What is our primary use case?
I have experience with Cisco products as I implement a lot of them. For example, I implemented switches and access points when I worked for infrastructure in a motorcycle company, and I implemented 199 wireless Cisco access points for a hospital.
I also implemented Cisco Meraki MX and Meraki VMX when I worked for NS BlueScope. For the office zone and IT zone, we separated the IT and OT segments. I implemented Meraki for IT, but we used Cisco for OT.
I am still working with both products. I work with Meraki for the IT side, but I also use Cisco access points for the OT side.
I do implement Meraki switches because I work as an infrastructure security engineer. When I worked for NS BlueScope, I made a change because almost all of the switch office zone reached end of service for Cisco switches. Then I changed to Meraki for all IT areas.
What is most valuable?
From a security view, Meraki MS Switches are easy to patch because normal Cisco switches are very hard to patch or update IOS. With Meraki MS Switches, I can set up auto patching when usable. For example, I can set patching and auto patching at midnight.
I use the Zero-Touch Provisioning feature for security and try to use Zero-Touch for IT security. Zero-Touch Provisioning helps streamline my deployments by ensuring that every system does not trust anybody or anything, requiring identification and authentication while implementing MFA. Every request includes not only external but also internal network traffic, which I have to declare for verification by using authentication.
My assessment of Layer 7 application visibility on my network management strategy indicates that I attach to normally connecting and implementing everything on Layer 7, but sometimes I have to choose lower layers of the seven-layer model.
Network access controls have helped enhance security. I use role-based access control by role-based access permission. I have to implement authorization for permission, and every owner has to allow access. I create policies and steps for requests for access from different departments.
I evaluate the benefit of virtual stacking in managing my network switches by using VLAN for implementing segmentation because many companies have security issues. This is the best practice for separating segmentation for each level. For example, most companies need to separate IT from OT side and implement deep segmentation from OT. I have to separate production to protect security. I use VLAN because micro-segmentation can be very complex and require upgrading hardware. However, it is an easy way to implement segmentation using firewalls for each level for security reasons.
Network cost and sustainability impact my network cost. I have experience implementing greenfield projects. Normally, I design redundant core switches to distribution switches using star mesh and redundant links, sometimes utilizing EtherChannel in Cisco switches for redundancy. For example, I implement EtherChannel from distribution switches to access switches for redundant links for robustness if any link breaks.
What needs improvement?
Meraki MS Switches are easy to manage, but I believe they are more suitable for use on the IT side because Meraki faces the internet, requiring an open connection through the internet for control. It is not the same as Cisco switches, which operate via command line. I normally use command line for configuration, while Meraki utilizes a cloud-based dashboard that necessitates a constant internet connection for configuration. Therefore, I find Meraki MS Switches more suitable for the IT side.
The improvement needed for Meraki MS Switches is the ability to connect in the worst case when I encounter internet issues. When I cannot connect to the internet and need to configure or connect directly to Cisco switches or access Meraki for changes, I face difficulties.
When Meraki MS Switches can be configured without an internet connection, I think I can use Meraki MS Switches on the OT side.
The only improvement I seek is configuration without an internet connection.
For how long have I used the solution?
I am still working with both products. I work with Meraki for the IT side, but I also use Cisco access points for the OT side.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
I do not have any problems with Meraki MS Switches.
What other advice do I have?
I find the pricing of Meraki MS Switches quite similar to Cisco's prices. I think they are cheaper and better.
I rated Meraki MS Switches an overall score of eight out of ten.