We performed a comparison between JD Edwards EnterpriseOne and SAP S/4HANA based on real PeerSpot user reviews.Find out in this report how the two ERP solutions compare in terms of features, pricing, service and support, easy of deployment, and ROI.
"We did not have any problems with the scalability of JD Edwards EnterpriseOne."
"The solution is stable."
"It is easy to inquire about any account in our company."
"I have found the solutions best features to be financial procurement, inventory, and manufacturing."
"With the new versions, it has become very user-friendly. We have integration with mobiles, and we have cloud-based solutions. There are a lot of things that can be done by front-end users without technical knowledge. They can create reports without having to do any coding, and it's very good now."
"The solution can scale."
"It is highly configurable. You have a choice in terms of how you want to run it. You can run it in your own data center, in a private cloud, or in a public cloud. The choice is really up to the customer."
"JD Edwards EnterpriseOne's most valuable feature is its one consolidated platform that runs all the different aspects of companies."
"Because I'm a procure-to-pay consultant, I mostly look at that angle, and I have a bit of experience with sales and distribution. I also like the integration between S/4HANA and other ERPs because S/4HANA is a suite. For example, the integration between S/4HANA and EWM Transportation Management, and Ariba."
"The most valuable feature is that HANA loads from memory, which means it loads very quickly."
"At present, it seems very stable because it is in the cloud."
"S4HANA is relatively stable."
"The most valuable feature of SAP S/4HANA is the innovational process. We are able to receive more efficiency or accuracy than previous versions."
"The key modules that I find most valuable are material management (MM), financial accounting and controlling (FICO), and human resources (HR)."
"SAP S4HANA version 1909 is stable. We have not gone live with 2020 yet."
"It is really fast. It is also very stable."
"They have been improving it every day, but it could have more automation."
"The flexibility of workflows and multi-industry implementation support should be improved."
"JD Edwards EnterpriseOne is more of a legacy solution because most of the competitors are or have moved to the cloud. It would be beneficial if there was a cloud version available. Additionally, the interface could improve."
"They have the interface with Hubble and other reporting, however, we just want that to be a part of JD Edwards."
"Something that could be included is a supply chain management system. That's what we're looking for."
"The reporting has to be flexible or it will turn the end-user off."
"Treasury management is typically used in forex, loans, trade management and property management is not available. The solution could improve if they added them."
"We originally used EnterpriseOne for preventative maintenance, but it is not very good at that so we migrated to Maximo for that task."
"The product's use of resources could be improved, as it is quite intensive at the moment."
"The migration to SAP S/4HANA is hard."
"You will not see convenient user experiences with SAP S4HANA's website or application."
"SAP S4HANA is not suitable for all-size companies. If you have a small company there are better fit solutions for your needs."
"I would like to see the AI included to help from a data standpoint."
"The initial setup could be better. They can make the process a little easier. The functions that we require will be available in the next release. We specifically need a new model, and I think we have some versions to implement. I already read on the SAP website that some functionalities we are waiting for are available in this new version."
"This product would be improved by adding more reports."
"An area for improvement would be integration with different kinds of legacies. In the next release, I would like the product to be prepared for blockchain technology and the best way to communicate with social networking."
SAP S4HANA is an ERP (enterprise resource planning) system that uses sophisticated technologies including machine learning and AI. It is most commonly used to integrate and manage business functions and is an ideal solution for large enterprises. The platform includes supplier relationship management (SRM), customer relationship management (CRM), supply chain management (SCM), and product lifecycle management (PLM) functionality.
SAP S4HANA offers three different deployment options:
SAP S4HANA Features
SAP S4HANA has many valuable key features, including:
SAP S4HANA Benefits
Some of the benefits of using SAP S4HANA include:
Reviews from Real Users
Below are some reviews and helpful feedback written by SAP S4HANA users.
A Mechanical Engineer at a construction company says, “It is a very powerful, highly customizable tool. The most valuable feature is that the reporting is fast. We can see the results from that in that our commissions come in fast. That is the main advantage.”
Another reviewer, a SAP Technology Manager at a financial services firm, mentions, "It is more or less a very, very smooth and seamless product. Day by day they are increasing their technology features and they are keen to resolve the issues. India has a complex business scenario and SAP is thinking about that and resolving the issues day by day. In terms of the features I have found most valuable, I don't think that there is any lack or any gap process-wise. SAP is a very good tool."
A Project and Service delivery Manager at a tech services company comments, "One of the most valuable features, which we used the most, was the FI module, for finance. It involved controlling, account receivables, account payables, and complete financial steering."
A Senior Architect at a construction company states, “The POD applications are very useful to us. There are a few POD apps which we are using for different business scenarios. They are quite interesting.” He also adds, “The initial setup is pretty straightforward. The documentation is very good. The solution can scale well. The solution is stable.”
JD Edwards EnterpriseOne is ranked 6th in ERP with 19 reviews while SAP S/4HANA is ranked 1st in ERP with 48 reviews. JD Edwards EnterpriseOne is rated 8.0, while SAP S/4HANA is rated 8.2. The top reviewer of JD Edwards EnterpriseOne writes "Offers a variety of features, easy to use and understand, reasonably priced, and has responsive technical support". On the other hand, the top reviewer of SAP S/4HANA writes "Smooth and seamless product with flexible licensing models". JD Edwards EnterpriseOne is most compared with JD Edwards World, Oracle E-Business Suite, SAP ERP, Oracle ERP Cloud and Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, whereas SAP S/4HANA is most compared with SAP Business One, Oracle ERP Cloud, SAP ERP, NetSuite ERP and Infor LN. See our JD Edwards EnterpriseOne vs. SAP S/4HANA report.
See our list of best ERP vendors.
We monitor all ERP reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.