No more typing reviews! Try our Samantha, our new voice AI agent.

CA Risk Authentication [EOL] vs Symantec Advanced Authentication comparison

Why PeerSpot?
Sponsored
 

Comparison Buyer's Guide

Executive Summary

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:
 

Categories and Ranking

Cisco Duo
Sponsored
Average Rating
8.8
Reviews Sentiment
6.6
Number of Reviews
176
Ranking in other categories
Single Sign-On (SSO) (5th), Authentication Systems (2nd), Access Management (5th), ZTNA as a Service (2nd), Cisco Security Portfolio (1st), Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) (1st), AI Data Analysis (7th)
CA Risk Authentication [EOL]
Average Rating
7.0
Number of Reviews
3
Ranking in other categories
No ranking in other categories
Symantec Advanced Authentic...
Average Rating
7.8
Reviews Sentiment
8.7
Number of Reviews
9
Ranking in other categories
Authentication Systems (22nd)
 

Featured Reviews

Johnson Nejo - PeerSpot reviewer
Technical Support Analyst at FBC Farm and Small Business Tax Consultants
Security has improved for confidential tax data and users access systems safely every day
One issue I see is when the device is offline. When the device is offline, sometimes people struggle to get in. If they don't have internet access on their device and Cisco Duo push works with internet access and connectivity, it sends a push to the cell phone. If the cell phone is offline, they are not able to get in. In that case, they need to find a way to reach out to the help desk or IT for IT to bypass them or find a solution. The reason why I don't see that as a big deal is because it is the way it is designed. Everything needs internet to work. It is not the fault of the developers that the users don't have internet on their device. The only thing is, maybe if they can probably innovate that area where regardless of internet access on your device or not, you are still able to get in. Or you still get that push or however you still get the prompt on the device, on your cell phone to be able to log in. We have seen a couple of tickets where people don't have internet access, maybe someone is in airplane mode or they are in a hotel and they cannot get into the hotel WiFi on their laptop. Because of that, if they are not registered for offline access, they don't get into their laptop. When we started, I remember if you tried to put in your password, then in a couple of seconds you would get a Cisco Duo push on your phone and then once you approved, it would take you in. I remember when we started, sometimes when the Cisco Duo push got to your phone, if you did not accept it within sixty seconds, it would ask you to repeat that process again. I think that time frame, if it can be reduced to like two minutes, would be great. I know it is for security reasons, since OTPs expire within a very short time frame. But for it to invalidate after sixty seconds, I think it is too short. Sometimes your phone might not be with you. Sometimes your phone might be in the other room and you are looking for it. So you put in your password and you are expecting to accept the prompt in sixty seconds. So if that can be maybe put to like ninety seconds or more, that could be good.
it_user351696 - PeerSpot reviewer
Software Development Manager at a comms service provider with 1,001-5,000 employees
It gives us the ability to deny authentications for known malicious traffic. We're having issues scaling it as well as SiteMinder.
The benefits are that it allows us to have real-time risk analysis on authentication traffic, so we can determine whether or not it's suspicious. How suspicious is it? If it's suspicious, we can enable step-up authentication and challenge for some additional credentials, or we can block the authentication attempt completely. If it's a known good customer, we can actually remove the friction of authentication, or even automatically authenticate them without challenging their credentials. That aspect has been working well, even at the expense of causing some latency for authentication for everybody else because of the amount of traffic we're getting.
Umair (Abu Mohaymin) Akhlaque - PeerSpot reviewer
Group CEO at Flexsolutions
Ensures robust security features and ease of deployment, although it may lack some of the more modern authentication options
There has been a need for aggressive development to modernize the product and align it with contemporary security requirements. While the rebranding has been a step forward, further enhancements are essential to meet the evolving demands of the market. It lacks features such as ActiveSync Exchange security, and it doesn't offer alternatives like password-less authentication via biometrics or patches. While Symantec mainly relies on traditional token-based or password-based methods, newer authentication methods are missing from its repertoire. Support services often lack promptness and depth of knowledge, leaving customers waiting for weeks to resolve issues. In the realm of multifactor authentication, swift resolution of problems is critical, as any slowdown or interruption can significantly impact operations. Urgent improvement is necessary to ensure that support responses are faster and more effective, aligning with the demands of MFA implementation.

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:
 

Pros

"Cisco Duo benefits my organization because we do not have too many logins since everything is in one place and we can use Cisco Duo for VPN, applications, and cloud solutions."
"Cisco Duo has improved my operational efficiency and reduced costs in areas such as authentication, IT support, and security operations significantly."
"For me, the biggest return on investment when using Cisco Duo is my time."
"The ease of deploying Cisco Duo Security and onboarding has greatly benefited our customers."
"What I appreciate most about Cisco Duo are the security features it brings to our network environment and machine access."
"All features of the solution are effective, particularly those involved in identifying vulnerabilities and updates."
"Cisco Duo has helped my organization reduce its overall authentication-related costs."
"Cisco Duo has benefited our company overall by giving us the ability to have multi-factor authentication."
"The benefits are that it allows us to have real-time risk analysis on authentication traffic, so we can determine whether or not it's suspicious, enable step-up authentication and challenge for additional credentials or block the attempt completely, and if it's a known good customer, we can remove the friction of authentication or even automatically authenticate them without challenging their credentials."
"With RiskMinder, we have seen a reduction in malicious attacks by at least 75%, and we've only implemented a few rules so far."
"In addition to password authentication, we use it for anomaly detection to understand the risk of someone not having a username password that is theirs."
"Symantec Advanced Authentication can be useful for wherever you require a strong authentication."
"One of the most valuable features of this solution is that it's a strong authentication solution that's able to integrate with applications."
"It actually increases our revenue and the customer base."
"The most valuable feature is that we get a wide range of authentication methods and authentication integrators, so different platforms can get service authentication with transparency to the final user while providing strong authentication forms and connectors."
"CA products are the best fit with our backend systems."
"Rules on Risk Authentication are very good."
"Ease of deployment: no need to keep up with physical devices for multi-factor authentication; no software to deploy on end-user computers requiring administrative rights."
"One of the most valuable aspects is its remarkable stability."
 

Cons

"It is easy to use when logging in, but at times, there's a delay in getting the pop-up on a phone, requiring users to occasionally retry authentication depending on backend services."
"However, I need to look into Cisco Duo; I had not realized they had an email aspect."
"General announcements when new features come out with Cisco Duo should be broadcasted to customers who are using it, which might bring more accessibility to their documents so users can be more in tune with updates."
"Regarding the Premier licensing, it is a little bit pricey, but it is in the market range with the competitors."
"While two-factor authentication with mobile devices provides a high level of security, it's still not foolproof, as someone could potentially steal your phone. It would be beneficial to have information about the authentication location."
"There is always room for improvement."
"I think Cisco Duo could be improved by including email authentication, as there is currently only SMS, SMS push, and code generation, but having email authentication could be beneficial when you don't have a phone."
"I would appreciate seeing Cisco Duo improved with a tighter integration with Active Directory to secure not just Remote Desktop to a server, but all the remote levels of connection that you can make to a server."
"But one of the things that we noticed is that it does at times impact performance when it's not supposed to."
"I think one of the issues is that there are limited people who understand the product; it's a fairly new product and expertise may be light."
"Make sure you scale for at least five times your actual load. We're having issues getting it to scale as well as SiteMinder."
"The initial setup of the tenant is a big cost element of the service and we were doing multiple tenants for our customer."
"Arcot itself is based on a browser technology. This means that the office ID is effectively stored as a cookie in the browser."
"Urgent improvement is necessary to ensure that support responses are faster and more effective, aligning with the demands of MFA implementation."
"They definitely need to automate a few processes like the Wiley process."
"Advanced Authentication talks about the Device ID. But how the device ID is captured, I want to know more about that."
"Symantec has very bad support, so I have no words for it. It's one of the worst support experiences I've ever had."
"It needs faster implementation on the cloud for our customers."
"We have seen quite a few issues with bugginess. It is indeed pretty buggy and we have had to install some fixes."
 

Pricing and Cost Advice

"The licensing is very good because it does not cost a lot of money. It's affordable for all-sized customers, including enterprises. There is an additional cost for premium support."
"It has a fair pricing model. I know they have different tiers, but it would be nice to have different types of licenses for certain groups of users in our organization. That way, we wouldn't have to lump everybody into one group. That would be also one complaint."
"It's a bit confusing because we're on a three-year plan with a certain number of licenses, and we've gone over that number. They told us that when we renew, they will add all these licenses. We've expanded quickly, so everyone's kind of scared because no one knows what the bill is with the long pricing cycle."
"My experience with the pricing, setup cost, and licensing of Cisco Duo has been great. We've been there for 10 years. While we haven't gone through the setup part for a while, licensing is straightforward and convenient for higher education because student populations are included. So, we don't have to pay extra for it. We just pay for our knowledge workers, which has been great, and the cost is reasonable."
"Cisco has the most expensive products because market leaders tend to charge a lot."
"It was very reasonable."
"Cisco's licensing is always a bit complicated to understand, but the price is fair. It could be more expensive than others, but the way they integrate everything, it has a fair price."
"Overall, the pricing is fair. Customers can wrap it into their Enterprise Agreement, making it easier for them to solve their issues."
Information not available
"There are eventually going to be implementation costs. Sometimes you're required to have custom code developments there, so that has to be part of the implementation price."
"The price is reasonable."
report
Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Authentication Systems solutions are best for your needs.
922,921 professionals have used our research since 2012.
 

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews
Outsourcing Company
12%
Financial Services Firm
11%
Comms Service Provider
9%
Manufacturing Company
9%
No data available
Financial Services Firm
15%
Construction Company
15%
Outsourcing Company
14%
Manufacturing Company
11%
 

Company Size

By reviewers
Large Enterprise
Midsize Enterprise
Small Business
By reviewers
Company SizeCount
Small Business66
Midsize Enterprise29
Large Enterprise93
No data available
By reviewers
Company SizeCount
Small Business2
Large Enterprise7
 

Questions from the Community

How does Duo Security compare with Microsoft Authenticator?
We switched to Duo Security for identity verification. We’d been using a competitor but got the chance to evaluate Du...
What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for Duo Security?
Regarding the pricing, what actually happened was that we got the product purchased through our HQ, so the costing as...
What needs improvement with Duo Security?
I do not have a straight answer for how Cisco Duo can be improved at this time. With the implementation that we are g...
Ask a question
Earn 20 points
Ask a question
Earn 20 points
 

Also Known As

Duo Security
CA RiskMinder
CA Advanced Authentication, CA Strong Authentication, CA Risk Authentication, Arcot WebFort, Arcot RiskFort
 

Overview

 

Sample Customers

Information Not Available
Global bank based in the United States
Global bank, Large Filipino Bank and SK Infosec
Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft, Cisco, Okta and others in Authentication Systems. Updated: October 2026.
922,921 professionals have used our research since 2012.