322710 - PeerSpot reviewer
Deputy General Manager with 1,001-5,000 employees
Real User
2015-10-03T18:20:37Z
03 October 15

Most important criteria is Log and Packet analizing.

Vendor
2015-09-21T13:58:40Z
21 September 15

Real time security related logs & incidents reporting, relates with risks and possible damages to the infrastructure

Vendor
2015-09-08T14:05:43Z
08 September 15

Search Performance / capable to parse any logs format / price.

it_user290796 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2015-08-12T21:37:41Z
12 August 15

Finding the balance between the costs and benefits of the solution.

it_user289152 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2015-08-10T20:58:16Z
10 August 15

Compatibility with diverse sources, including ability to adapt to unknown ones. Performance. Ability do multilevel correlation.

Vendor
2015-08-05T10:29:48Z
05 August 15

Correlation and search performance.
... and price.

it_user285582 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2015-08-04T18:31:13Z
04 August 15

Threat intelligence and engine analytics

PeerSpot user
Security Professional with 501-1,000 employees
Consultant
Top 20
2015-07-27T16:16:34Z
27 July 15

It all depends on the purpose of the purchase.
Security Information and Event Management can be used to so many thing.

If its purpose is auditing/compliance it need to secure the chain of evidens or audit trail.
If its purpose is security it need to be abel to correlate the data.
In all purposes it need to be abel to receive data from all the sources you are using.

You need to think of the SIEM as a umbrella over all of your IT including physical surveillance equipment if needed.

PeerSpot user
Consultant SSI at a tech services company
Consultant
2015-07-07T18:57:48Z
07 July 15

Strong use cases implementation capabilities

Vendor
2015-06-26T15:09:01Z
26 June 15

The Real-time Gathering of Logs, and Reporting. Stability, and Price! Ease of use. Notification event Triggering.

Vendor
2015-06-09T07:35:34Z
09 June 15

Being available special Event Collectors with different environment is most important criteria.
Real time gathering logs from systems and Log Correlation is also very important

it_user244524 - PeerSpot reviewer
Security aadministrator
Vendor
2015-05-26T09:24:20Z
26 May 15

Real time threat analysing and reporting

PeerSpot user
Tecnical Security Analyst/Engineer at a retailer with 1,001-5,000 employees
Vendor
2015-05-04T08:42:56Z
04 May 15

From bitter recent experience, gaining easy access to evaluation software. Some main vendors make obtaining even limited license period packages very difficult - no names no pack drill here but one is 2 letters ending in a P.
My clients want vendor agnostic advice and as a small independent evaluator, I cannot afford to buy packages from all the disparate SIEM providers.

Real User
2015-04-23T21:51:10Z
23 April 15

That it is top rated and applies secuirty indepth. Must be easy to deploy, configure and use. Must complement and mix well with others, e.g., run QualysGuard along with Arcsight, Symantec endpoint and HBSS (McAfee).

it_user200754 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2015-02-26T21:45:26Z
26 February 15

Alerting and workflow integration

it_user200754 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2015-02-26T21:44:01Z
26 February 15

Sletting and workflow integrasjon.

PeerSpot user
system engineer at a government with 10,001+ employees
Vendor
2015-02-21T18:39:40Z
21 February 15

Working with Identity and Acces Management, is at the first place a controlled release and registration of all personel that is working in our department. From the beginning of the HR department, the provisioning of the roles and privileges, till they change job, department i.e. from Amsterdam to The Hague, of even die, you must be auditable of the amout of people the have role a, of permission z.. The SOLL situation must be updated frequently.
At our company, there is a bifurcation between the technic Department, an the Central Administration, owner of the data.
There is a good cooperation between the data owner and the technics.

Related Questions
Shibu Babuchandran - PeerSpot reviewer
Regional Manager/ Service Delivery Manager at ASPL INFO Services
Sep 11, 2022
Hi community,  I am a Service Delivery Manager at a medium-sized tech services company. I am researching PSIM (Physical Security Information Management). What are the main use cases and benefits of products that fall under this category? Thank you for your help.
it_user153546 - PeerSpot reviewer
User with 5,001-10,000 employees
Jul 28, 2017
Looking at SolarWinds LEM as a SIEM tool. Several of my managers are questioning the scalability for a global deployment. I am having difficulty providing adequate information as to its distributed architecture and the ability to access the raw (and/or) normalized data directly so that I can export the data into another analytical engine. Any help you have would be greatly appreciated.
2 out of 4 answers
PeerSpot user
Senior IT Security Consultant at a tech consulting company with 51-200 employees
23 September 14
Hi Russel, I'm afraid but I'm not an expert on the Solarwinds solution and can't really help your friend. If you need more general information about SIEM technology or on specific for McAfee or NetIQ let me know. Best Regards, Giacomo 2014-09-23 12:25 GMT+02:00 Russell Rothstein - CEO of IT Central Station < site-admin@itcentralstation.com>:
Byron Anderson - PeerSpot reviewer
Information Security Engineer at a cloud provider with 51-200 employees
23 September 14
If you are looking at scaling LEM for a global deployment it's really going to depend on how many systems you plan to manage and even more important is how many events you are planning to process on any given LEM appliance. You can install LEM appliances at different locations and then manage them all via one interface. As far as exporting the data into other systems, you options there are pretty limited. LEM unfortunately doesn't provide many options as far as exporting data is concerned. I think your best bet would be contacting SolarWinds and working with one of their Sales Engineers or even posting some of your questions to the LEM section of the Thwack.com forums. I know that the LEM product manager participates daily in the forums as well as many other LEM users such as myself. I hope this helps!
Download Free Report
Download our free Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) Report and find out what your peers are saying about Splunk, IBM, Microsoft, and more! Updated: September 2022.
DOWNLOAD NOW
633,572 professionals have used our research since 2012.