2014-10-13T10:09:00Z
Avigail Sugarman - PeerSpot reviewer
Community Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
  • 7
  • 57

User question: which of the following is the best Ethernet Switch?

I would highly appreciate it if you can help me choose the best solution between the following switches:

Core SwitchHP 5412 zl/ Huawei 7706 Access SwitchHP 2920-48G-POE+/S5700-52X-PWR- Access SwitchHP 2920-24G-POE+/S5700-28X-PWR- WifiHP 425/AP5130D
6
PeerSpot user
6 Answers
it_user337716 - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Security Manager at a non-tech company with 201-500 employees
Vendor
2015-11-06T17:44:21Z
Nov 6, 2015

Core SwitchHP 5412 zl and Access SwitchHP 2920-24G-POE+

Product comparison that may be of interest to you
it_user101373 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a comms service provider with 1,001-5,000 employees
Vendor
2014-10-19T15:01:41Z
Oct 19, 2014

I think - HP is niche solution.
You could use it in DC environment, for example, in office net.
For choosing the best solution you should describe your project, your task, your goal, after that there should be understandable the best solution for exactly your case.

it_user70830 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a media company with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2014-10-19T10:43:55Z
Oct 19, 2014

Depends on the purpose of the switch. There is a core switch and 2 access switches with a Wi-Fi switch.

The core switch is modular and perhaps more expensive….

Just depends what it is going to be used for. “fit for purpose” comes to mind.

Angel Rivera Baez - PeerSpot reviewer
Information Systems Director with 501-1,000 employees
Real User
2014-10-15T20:51:11Z
Oct 15, 2014

Hi.

Never used either of them, but I did some research. What really matter here is for what type of network configuration and services you are going to use it for. If you need leyer 3 services like UDP helper function and a higher speed among other good features the HP 5412 is the one, if you only have a normal Ethernet network, with a normal traffic working mainly on leyer 2 you can go with the HP 2920. I hope this can help you.

it_user106689 - PeerSpot reviewer
Manager of Infrastructure with 51-200 employees
Vendor
2014-10-13T13:42:32Z
Oct 13, 2014

Hi,

It entirely depends on your budget and requirement for IDC or End User.

While you select POE switch you need to be very careful on below points

1) assessing the capability to provision power of switch

2) How POE enable device can be connect to Access switch (limitation)

Above two points mainly left aside while selecting the POE switches by majority of the NW admins.

Also you can look for new series release by HP, which can be stack to 9 switch in a single stack.( HP 5130-48G-4SFP+ EI Switch)

However for Huwai, don’t have any idea.

Thanks & Regards
Ankit Shah

it_user151515 - PeerSpot reviewer
Consultant at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
Consultant
2014-10-13T10:54:15Z
Oct 13, 2014

Hi there Avigail,

It really depends on use and budget. Those switches are quite different in many ways. The HP 5412zl (and btw, that model is EOL you should get the 5400-R series which was released a few months ago) is part of HP's "ProCurve" range (i.e. there pre-3Com acquisition). It's one of my personal favourite switches due to its versatility, reliability, performance and price. ProCurve switches have a CLI based on HP's licensing of Cisco IOS around 15 years ago which was then simplified so setting them up even in fairly complex environments is a snap. They also come with a lifetime NBD warranty so you can usually self-spare and not bother with hardware maintenance. It supports a number of core features such as IPv4/v6 (dual stack) routing (RIP/OSPF/BGP), VRRP and basic distributed trunking but it doesn't stack all that well.

The Huawei 7706 is a different beast altogether. Think of it as a clone of the Cisco 4500 series. It's far higher performance than the HP switch and allows 40/100GbE interfaces (the HP can only do 10GbE) as well as supporting true stacking and far more granular configurations. It's also somewhat more expensive and will require ongoing hardware maintenance.

The choice for core switch really thus comes down whether or not you need the advanced features and performance of the Huawei switch and are willing to bear their upfront and ongoing cost. If not then the HP 5400 is the winner. (NB: Huawei and 3COM have common routes so if you like the Huawei 7700 you might want to consider the HP Comware 7500 which is more or less identical).

The access switch is somewhat easier. The S5700 is way overkill for an access switch and no doubt cost a lot more. The HP 2920 series is a high-performance access switch which supports the fundamental technologies you need as well as easy stacking whilst the S5700 is better suited to a distribution switch where technologies like MPLS are required. HP also gets the nod for ease of configuration and pricing (paritcularly since the lifetime NBD warranty extends to all their stackable switches).

The wireless is a bit more complicated since those APs are somewhat different. The HP 425 is a dual-radio 2:2 MIMO 802.11n AP whilst the Huawei AP5130D is a single radio 802.11AC device. I'm not a fan of single radio APs since even a single slow client (i.e. 802.11a/b/g)/n will slow the AP down somewhat and it will be a long time before all clients are running 802.11AC.

I'm not a huge fan of the HP 425; it's a budget model and I much prefer the MSM460/466 (dual-n) or the 560 (n/AC) as being more powerful and versatile. I can't comment about alternate Huawei wireless as I am less familiar with their wireless products but they have quite a broad range.

With wireless, both vendors are very good so it somewhat comes down to the controller. The Huawei controller is very CLI focused (somewhat like Cisco) and - IMO - a bit of a pain in larger distributed deployments but it is very flexible and reliable. The HP MSM controller is quite a bit easier to configure and learn to use but it only scales to 800APs whereas the Huawei device can go much futher than that. Both vendors offer embedded controllers within their chassis switches but only HP maintains the free lifetime warranty.

Whichever vendor you choose make sure you include their management software (IMC for HP, E-sight for Huawei). Again these are both very similar - and very good - offerings. This will make management and troubleshooting of your environment much easier and more streamlined.

Probably the final consideration you need to make is the support offered by each vendor in your country and there - if you are not in Asia - HP probably has the advantage of having an extremely mature support and logistics model given there global presence and longevity.

I hope this helps, I've tried to be as unbiased as possible in my response.

Michael

Find out what your peers are saying about HPE Ethernet Switches vs. Huawei Ethernet Switches and other solutions. Updated: November 2022.
654,218 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Related Questions
AZ
User at infra projects
Mar 25, 2021
Hi community members, I'm looking to compare Cisco Ethernet Switches with Huawei Ethernet Switches. Which one is better and why? What about their pricing ranges? Thank you!
Miriam Tover - PeerSpot reviewer
Service Delivery Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Oct 5, 2022
If you were talking to someone whose organization is considering HPE Ethernet Switches, what would you say? How would you rate it and why? Any other tips or advice?
2 out of 33 answers
BA
IT Manager at a maritime company with 51-200 employees
Oct 21, 2019
When it comes to HPE switches, as a recommendation, in the end it depends on the requirements. They have to know exactly what they need because HPE has all types and all levels of switches. They keep changing models, and sometimes we have challenges because we find out that two years later, the model is discontinued. Because of this, I say that it is important to purchase the latest model, and not one that is two or three years old because in another year it will be discontinued. I would rate this solution an eight out of ten.
AB
CIO at a tech vendor with 1-10 employees
Oct 21, 2019
I would recommend this product and also a support contract. I don't think that I would pay this price without getting the support. We are happy with this solution but it is really an old model. I would rate this solution a six out of ten.
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technology products and we want your vote! If there’s a technology solution that’s really impressed you, here’s an opportunity to recognize that. It’s easy: go to the PeerSpot voting site, complete the brief voter registration form, review the list of nominees and vote. Get your colleagues to vote, too! ...
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
May 2, 2022
Hi peers, We're happy to share our new bi-weekly Community Spotlight with you. Here you'll find recent contributions by PeerSpot community members: questions, articles and trending discussions. Trending See what your peers are discussing at the moment! What to choose: an endpoint antivirus, an EDR solution, or both? What is your recommended IT Service Management (ITSM) tool in 2022? W...
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Apr 4, 2022
Hi peers, This is our new Community Spotlight that includes recent contributions (questions, articles and discussions) by the PeerSpot community members. Trending Is RPA beneficial for a healthcare organization? With the increasing risk of cyber attacks in the west, due to the war in Ukraine, how safe is your data in the cloud? Articles 8 Business Automation Ideas to Save Time and...
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Mar 4, 2022
Hi community members, Here is our new Community Spotlight for YOU. We publish it to help you catch up on recent contributions by community members. Do you find it useful? Please comment below! Trending Top HCI in 2022 What are the main differences between XDR and SIEM? Articles Top 5 Ethernet Switches in 2022 SASE: what is it and what are the main benefits? Questions Che...
Netanya Carmi - PeerSpot reviewer
Content Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Mar 3, 2022
Ethernet switches connect computers and laptops to a local area network (LAN). Organizations can connect several switches to boost the ethernet’s capacity. We asked PeerSpot users what they consider to be most valuable when looking for an ethernet switch. Some of the answers included: compatibility with the system’s needs, robust connectivity, an API, and good interoperability. Here is t...
See 1 comment
Dibyendu Das - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at Apace Systems Corporation
Mar 3, 2022
Netgear has always been one of our most trusted partners in terms of performance and cost of ownership.  We always recommend using their M4300 Edge Platform (for our Apace Speciality Intelligent Platform Server Storage vStor & eStor with ODM for Video Editing QoS workflows for 24x7 operations).
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
PeerSpot User's Choice Award 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technol...
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
May 2, 2022
Community Spotlight #13: Top Products and Solutions
Hi peers, We're happy to share our new bi-weekly Community Spotlight with you. Here you'll find ...
Related Categories
Download Free Report
Download our FREE report comparing HPE Ethernet Switches and Huawei Ethernet Switches based on reviews, features, and more! Updated: November 2022.
DOWNLOAD NOW
654,218 professionals have used our research since 2012.