What is our primary use case?
We primarily use BlueCat Edge for our entire internal infrastructure and all internal clients for all DNS resolution needs. We also leverage it for DNS redirects, integrations between cloud and on-premises providers, and as a sorting engine to direct queries to the appropriate internal DNS infrastructure. This is necessary because we have multiple internal infrastructures for resolving internal system queries.
We implemented BlueCat Edge to solve the visibility and security issues we were having.
Our infrastructure, including both Edge and BlueCat components, utilizes a full hybrid cloud and on-premises model.
How has it helped my organization?
We encountered some malicious queries, and BlueCat Edge proved invaluable in detecting these DNS threats. While currently only operating in monitor mode, its biggest benefit has become its instrumental role in diagnosing performance issues. It serves as a crucial troubleshooting toolset within our infrastructure, helping us identify and resolve outages effectively.
BlueCat Edge's ability to provide agnostic DNS discovery and resolution across multiple cloud environments is fantastic. I even use it for various DNS providers, including Active Directory, F5, Route 53, and GCP. This capability makes it a key component for me, as it allows me to seamlessly navigate the same DNS namespace across different infrastructures, something that I've found only BlueCat can offer.
The main benefits of BlueCat Edge are its improved performance over our previous infrastructure and its large cache management capabilities. Both contribute to exceptional performance gains. Additionally, it provides valuable visibility into DNS activity, revealing which clients are making what queries and enabling detailed investigation. As we migrated more of our infrastructure onto BlueCat, beyond just the Edge product, we observed immediate benefits in terms of visibility. The biggest hurdle we faced was redirecting our internal clients to use Edge over existing internal DNS solutions. This initially slowed down our metrics, but we still had access to the data. As more systems started using Edge, the benefits became increasingly apparent.
BlueCat Edge has helped our organization reduce operational expenses by decreasing our downtime and providing better DNS performance for queries, as well as helping us identify misconfigurations within our clients' networks.
What needs improvement?
I have concerns about several aspects of BlueCat's site management. Firstly, the cleanup process doesn't seem thorough enough, leaving behind residual data. Secondly, the logging duration has been significantly reduced. When I started using Edge, I had access to 3-6 months of historical data, but now this window has shrunk to just two weeks.
I understand that the platform processes over one and a half billion queries per week, which necessitates data management. However, I believe access to longer-term logs would be beneficial for our analysis. The current two-week window limits our ability to identify trends and track historical events effectively.
BlueCat Edge has a limitation of 10,000 records for exports. While I understand the need to export all data, it would be more efficient if I could selectively export the data I need. Currently, there is only one export mechanism that provides all 10,000 records. I would prefer the ability to select specific values and export more records at once, as I don't require all the data available.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using BlueCat Edge for five years.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
I would rate the stability of BlueCat Edge a nine out of ten.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
On a scale of one to ten, I'd rate its ability to scale as a nine. In that regard, it's very robust. However, the complexity of scaling brings it down to a seven. Scaling out can be intricate, involving many adjustments and configurations. However, once everything is well-tuned, it functions flawlessly.
How are customer service and support?
Technical support responsiveness presents a concern. While it's comparable to other vendors like Microsoft, I expect someone to answer my call within five minutes. Unfortunately, that wait often extends to an hour. The knowledge base, however, seems adequate. I believe BlueCat is rebuilding its content, as it was exceptional when I first started using it. While the current support team is competent, it pales in comparison to their previous level of expertise.
How would you rate customer service and support?
Which solution did I use previously and why did I switch?
We migrated all DNS records from our Active Directory infrastructure. Previously, each domain within our internal network had its own separate DNS server on Active Directory. These servers hosted a variety of zone types, including public, private, and antivirus-specific zones. We consolidated all of these records onto BlueCat Edge.
How was the initial setup?
This architecture can be complex, but I initially found it quite simplistic. However, it's significantly more intricate than single-service systems like Active Directory due to its multiple components. I managed to perform Edge upgrades, BDDS deployment, and BAM deployments simultaneously. By implementing a full DDI configuration from the outset, the system gained further complexity. However, I found the logic behind it intuitive. While slightly more intricate than freely available versions, I didn't find the architecture or deployment overly challenging, thanks in part to collaboration with BlueCat's architecture team.
Our Edge deployment took four to six months and required a hybrid infrastructure with specific virtual infrastructure, firewalls, and connectivity at 18 sites. However, much of the delay stemmed from the need to upgrade our infrastructure, which involved additional legal work due to our status as a financial fintech company. We faced stricter regulations regarding permissible connections to the SaaS portal, resulting in delays related to whitelisting and verifying data security and privacy.
I was the only one involved in the deployment from our organization.
What about the implementation team?
We leveraged BlueCat's migration services during our Edge deployment to migrate our DNS Active Directory zones to the BlueCat platform.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
We find the current pricing model more reasonable compared to the previous per-IP pricing. BlueCat was competitively priced against Infoblox during our evaluation. While currently using their maintenance support only, BlueCat is certainly an expensive product. However, considering our company's growth and performance, we believe it's a necessary investment. While free solutions like AD DNS exist, BlueCat offers significant added value, justifying its cost. Our senior leadership shares this view and is pleased with the results.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
I evaluated Infoblox five years ago when we had a specific need: our use case involved having multiple SOAs for the same Route Zone. At that time, BlueCat offered a resolution method that could handle this scenario by querying multiple SOAs to find the desired answer.
While Infoblox has since improved its capabilities, BlueCat was the only solution that met our requirements at the time of our analysis. During the initial phase of our migration, we indeed had multiple SOAs, and we needed the ability to send queries to different name servers for the same zone. BlueCat was able to fulfill this requirement, while Infoblox was not.
What other advice do I have?
I would rate BlueCat Edge nine out of ten.
BlueCat Edge will release optics patches which will require manual deployment by our IT team. Due to company policy, automatic updates are disabled, even though BlueCat Edge offers an auto-upgrade feature. This aligns with our general policy of avoiding automated tools in certain situations.
DNS-specific security solutions offer the first line of defense by providing greater visibility and control compared to traditional methods like individual firewalls. Consolidating all DNS queries in a central location enhances effectiveness and simplifies management, making it superior to utilizing a basic firewall for DNS security, such as a Cisco firewall.
I recommend completing the Edge homework. Make sure to understand the main list, name servers, resolution process, and similar concepts. It's also crucial to grasp the nature and function of caching. Remember, thorough understanding is key.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
Hybrid Cloud