What is our primary use case?
My main use of HPE ProLiant DL servers is virtualization. During my apprenticeship, we used HPE SimpliVity, with an infrastructure of two HPE SimpliVity 380 Gen10s and an arbiter, which was an ML350, also Gen10. This setup was for VMware virtualization. It was a 5-year contract that ended last year. Given the price increases, the company where I worked, and still work today, left—or half-left—HPE to move to Dell, and left VMware for Proxmox, even though there is still a new HPE DL380 Gen12 server for backups.
For my own sole proprietorship, I also use HPE ProLiant DL servers. At the beginning I had Gen8s and Gen9s, and currently I am on Gen10. I have an HPE DL380 Gen10 coupled with an ML350, also Gen10. They are two compute servers with RAM, CPUs, and storage, which are hyperconverged under Proxmox, currently with DRBD and LINSTOR. Before that, they were running VMware with a vSAN, which has now been removed.
Right now, I have these two servers in hyperconvergence with a third node, which is an older server, an HPE DL360p Gen8, that only serves as quorum for both storage and Proxmox. So the main use is virtualization.
As a concrete virtualization example, I host all my applications and all my tools for my personal infrastructure on these servers. It was the same for my clients, where the whole infrastructure was running on them. My current infrastructure runs on them. So it is mainly virtualization with a hypervisor. We ran them with VMware and Proxmox, and at my clients there was VMware with the SimpliVity solution on top.
How has it helped my organization?
HPE ProLiant DL servers allowed me to run my business and enabled clients to work. In the case of one of my clients, they allowed students to learn on IT tools with thin clients, and the entire infrastructure was running on HPE servers. So basically, they allowed people to work.
I cannot necessarily point to measurable benefits such as time savings, cost reductions, or improved stability with HPE ProLiant DL servers, but I would say I have small time savings and a bit more enjoyment in doing certain tasks that would be annoying on other servers.
What is most valuable?
Everything related to server management with HPE ProLiant DL servers, whether it is iLO, the whole SPP, RAID card management, or iLO configuration, is much more advanced than with competitors. If I take Fujitsu for example, overall it is a nightmare, and RAID card configuration is all done in BIOS mode. I have not tested the very latest iDRAC, but at least up to iLO 5, HPE is a bit above Dell and far above what I know from others such as Fujitsu.
I would say all the hardware management of the server is above the rest, including the boot-up sequence, SPP management, RAID card management, and BIOS and component updates. Everything is much simpler than with the competition in my opinion. That is what makes me personally stick with HPE for my personal infrastructure.
A particular feature that has made my daily work easier is iLO, though competitors offer something similar. iLO and everything related to hardware management, such as RAID card management, is very, very simple with HPE.
What needs improvement?
HPE ProLiant DL servers should continue on their current path. The issues I see now are not necessarily related to HPE but more to the current market, with exploding costs. Otherwise, for my use case and my clients' use cases, we have never really seen a limitation.
There is one point, which I think is in the design of the product, and I may be going a bit out of scope. With SimpliVity, it is almost impossible, without huge costs, to add storage even if you have free slots. You immediately have to go through an approved provider. We did not have any more space, and the solution we were given was that we needed to add a third node. So I would say that with the SimpliVity solution, adding storage in a hyperconverged setup is quite complicated and becomes very expensive very quickly.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have used HPE ProLiant DL servers for 5 years, since my apprenticeship.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
In my current usage, HPE ProLiant DL servers are quite stable. The only problem is with 1U servers, where fans fail very often; it is usually one or two fans to replace per year on a 1U server. Apart from that, they are very stable.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
In my current environment, they are servers, so if you want to scale them, it is mainly on the software side afterwards, on the hypervisor side to build clusters. They are scalable, as with any other servers, without too many issues, except if you go with solutions such as SimpliVity, where it is much more complicated.
How are customer service and support?
My overall impression of the customer support for HPE ProLiant DL servers is average. They send parts within the agreed timeframes. However, they do not necessarily take the opinion of the professionals, the clients, into account. For example, for SimpliVity, they sent us a network card three times even though we were explaining that it was the GBIC and asking which GBIC we should take. They sent us three network cards and dispatched an engineer who did not understand anything, who just blindly swapped out the network card, and that was it. So for simple tasks it is fine, but as soon as it gets a bit more complex, the service is less good.
Which solution did I use previously and why did I switch?
I have worked on Dell and Fujitsu servers, because those were the servers some clients already had. Personally, as I mentioned earlier, I find that HPE is a bit above in terms of hardware management with SPP, RAID card management, and more. They are a little bit above Dell, even though I have not dealt with the very latest Dell generations, so I do not know if they have caught up for equivalent modern generations. Compared to Fujitsu, HPE is far ahead.
What was our ROI?
With HPE ProLiant DL servers, I have seen time savings in overall server management.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
The price, installation costs, and license management for HPE ProLiant DL servers have been fairly reasonable. The problem is that today we are in a very, very, very difficult period where everything is expensive. We have contracts that over 5 years have quadrupled, going from 300,000-euro contracts to 2-million-euro contracts. So in terms of costs, it is very complicated at the moment, but that is the market.
Beyond that, I think that given the price we pay for the servers, iLO should not require an additional license once the iLO chip is present in the server. That is my opinion on that.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
Before choosing HPE ProLiant DL servers, I mainly evaluated Dell.
What other advice do I have?
I would give HPE ProLiant DL servers an 8 out of 10.
The reasoning behind my rating of 8 is that among all the servers I have worked with, they are, in my opinion, the easiest to operate and the most stable. Nothing is perfect, of course. But in my view, it is the server brand I favor and the one I find easiest and prefer to work with.
HPE ProLiant DL servers are deployed on-premises in our organization. Everything is in our server rooms, in our premises.
HPE ProLiant DL servers are simple to use and very reliable.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
On-premises