Executive SummaryUpdated on Sep 16, 2024
Visual Studio Test Professional and Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer are both tools for software testing and requirements management. User reviews indicate that Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer has the upper hand due to its robust features, making it worth the investment.
Features: Visual Studio Test Professional is praised for its integration with other Microsoft products, efficient test case management, and straightforward automation workflows. Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer stands out for its comprehensive requirements modeling, automated test case generation, and advanced requirements traceability. Users find Broadcom's features more extensive and better suited for complex project needs.
Room for Improvement: Users of Visual Studio Test Professional have noted a need for better performance optimization, enhanced flexibility in test automation, and more intuitive user interface design. Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer users have highlighted a steep learning curve, difficulties in initial setup, and a need for more accessible training resources. Despite these issues, Broadcom's more specific critiques suggest it covers broader needs once initial hurdles are overcome.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Visual Studio Test Professional is appreciated for its relatively straightforward deployment, though some users find it time-consuming. Customer service receives mixed reviews, noted for responsiveness but not always effective solutions. Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer's deployment has been described as complex but ultimately rewarding due to its powerful capabilities. Its customer service is known for thorough support and effective assistance, giving it the upper hand in customer satisfaction.
Pricing and ROI: Visual Studio Test Professional users report satisfaction with the cost relative to its capabilities, but some question its ROI given the costs of additional features. Broadcom Agile Requirements Designer is seen as more expensive but justifies this through significant long-term ROI, attributed to its comprehensive feature set and efficiency improvements. Users generally find Broadcom worth the higher initial investment.
