What is our primary use case?
My main use case for F5 Advanced WAF is providing deployment solutions for financial institutions and onboarding their applications on the solution itself. I perform fine-tunings on their solution based on the type of application services that they are hosting on the WAF and also based on traffic behaviors. I provide them with appropriate solutions and tuning requirements for the solution itself.
I deployed F5 Advanced WAF in one of the top-tier commercial banks of Nepal, and I have deployed it in more than two or three banks here. The deployment went from a proof-of-concept state to the deployment stage. Initially, I deployed the proof-of-concept product and tested it on some of their proof-of-concept applications. After that, I deployed it for the production applications. I gradually kept it under tuning and overall monitoring, and after learning the traffic behavior, I moved it to enforcement mode while turning on the blocking part. Initially it started with a monitoring phase and eventually turned into the blocking phase where it starts to protect applications against real attacks.
What is most valuable?
F5 Advanced WAF offers excellent configurability, and you have all the things in your hand that you want to configure for it. It starts from overall network level things to how a web application should be developed, for example, how an HTTP request should be created from the backend itself and how it is made an RFC compliant HTTP request. I can tune the configuration and security configurations based on each very minute content or minute context details. I can fine-tune my policy to act upon very specific parameters on very specific URLs and very specific headers.
Even if I get false positives, I can disable it for very specific contexts in an HTTP request and not on the whole application level because disabling a signature on a whole application level might not be that secure or recommended as it might cause false positives on specific input endpoints or on a specific area. The same kind of attack signature or the same kind of attack may be executed in another part of the same application which is covered by a single policy in itself. The level of configurability that I get with F5 Advanced WAF solution is immense, and I have to be a bit aware of how it works and all of its features, but at the end of the day, it is all about the administration expertise that I will require to have and use it to my liking based on the kind of services that I have onboarded on my solution itself.
F5 Advanced WAF has positively impacted my organization by providing immense visibility of the application traffic itself and how it protects against attacks that are prevailing in the application. The threat intelligence and threat campaigning feature that F5 provides allows their in-house threat intelligence team to research regularly and provide updates based on real-time or near zero-day attacks. The IP intelligence databases that it provides and the many other things F5 provides are something that I believe every organization should have in their security budget or security architecture. I think it is something that is a must-have solution. It does not matter if it is F5 or any other solution, but it should be enough to protect an organization from the threats that are prevalent in these generations, which require a really complicated solution itself, and F5 is one of them.
What needs improvement?
On the features I wish existed, Big-IP Advanced WAF is primarily an on-premises solution and in that solution, there are not enough features that need to be there to protect API-based applications. F5 somehow tends to force clients to go for a cloud WAF solution where it provides a solution for API security at least at some granular level, but Big-IP Advanced WAF in itself does not provide a complete API security solution. There could be a bit more of an easier way that I could configure things, and the resources that F5 provides should be freely available. Maybe some training and many other things regarding application-specific configurations and all those things would help. It is fine in itself, but the main thing that I wish should be there or it would be great if it was there is the API security solution that was supposed to be there in Big-IP Advanced WAF itself but which is not completely there. Only the basic features are there.
F5 Advanced WAF can be improved by including some features that need to be included regarding API security solutions and all, but as of now, it is improving and it will keep on improving. It is fine for now, but it is improving itself. If some of the features that I mentioned above are integrated into the application or the solution itself, then it will be good to go.
Regarding the needed improvements, it would be better if F5 Advanced WAF could have some professional-level training and some curated training and not just paywall-backed training, but some free-of-cost training that administrators can access and complete. F5 itself provides a good amount of knowledge base articles and documentation and a help menu in the solution itself in the user interface. It is not that tough, but it could have been a bit more easier.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using F5 Advanced WAF for around two years.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
F5 Advanced WAF is pretty stable. It faced a persistent attack on the F5 company itself and some part of the F5 source code was hacked as per the news, but besides that, F5 is stable. The newer updates are coming up and they offer even more good options.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
F5 Advanced WAF is pretty scalable. I can have multiple solutions or multiple instances running or I can run it in HA mode or even divide the traffic volume to the number of instances that I have based on their resource sizing. I can prioritize traffic also. So it is pretty scalable.
How are customer service and support?
The customer support for F5 Advanced WAF is fine in itself, though a bit late, but on priority they come in time, so it is not that bad. It is good enough.
How would you rate customer service and support?
Which solution did I use previously and why did I switch?
I do not use a WAF solution in my end itself, but I do provide that solution to others. I have used FortiWeb and Imperva and Traceable to provide solutions to clients, but as of now, the on-premises solution is primarily F5, which is a bit better in this case. Imperva and Akamai are there if they provide on-premises solutions, but it is good enough in itself for now, at least.
What was our ROI?
In terms of return on investment with F5 Advanced WAF, if an administrator is good enough in operating a WAF solution, then a single administrator would work. The amount of attacks it protects against is immense, more than F5 Advanced WAF itself costs. So it is worth it to have.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
The pricing for F5 Advanced WAF is a bit higher, but not that high. I would say for a good amount of revenue-generating organization, it is a worthwhile investment, but it is not that easily accessible for small and medium-sized enterprises. The licensing and setup cost require some setup manpower that is technical, so there might be some pricing involved, but I cannot name the pricing itself. It is pretty steep.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
On-premises
If public cloud, private cloud, or hybrid cloud, which cloud provider do you use?
Other