What is our primary use case?
Our main use case for Mimecast Advanced Email Security is phishing emails. We use it to identify phishing emails and the elements that can be targeted. Many recent attacks involve highly convincing or spoofed emails that pretend to come from the IT environment, ask for information, and ask the client to verify their credentials. Mimecast helps in that area. It encodes the URL, automatically detects the malicious URL, flags that URL or domain, and sends that email into quarantine. These are basic examples of how we use it for phishing. In our projects, we use Mimecast for a security track for various purposes, such as identifying emails, releasing users from the whitelist, and releasing particular emails that were quarantined.
In a specific incident where Mimecast made a big difference, an email was delivered to the user's inbox and contained a suspicious URL. Whenever this happens, Mimecast encodes that URL, so if the user clicks on it, he is not able to execute the original URL, because the original URL has been encoded. That is the big difference it makes.
I would also add how Mimecast is better than other tools. It combines threat protection, email continuity, and compliance within a single platform. It deploys as a traditional gateway, and we can integrate an API-based cloud integration tool as well. Mimecast is easy to deploy compared with other tools. The best thing about Mimecast is that it offers threat defense alongside security awareness training, including DMARC management and human risk monitoring. These are the areas it improves. In the enterprise, it also provides URL and attachment scanning.
Our internal email security policies and compliance requirements shape our configuration and ongoing management of Mimecast's policy engine, because we have strict obligations around data privacy, phishing, and auditability, such as GDPR, ISO 27001, and data loss prevention rules. We use Mimecast's granular-level policy definitions to enforce those standards automatically at the email gateway. For example, our internal security policy requires strict protection against executive impersonation and financial fraud. To enforce that, we configure Targeted Threat Protection rules for high-risk groups such as finance and leadership, alongside mandatory external sender warning banners. Whenever an external email is delivered, a note is shown at the top stating that the email was sent by an external user.
For compliance and data protection, we configure content examination DLP policies to detect sensitive data such as PII, financial records, or confidential keywords, and we automatically enforce TLS encryption or hold the message for review before it leaves our organization. For ongoing management, we put these controls in place and apply URL filtering rules. We rely on Mimecast's detailed audit logs to prove to auditors that our controls are actively enforced.
How has it helped my organization?
Mimecast Advanced Email Security has impacted our organization positively, as I mentioned, because it is an email security tool that helps identify potential threats in our environment. It improves our environment by strengthening policies, such as URL rewriting and URL protection. It provides long-term retention by storing emails and their associated data in the Mimecast cloud archive for an extended period. I have already mentioned many more things. As for improvements in Mimecast, I do not see any needed improvements in Mimecast itself, and its benefits are very good. It provides certifications and various other things.
Since implementing Mimecast Advanced Email Security, we have seen a noticeable drop in phishing and spam emails reaching user inboxes, which has significantly reduced our overall security risk. On the operational side, the security team saves several hours each week because we spend much less time manually investigating suspicious messages. We use sandboxing, automated threat blocking, and URL protection, which catch malicious links before employees even see them, and this lowers the number of security incidents we have to remediate. The best part of Mimecast is that it rewrites URLs. If the malicious element is not visible to the user, there is no harm to that user. That is how it helps.
Mimecast Advanced Email Security reduces the day-to-day workload on both the IT help desk and the security operations team. Before implementing it, a huge portion of our week went into rewriting everything and checking the analysis manually. With Mimecast, things are automated easily. It finds malicious domains, rewrites URLs, and can perform sandboxing as well. Many things are covered. It cuts down the manual process and makes things automated. This is how it helps the IT team and the security operations team.
We can assess the effectiveness of Mimecast's multi-layered detection techniques, such as Targeted Threat Protection and Impersonation Protect, against evolving email-borne threats through multiple points. Mimecast uses these detection techniques through a combination of quantitative security metrics, real-world incident testing, and day-to-day operations. First, we closely track threat telemetry and block rates in Mimecast reporting dashboards. Specifically, we look at how many malicious URLs are blocked at time of click, how many weaponized attachments are caught in sandboxing, how many executive or vendor spoofing attempts have occurred, how many impersonations have occurred, and how many emails have been moved to quarantine. These are the things we check. Second, we measure the downstream impact on our end users. Since rolling out Targeted Threat Protection, we have seen a sharp drop in user-reported phishing tickets and zero successful credential harvesting or wire fraud incidents. We also run internal phishing simulations and red teaming tests. The Mimecast engine detects and consistently flags those emails and checks domain anomalies right away. We also check how the system adapts without creating any friction, because Mimecast continuously updates its threat intelligence and behavioral models. There are multiple phishing techniques, such as QR code phishing or AI-generated social engineering, and we can handle them without constantly having to write manual rules to deal with spikes in false positives.
What is most valuable?
The best features of Mimecast Advanced Email Security are that it strengthens targeted email threat protection by protecting URLs, rewriting URLs, and handling malicious URLs and attachments. Mimecast rewrites URLs and checks destinations at time of click to stop malicious redirects. It stops that URL from redirecting to other URLs. It scans the files and sandboxes them in its own environment with minimal disruptions. It flags domain spoofing, executive impersonation, and business email compromise attempts. It also keeps email accessible during primary email server outages and supports long-term retention. These are the best features of Mimecast. The features I would pick for my organization are URL Protect and Attachment Protect. They are very helpful because if the user clicks on the URL, he still does not reach the original URL, since Mimecast rewrites those URLs, and the URL can be decoded only within the Mimecast tool. The user does not have access to the original URL. Even if he clicks on the malicious URL, it will not be executed. This is the best feature of it.
For security awareness training, Mimecast Advanced Email Security offers two types of certifications. These certifications let you learn more about Mimecast, including how things work and how policies are implemented. This is the awareness training I was talking about. The long-term retention period means that Mimecast holds the email for a longer time. That is basically how long-term retention works.
I have a lot of confidence in the governance and security surrounding Mimecast Advanced Email Security's AI capabilities, because email contains some of our organization's most sensitive communications, such as our emails, our projects, and details. Most of the details have been provided above. It provides data privacy, which is a complex top priority for us, and Mimecast handles AI-driven threat detection in a very secure, enterprise-ready way. From a security standpoint, the AI models do a standard job of detecting sophisticated AI-generated phishing emails, social engineering, and anomalies in sender behavior without exposing our internal data externally. We appreciate that the AI operates within strict compliance standards such as GDPR and ISO. On the governance side, it maintains clear visibility and control over how automated decisions are made. You can audit why an email was flagged or quarantined, and we can check that part. If an email is falsely quarantined, we can release it as well. This is what I can mention about the governance and security part.
The accuracy and reliability of Mimecast's AI capabilities are very good because it identifies the root cause. It catches sophisticated threats such as Business Email Compromise (BEC), executive impersonation, zero-day phishing links, and threats that traditional signature-based filters miss. The best thing that makes it stand out is that it analyzes language patterns and sender behavior. It finds domain anomalies in real time without slowing down normal email delivery. Before emails are delivered, it rewrites URLs. This is what makes it stand out from other tools.
One notable instance where Mimecast Advanced Email Security's detection capabilities handled a sophisticated email-borne threat involved Business Email Compromise (BEC). There was a campaign aimed at a client's finance department. The attacker used a lookalike domain and mimicked an executive's writing style to request an urgent wire transfer. There were no malicious links or attachments in that email. Traditional filters would have let it straight through, but Mimecast's Impersonation Protect and behavior-based detection immediately flagged the domain anomaly. The domain was found to be suspicious. Mimecast detected this at the earliest stage and held that email at the gateway itself before it reached the user's inbox. It stopped the email, flagged it, and quarantined it.
There is one more example related to phishing. Attackers send a link in an email, but when that link is checked, it is found to be clean. Then, an hour later, when the email is clicked, the link is found to be malicious. Mimecast has a Time-of-Click policy. When a user clicks on that URL, it inspects the URL at the back end. If the URL is found to be clean, only then will the URL be opened. These are the notable instances of Mimecast that I have seen in both cases, BEC and phishing, as I mentioned.
Because human users cannot realistically spot every AI-crafted lure on their own, I perceive Mimecast Advanced Email Security as a primary foundational layer of defense in my strategy against the evolving landscape of sophisticated email-borne threats. Rather than relying solely on known threat signatures, Mimecast works on both signature-based threats and non-signature-based threats. It monitors the behavior of the email, the sender address, and the domain. It verifies the communications, the identity, the communication patterns, and the message intent. It finds these things beyond blocking threats at the gateway, in real time. It rewrites URLs and sandboxes the attachments. It also plays a broader role: if a URL is already in the user's inbox, it helps the user when the URL is clicked. When a user clicks on a malicious URL, it does not execute at the same time. At the back end, it checks whether it can be executed or not. This is how it plays a role.
Mimecast fits with the rest of our security environment, including Microsoft 365 and other Mimecast products, because it integrates very smoothly into our broader security ecosystem and acts as a critical intelligence source for the rest of our stack. We feed Mimecast threat and audit logs directly into our SIEM platforms via its API connectors. That gives the SOC team unified visibility, allowing us to correlate email-based phishing attempts with endpoint, identity, and firewall alerts. We can therefore spot multi-stage attacks much faster. Beyond the SIEM, Mimecast works seamlessly alongside our Microsoft 365 Defender tool, adding stronger defense against threats before they ever touch our internal network or user devices. Within the Mimecast ecosystem, pairing email security with the DMARC Analyzer, cloud archive, or awareness training also creates a connected workflow. For example, phishing trends caught by our email gateway directly inform users' training modules, while archiving and continuity features ensure our compliance and disaster recovery needs are covered from a single domain admin console. If any phishing activity is found, we can use it and notify the user as well. It is easy to integrate with SIEM or SOAR tools as well as Microsoft 365 tools.
What needs improvement?
In my opinion, Mimecast Advanced Email Security can be improved, and I have been working with Mimecast for more than three years. Overall, Mimecast is a very reliable tool, but there are a few areas where it could be improved, such as the administration experience and the initial setup. The initial page, the homepage of Mimecast, can be improved. The admin console feels a little bit complex and sometimes overwhelming because there are so many policies and definitions. Granular-level settings are spread across different menus. There are around 12 to 13 menus that you need to open and then identify the other things as well. Those things can be improved. The admin console can be improved by making the user interface more modern and intuitive, so that users can easily identify things in the tool. The second improvement is fine-tuning spam and impersonation policies, with some effort put into reducing false positives. These are the two basic feedback points I would make about Mimecast Advanced Email Security from my point of view.
Another needed improvement is customer support, which is a problem we have also faced. Tier 1 support can sometimes feel very slow to provide a resolution. Because of some policies, they were not able to put up the data, and they were not able to identify the root cause. The second thing is that with Mimecast, the complexity of deployment exists only at the initial stage, such as setting up DNS, SPF, DMARC, and DKIM authentication during onboarding for the tool, so that we can get better visibility. In terms of pricing and licensing, it also provides the DMARC analyzer, which is a bit expensive. If those things can be improved, there would be no overall feedback required for Mimecast. Overall, it is the best tool to use for identifying the root cause and identifying phishing happening in your environment, because it provides URL rewriting, which helps users avoid clicking on malicious URLs, and it also helps the security team.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using Mimecast Advanced Email Security for more than three years. I have used this tool in multiple projects. Currently, I am working on MSSP projects in which I handle this tool. I have been working on this tool for more than three years.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
Mimecast Advanced Email Security is a very stable tool. As I mentioned earlier, Mimecast has many advantages. It provides the best data, the original data, and the important data. It reduces false positives and provides the original data that was found to be suspicious or that requires immediate action or attention.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
Mimecast Advanced Email Security provides good scalability, and I would like to mention it here, because it handles growth effortlessly as a complete native, SaaS-based platform. You do not need to worry about adding additional hardware, managing on-premise appliances, or dealing with related details or email traffic spikes. You can add new users, domains, and regional offices in a very straightforward way through AD and cloud directory synchronization. From a performance point of view, it has a long retention period. Mail flow remains fast with zero noticeable latency. URL scanning and attachment sandboxing are also included. It is the best thing.
How are customer service and support?
Overall, the customer support is good. It is supportive, but in some cases it needs to provide the TTR a little bit faster.
I would rate them around 10.
Which solution did I use previously and why did I switch?
We previously used Office 365. The reason for switching to Mimecast is that Microsoft 365 doesn’t provide URL rewriting built into Microsoft Defender. That is one piece of feedback regarding Microsoft 365 and the improvement Mimecast offers. In Microsoft Defender, there is also no policy such as URL Pre-Delivery scanning in the way Mimecast provides that policy. Third, in Defender, we get more false positives. 90% of the alerts were found to be false positives, but in Mimecast, false positives are reduced. It cuts down false positives and triggers an alert only when something is found to be suspicious. If I have to rate Mimecast versus Microsoft Defender, I would choose Mimecast, because it is a better solution and provides more details.
How was the initial setup?
The initial deployment process for Mimecast Advanced Email Security requires planning and coordination because it involves reconfiguring all mail flow routes. In our case, with Microsoft 365, the setup involves updating the MX records, configuring SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication, and setting up mail routing connectors. Working alongside Mimecast onboarding engineers, we have checked that the transition was smooth, with zero downtime for end users. The core rollout takes roughly one or two weeks for us, and the testing part is done in one or two weeks. The biggest part of the initial phase is policy calibration, which means putting the same policies into the tool. We run in monitoring mode to make sure that legitimate workflows, third-party apps, and business partners are not accidentally caught in the hold queue.
Once everything is tuned, ongoing management becomes routine and low maintenance. Day-to-day activity mostly involves reviewing occasionally quarantined messages, and if any mail needs to be reviewed or released from quarantine, we do that. This is how it works. It has decreased the work and made the analysis easier.
What was our ROI?
I have seen a return on investment. As for money saved, I need to check on that part, but as for time saved, it helps in various ways. It helps the analyst analyze things more quickly, and it reduces false positives. As for money saved, I would give a specific example. In terms of return on investment, it reduces security risk and avoids the need to hire additional security headcount, such as additional users and analysts. From an operational point of view, the biggest saving comes from automation. Before Mimecast, our IT team and security team spent roughly eight investigating suspicious emails, identifying suspicious message headers, and purging phishing campaigns from user inboxes after delivery.
Since deployment, Mimecast’s gateway blocking and Targeted Threat Protection have reduced user-reported phishing tickets by around 70 to 80%, saving our team at least 70 to 80% of work, because the system handles triage and remediation automatically. It gives extra time to the analyst. This is the example I would like to give. Overall, it is the best tool, and it reduces analyst fatigue as well. It reduces false positives by 70 to 80%.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
In terms of pricing, setup cost, and licensing, compared to other tools, I have found Mimecast Advanced Email Security to be a good tool. It is not as expensive, but when it comes to licensing, it sits in the premium tier. It is certainly not the cheapest email security solution on the market. Compared to other tools, it provides good ROI, meaning the rate of return on investment is good, and it provides better visibility. On the licensing side, a per-user subscription gives you a good cost. It includes many features, such as cloud archive, DMARC Analyzer, and awareness training, which reduces the need for higher-tier plans.
For cost, there is a modest one-time implementation and onboarding fee to work with the deployment engineers, which is worth it to ensure our DNS and MX records and policies are configured properly with zero downtime. Overall, it is a good tool. The price is higher than some other tools, but the ROI is good, and setup and onboarding costs are reasonable. Renewals are also reasonable.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
As I said, before Mimecast, we had Microsoft 365, and after that, we found that Mimecast Advanced Email Security is the best tool on the market, so we directly chose this tool. We did not choose any other tools. It is the best tool among all the email security tools available. It has the best features and the best retention periods, and it eases the work of the analyst. That is the best thing about this tool.
What other advice do I have?
On a scale of one to 10, I would rate Mimecast Advanced Email Security as a nine.
Overall, based on my experience, my experience with Mimecast Advanced Email Security has been very positive, and it has proven to be one of the most reliable components of our organization, because email remains the number one attack vector for phishing, ransomware, and business email compromise. A resilient gateway in front of our email environment gives both our IT team and executive leadership real peace of mind. Several factors help Mimecast, such as URL rewriting, URL at click, and attachment sandboxing. It consistently blocks sophisticated spoofing, malicious links, and zero-day attachments before they reach the user's inbox. Second, it cuts down spam tickets, helps the help desk team with tickets, and reduces manual post-delivery inbox cleanups. It saves our team hours of work every single week. There is no downtime. Email downtime is not an option for our business, and Mimecast uptime and continuity are ensured. It does not have downtime. This is what I will note here.
It is the best tool on the market to analyze emails, identify true positives, and take actions on appropriate emails. It does URL Protect, Attachment Protect, URL rewriting, and URL pre-delivery scanning. It will reduce your false positives by 70 to 80%, which will help your analysts work on true positive alerts. I advise them to always choose Mimecast Advanced Email Security as their tool for email security.