Coming October 25: PeerSpot Awards will be announced! Learn more

SAP ERP or Dynamics AX?

Have you compared SAP and Microsoft's ERP solutions for the process industry, or specifically for pharmaceutical businesses?

PeerSpot user
9 Answers
PeerSpot user
User at a pharma/biotech company
06 January 15

SAP with its other acquired applications (APO/ Business Objects /LPO/MII / ME) definitely provides lot more functionality in diverse / complex / automated ISA95 based manufacturing environment and also has a lot of open potential for diverse manufacturing models in Planning & execution. Standard SAP ERP is well suited for low complex manufacturing (pharma packaging, Medical device etc..), but for a complex manufacturing (biologics or API MFG) you will need a MES and additional (MOMS) manufacturing operations management system
AX is an excellent application for a low complexity manufacturing (packaging, medical devices, simple chemical processing etc..) environment.. Some of the complex planning and complex manufacturing execution processes will need third party application, which are not as tightly integrated as SAP.
Below comparison is based on basic ERP of SAP and AX. IF CRM/APO/BO/ME/MII etc is added there is no comparison.. The below comparison is only between ECC & AX
Operator delight (manufacturing) – AX is better than SAP
Customer Delight (sales management) – AX is better than SAP
Vendor delight (Procurement Management) – AX is better than SAP
Validation Documentation – SAP has more knowledge depth than AX
Low complexity Manufacturing – No Major difference between AX or SAP
Integration to third party – SAP is better than AX
Knowledge and resources – SAP has a lot more than AX
ROI – AX is a much better then SAP

As far as FDA 21 CFR Part 11 validation is concerned, you would find lot more knowledge and resources for SAP than AX, but the effort of documentation and testing will be the same.

SAP has a lot more vendors providing FDA 21 CFR Part 11 validation services than AX and the quality of those resources is very, very mature. AX does not have that industry expertise depth

Lot of SAP vendors have developed accelerators for validation, which have gone through test of time and there are vendors who have developed SAP centric applications to fill SAP deficiency GAP (EX: Weigh & Dispense, recipe Authoring, Equipment/labor validation, container management etc..)

In my current situation the company has selected AX over SAP. The decision was purely based on cost and complexity of manufacturing.. There are certain industries which do not need the complexity of SAP, AX is a very good solution. CIO of this company looked the functionality needed for next 5 years and did an excellent job by focusing his ROI on customer delight and operational efficiency. “bad for my career but good for company bottom line”

PeerSpot user
CEO at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
19 October 15

Back in 1999 JD Edwards made a strategic decision to align with the top software providers for Pharma, and that decision has carried JDE forward into 2015. I would point out that the new inventory functionality in EnterpriseOne 9.2 will dramatically improve the process manufacturing requirements.

Oracle's JD Edwards EnterpriseOne has robust functionality for process manufacturing. From a cost basis, versus SAP, JD Edwards wins every time.

AX has limited functionality and will require customization the JD Edwards delivers off the shelf. This is not to say that you won't have some level of customization in JD Edwards; it will be significantly less customization than AX and will be easier to manage at an organizational level.

06 January 15

SAP is good for manufacturing and so many clients are using the SAP for
process industry
Here we use SAP for process orders execution and other components
integration of manufacturing industry

I don't have any exp on Microsoft ERP

PeerSpot user
Director at Infor
Real User
05 January 15

I worked for both SAP and Microsoft Dynamics. Many years ago there was a partnership to make AX FDA compliant, but that did not go very far. AX today has basic process manufacturing capabilities and strong globalization support, but it is not a good fit for a highly regulated industry in my opinion. SAP has strong presence in Pharma and is arguably the best solution to enforce compliance, but it comes at the cost of flexibility and cost.

Regarding other people's suggestions on JD Edwards... I agree that JD Edwards is potentially a good fit for pharma, but I would be concerned about the future roadmap here. With Fusion as the future solution, I would be concerned about the roadmap of JD Edwards.

Besides functional requirements, make sure you look at vendor viability and the role the solution plays in that vendor's portfolio. You will run this product 10-15 years, so make sure the product has a large and growing install base and a thriving ecosystem of consultants and complementary solutions. How large is your company? Do you have multi-national operations? How many sites? Will this solution be your corporate ERP? Good luck with your selection process! I don't envy you.

PeerSpot user
Senior Account Manager at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
05 January 15

I used to sell Dynamics and currently sell SAP as well as another ERP developed for the Pharma Industry.
Hands down from cost, stability, and design this ERP is the one to look at : video If you need help please give me a call at 708 743 2024 Thanks Joe:

PeerSpot user
Consultant at a tech services company
05 January 15

The most cost effective solution with best functionality would be Oracle's JD Edwards.
If you are going with SAP or Microsoft Dynamics without considering JD Edwards then you are not doing justice with yourself.

A number of top pharmaceutical companies are using JD Edwards.

Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft Dynamics AX vs. SAP ERP and other solutions. Updated: September 2022.
635,513 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Content at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Community Manager
05 January 15

Hi Farukh- can you share with the community what you found? Did you choose to implement one of the solutions?


PeerSpot user
User at a pharma/biotech company
05 January 15


Sydney Chidambaram - PeerSpot reviewer
Consultant at a government with 1,001-5,000 employees
05 January 15


I have not compared SAP and Microsoft, you could look at Oracle's JD Edwards,

Related Questions
User at Hijazi Ghosheh Group
Feb 08, 2022
Hello community,  I've been looking at the following 2 products: SAP Business One and SAP ERP. What are the limitations of SAP Business One that should make me choose SAP ERP, instead? Thanks for your help!
See 1 answer
Amritanshu NEHRA - PeerSpot reviewer
User at
08 February 22
Hi all within SAP there are two products:  SAP Business One and SAP S/4 HANA SAP Business One as per SAP is for Small and Medium Enterprises and SAP S/4 Hana - is for Large enterprises SAP Business One (as per SAP) is an entry-level product with limited functionality like sales, purchase, AR, AP, MRP, Inventory Production and project management and the rest of the functionality is done through customization wherein  SAP S/4 Hana has a full-blown module related to large organization MM (Material Management), FICO (Finance and Costing), PP (Production Planning),  PS Project system and can be customized as per the requirement with large user login. Cost for both systems has a big difference: Business One is approx. starting at $160K for 10 users and SAP S/4 Hana starts at $ 700K for 10 users. Hope that answers the query.
Netanya Carmi - PeerSpot reviewer
Content Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Nov 09, 2021
See 2 answers
James Myers - PeerSpot reviewer
Founder and CEO at FP&A Strategy Consulting
13 October 21
SAP ERP and Anaplan serve different purposes and actually work well together.   Think of SAP ERP focused on the Actuals, while Anaplan models the future. The reason why I’ve seen clients use Anaplan for planning vs. SAP BPC is Anaplan is more flexible and can easily keep up with constant changes in business planning.  While BPC is more of a consolidation tool, with Anaplan you can also have your driver-based models in a system vs. running them offline and only putting the answer into a system.   Therefore, my recommendation is to use both.
Janet Staver - PeerSpot reviewer
Tech Blogger
09 November 21
There are different aspects of both Anaplan and SAP ERP that I like and dislike. Anaplan improves forecast accuracy and drives up the quality of analytics. Rather than spending all of their time consolidating numbers into one space, employees can reshift their focus to deep-diving into the numbers, which is a huge advantage because it frees them up to do more value-added work instead. I also like that Analplan is a collaborative solution - it makes building out forecasts and modeling data much easier than just using Excel because it is in the cloud and is more structured. Anaplan is also very well connected. For example, data from one use case can be used in other models. Moreso, if a change is made to one model, it will be changed in all other models as well. Although Anaplan requires a slight learning curve and some training, initial setup is fairly easy. And for the times where you have technical questions, I have found that support is adequate. However, Anaplan is quite expensive. Nevertheless, I am very impressed with the stability of the solution and its performance. Not only that, but I am impressed by its ability to scale phenomenally. SAP ERP has been recognized as the best solution in the class of ERP products. In addition, it provides excellent visibility into the details of enterprise resource planning. Like Anaplan, it is very scalable. I think one of the best features SAP ERP has to offer is the claim management. One disadvantage is that you cannot easily create customizations. Also, outside of the SAP for RPA it is required for you to use an additional solution on a platform as a service if you want to extend the solutions. Another downside is that the initial setup is not straightforward and can be quite complex, so you have to be prepared to handle that. Conclusion: Overall, I would give Anaplan a 9 out of 10 rating. Anaplan has many more advantages for me than SAP ERP and since both options are very pricey, Anaplan takes the win because I like that it has so much more to offer.
Related Articles
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Jan 25, 2022
Hi peers, Spotlight #6 is our fresh bi-weekly community digest. It helps you catch up on recent contributions by community members. Please comment below with your feedback about our new brand name and this Spotlight!  Trending Top RPA trends and forecasts that will help boost the technology-driven sector in 2022 and beyond What are your top Extended Detection and Response (XDR) pr...
See 2 comments
reviewer1577907 - PeerSpot reviewer
Manager at PeerSpot
24 January 22
Thank you for this helpful post and congratulations on the new company name!
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
25 January 22
@Shibu Babuchandran ​and @Dominic-Gopal, thank you for contributing your articles!
Marketing Manager at MIE Solutions
Mar 01, 2021
Shop floor management with improved capabilities is an important component of the manufacturing industry. This makes it vital for manufacturers to have centralized systems and the best ERP software is the ideal choice in this regard. The main purpose of shop floor management is to increase and sustain the production quality and efficiency. Today’s rising trend of digitization calls for ident...
Gene Hammons, MBA - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at a consultancy with 1-10 employees
Nov 16, 2020
Over the past few months, political coverage reminded me of a Winston Churchill quote – “A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get it’s pants on”. Living in a world of competing politicians and contentious media, there were seemingly plenty of lies for both sides to yelp about. I thanked my lucky stars that in the business of ERP, we don’t deal in lies as the c...
Related Articles
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Jan 25, 2022
Community Spotlight #6 by PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Hi peers, Spotlight #6 is our fresh bi-weekly community digest. It helps you catch up on recent ...
Marketing Manager at MIE Solutions
Mar 01, 2021
ERP Helps Improve Shop Floor Management & Productivity
Shop floor management with improved capabilities is an important component of the manufacturing...