SAP S4HANA on AWS and Google Cloud compete in cloud-based enterprise solutions. SAP S4HANA on AWS seems to have the upper hand in enterprise resource planning due to its robust integration and performance benefits, while Google Cloud is praised for usability and flexible pricing.
Features: SAP S4HANA on AWS distinguishes itself with financial capabilities and process automation, using the HANA database for enhanced speed and efficiency. It offers AI and machine learning capabilities and provides comprehensive module coverage. Google Cloud is known for its ease of use, flexible hosting, and scalability, offering managed services that simplify infrastructure management with a familiar interface.
Room for Improvement: SAP S4HANA on AWS is complex and resource-intensive, with high on-premises hardware costs and integration difficulties. Enhanced technical support and pricing transparency are sought by users. Google Cloud could improve analytics capabilities, multilingual support, and offer more intuitive training resources and smoother integration with external devices.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: SAP S4HANA on AWS offers deployment across various environments but faces slow support response times. Google Cloud is mainly used in public cloud deployments with a straightforward implementation process. While its support is effective, improvements in technical documentation and response clarity would be beneficial.
Pricing and ROI: SAP S4HANA on AWS requires strategic financial planning due to high licensing and hardware costs but delivers robust ROI through operational efficiencies. Google Cloud is recognized for competitive, scalable pricing, appealing to small and medium businesses with flexible pay-as-you-go models, though clearer pricing transparency is desirable.
On a very good implementation, usually, if the scale of the business is large, the implementation can give a payback within six, seven, or eight months of implementation.
Although our investment was higher compared to the previous ERP system, we are able to derive ROI from SAP S4HANA on AWS.
Cloud support directly is not strong, but via partners is strong.
I consider them good partners when it comes to support.
We have consulted Google support several times, and we received a quick response.
We received the right support during our implementation and continue to benefit from it.
They have a support model available, with first-level support handling initial issues when I integrate the system.
If I had to rate scalability from one to ten, I would rate it a nine as we have never faced any issues with scalability.
This solution is suitable for enterprise-level organizations, particularly in finance and healthcare domains where there is substantial data volume.
AWS has been running probably 96% of Fortune 500 companies across the globe, so scalability is not an issue.
The product is versatile and can manage complexity beyond expectations.
As a finance controller, we have seen improvements in finance deliverables, SLAs in payables, and reconciliation timelines.
If the hierarchy or similarities were the same, that would help developers more conveniently migrate from a traditional SQL server to BigQuery.
An area of improvement could be the release of products prior to general availability not being performant, as releasing to private preview occurs too soon before products are ready.
Providing more hypervisors would be beneficial.
SAP introduced flexible workflows, which are even better if I want customized workflows for my documentation within the procurement domain.
The interface and interaction with the technical team require intensive training.
Having these integrations as a single source rather than working in silos would be beneficial for customers.
As far as I know, it is a little more expensive compared to other cloud options.
SAP is not cheap, with many hidden costs encountered during implementation.
The initial setup required a higher investment, but the return on investment has justified the cost.
The most valuable features of Google Cloud for us are the integration with Kubernetes, IAM, Istio integration, and Terraform capabilities.
We mainly use Google Cloud products that are centered around Data Warehouse, specifically BigQuery.
If customers use different technologies within their environment, GCP cannot offer a full performance analysis covering all the disclosures.
From the finance side, we have enhanced our internal controls and reduced the timeline for closing the month from a year to just two days.
The costing and personnel planning integration are among the strongest areas of this solution.
The configurations are quite comprehensive, and the product can handle many complex scenarios.
| Product | Market Share (%) |
|---|---|
| Google Cloud | 6.5% |
| SAP S4HANA on AWS | 3.2% |
| Other | 90.3% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 40 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 8 |
| Large Enterprise | 32 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 19 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 8 |
| Large Enterprise | 15 |
Google Cloud is an Infrastructure as a Service Cloud (IaaS) and Platform as a Service (PaaS) solution that provides infrastructure tools and services for building applications on top of a public cloud computing platform. As one of the leading global infrastructures, this product allows users to securely manage enterprise data, receive valuable insights, and store documents. Google Cloud provides its various services through tools and services for data warehousing, security key enforcement, application programming interface (API) management, artificial intelligence (AI), and machine learning (ML).
The use cases of Google Cloud can be divided into four main categories:
The solution is utilized by organizations of all sizes and industries, as it is suitable for the following purposes:
Google Cloud Features
Google Cloud offers multiple features for its clients. Some of these include:
Google Cloud Benefits
Google Cloud brings various benefits to its users. Some of these include the following:
Reviews from Real Users
Isuru P., an assistant vice president at a tech services company, likes Google Cloud because it is easy to deploy next-generation applications using it.
An IT solutions consultant at a tech services company rates Google Cloud highly because they find the solution stable with a good user experience and a straightforward setup.
SAP customers of all sizes can fully realize all the benefits of the SAP S/4HANA, on-premise edition on the AWS Cloud. With SAP S/4HANA, on-premise edition on the AWS Cloud you can:
We monitor all Infrastructure as a Service Clouds (IaaS) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
