What is our primary use case?
My use case is not extensive because I am using a module of Eightfold. As a financial controller, I am not directly involved in recruitment myself. I have only seen it on someone else's screen, so I am not a good judge of the solution.
What is most valuable?
The main feature I find valuable is the possibility to work with an extensive amount of data. While you can achieve some of this with Excel, it takes much longer to perform calculations.
Power BI processes data differently, efficiently utilizing memory for detailed-level processing. The visual capabilities are another significant advantage over Excel, though Excel continues to improve. Access, however, does not compare in terms of graphical evolutions like those in Qlik.
Furthermore, the potential to use custom add-ons in Power BI is restricted if you do not use native Microsoft products, which is understandable for quality control. Ultimately, the ability to handle large volumes of data and provide dynamic selections is a considerable benefit. In today's data-driven environment, these tools are of substantial value, particularly for large enterprises with numerous processes that require extensive data analysis.
What needs improvement?
Sometimes in Power BI, the logic can be challenging to follow. For example, Access worked well by differentiating between the data and the processes applied to the data, which were clearly separate stages. In many applications, including Excel, you finalize the layout with ease.
With Qlik, though, you are often required to first manipulate data tables before assessing how they look in the report, which might feel counterintuitive to someone accustomed to Access's approach. Access was more logical in how it distinguished between data and its formatting.
Despite this dual-check process feeling odd, once familiar with it, you adapt. I believe maintaining a clearer distinction, like Access, between data handling and formatting would benefit those new to Power BI.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using the solution for about one year, however, not on a daily basis. I started working with a few layouts last year and recently have worked on another layout. I would consider myself a beginner.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
I would rate the stability as a seven out of ten. It's not a bad grade, as I know of better products in this field. However, if starting from nothing, I believe most people would rate it higher.
How are customer service and support?
The significant drawback I notice is that Microsoft's size makes it hard to get specific change requests addressed unless they involve a bug. With smaller suppliers, it's easier to request changes.
Unfortunately, with Microsoft, you must accept the product as it is. I presume there exists a structured first line of support, but I have not used it, so I cannot comment further.
How would you rate customer service and support?
How was the initial setup?
The initial setup is not very easy. Understanding the logic of how to work with that solution takes some time. Unlike Excel, which immediately provides results for input formulas, Power BI requires using DAX code for simple operations, which can be restrictive.
Certain basic tasks, like bolding a column in the middle of a table, are not possible. While it has many impressive capabilities, Excel feels more open and flexible. Excel seldom leaves you with the sense that a function cannot be done. Power BI, however, can feel more limited in that regard.
What was our ROI?
There is a substantial benefit to using Power BI. In a world surrounded by data, tools that allow navigation of large data volumes ensure decisions are data-driven. Investing in such tools has a high value, especially for large companies with numerous processes and data demands. Power BI is strategically essential for analyzing large data sets.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
I must note that Power BI is not as powerful as Qlik, which is a comparable solution offering superior dynamic data selection. Qlik’s filters are more efficient, especially if detailed data filtering is crucial.
Power BI's filters are basic in comparison, and the advanced filters can feel awkward. Therefore, if extensive filtering is needed, I believe Qlik is a better choice.
What other advice do I have?
Overall, I would rate the solution as an eight out of ten.
While Excel has become increasingly capable, making significant improvements, Power BI offers advantages for certain users. Medium-sized companies might find Excel sufficient and of good value. Excel’s evolution with functions like XLOOKUP over VLOOKUP offers ease of use.
Additionally, tools like Copilot bring another dimension of capabilities. Although Excel is not free, it remains a versatile tool. Some achieve excellent dashboard results with it, comparable to Power BI.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
Public Cloud