Executive SummaryUpdated on Nov 3, 2024
Cisco Catalyst Switches and Fortinet FortiSwitch compete in the network switching category. Cisco Catalyst tends to have an advantage in reliability and feature set, whereas Fortinet FortiSwitch excels in integration with security solutions, particularly when paired with FortiGate.
Features: Cisco Catalyst Switches are known for their rich feature set including VLAN management, PoE capabilities, and advanced security options. User reviews often mention their ease of configuration and strong technical support. Fortinet FortiSwitch focuses on seamless integration with FortiGate, providing robust security features, centralized management, and straightforward usability.
Room for Improvement: Cisco Catalyst Switches are often criticized for their high cost and complex licensing models, with suggestions to simplify licensing and reduce prices. Fortinet FortiSwitch users suggest improved integration of wireless products and enhancing the user interface. Both products could improve in terms of operational streamlining and cost-effectiveness.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Cisco Catalyst Switches are typically deployed on-premises, though some users choose cloud setups. Technical support is generally well-received, albeit with occasional reports of delays. Fortinet FortiSwitch users benefit greatly from its integration with FortiGate, supporting hybrid and on-premises deployments. Fortinet's customer service is praised for its responsiveness and reliability, although integration challenges with non-Fortinet products persist.
Pricing and ROI: Cisco Catalyst Switches are perceived as expensive with a complex licensing model, yet users view them as a worthwhile investment due to their reliability and features, though the ROI may be prolonged. Fortinet FortiSwitch is considered more cost-effective, especially in FortiGate-based environments. Users find that FortiSwitch offers good value for money with a quicker ROI than Cisco. While both solutions incur high initial costs, they ultimately provide solid returns over time.
