Magnolia CMS vs dotCMS comparison

Cancel
You must select at least 2 products to compare!
dotCMS Logo
136 views|121 comparisons
Magnolia International Logo
1,178 views|864 comparisons
Executive Summary

We performed a comparison between dotCMS and Magnolia CMS based on real PeerSpot user reviews.

Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft, Wordpress, Adobe and others in Web Content Management.
To learn more, read our detailed Web Content Management Report (Updated: March 2024).
767,847 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Q&A Highlights
Question: What is the price range for Web Content Management solutions?
Answer: Although we have no direct experience implementing Magnolia or dotCMS, our technical team likely could figure it out fairly quickly. Both are known to be simple to deploy. However, both are open source and are therefore free. Implementation costs, if you use an outside contractor, will depend on what exactly are you implementing and how customized versus out-of-the-box. I should think though, that a simple brochure website or intranet using either will run in the low 10s-of thousands of dollars, not 100s-of-thousands of dollars. More expensive than Wordpress, but more robust web content management functionality. Magnolia is a solid solution, comparable to Kentico, and more robust than SharePoint (for web content management).
Answers from the Community
AYMAN MOAWAD
Murugappan Ramanathan - PeerSpot reviewerMurugappan Ramanathan
Consultant

Web Content Management consists of the following:

(1) Platform
(2) Tools
(3) Frameworks.

In general, there are two types for each of the above. These are completely open-source free versions and paid versions. My suggestion is to go those within the price range of USD 39 to USD 400. I found these to be the best in the market. Platforms like Joomla, Drupal can remove the need for hardcore techies to launch your applications. They are comprehensive, flexible and extendable. Based on these are so many tools and frameworks that speed your application development. Examples like Joomshaper, Codeigniter, etc. Magnolia is based on Java and could end up been pricey unless you are Java shop.

Questions from the Community
Ask a question

Earn 20 points

Top Answer: "The best" is a very subjective thing when it comes to CMS, as well as with anything in life. I've worked in a place where we used Magnolia as the content management system and I can't really find… more »
Top Answer: Honestly, I don't see what should stop you from using Magnolia CMS for your personal use or to grow the digital experience you can provide. It gives you a free trial and from there you can establish… more »
Top Answer:No, you don't have to be a developer or any kind of professional IT specialist to use the services of Magnolia CMS. In fact, if you're neither of these things, then Magnolia is the right thing for… more »
Ranking
24th
Views
136
Comparisons
121
Reviews
0
Average Words per Review
0
Rating
N/A
6th
Views
1,178
Comparisons
864
Reviews
0
Average Words per Review
0
Rating
N/A
Buyer's Guide
Web Content Management
March 2024
Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft, Wordpress, Adobe and others in Web Content Management. Updated: March 2024.
767,847 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Comparisons
Learn More
Overview

dotCMS is a powerful content management system that simplifies the complex needs and integration requirements of large organizations. It delivers content to websites, intranets, mobile apps and anything with an internet connection. Teams can push entire websites to geographically distributed servers or CDNs. Fully customizable workflows adapt to your business needs. dotCMS easily integrates with third party systems, like marketing automation, eCommerce, CRMs and ERPs.

Magnolia is one of the oldest and most popular digital experience platforms, delivering high-quality services for customers looking for established CMS solutions. Having started out as an open-source content management system, today Magnolia provides digital experience for some of the largest companies in the world. This DXP is Java-based and uses a JCR repository to store, search, and restore data. Organizations that employ IT specialists with expert Java knowledge can benefit from the services of Magnolia, but the company also provides education for beginners. Through the Magnolia education program, business owners who are inexperienced in Java or other technologies can learn the concepts of the CMS and use it to benefit the digital experience of their company.

The main industries that benefit from the services of Magnolia include retail and e-commerce, finance, travel, and media. According to Magnolia, companies from these industries benefit from increased revenues and improved customer service. Through the various services and features of Magnolia, an organization can build and establish a digital experience that can popularize the company online and expand the existing client list.

Magnolia CMS Features

The features of Magnolia CMS allow you to create a personalized multi-channel digital experience while managing all content in one place. Magnolia divides its features into four main categories:

  • Creation: Even though Magnolia provides companies with powerful tools, the interface remains relatively simple to use. This means that different businesses can benefit from the ability to create content that is specially catered to their users' digital experience. The features in this category include what-you-see-is-what-you-get (WYSIWYG) editing, single-page app (SPA) editing, optimized content authoring, content reuse, an option for multichannel preview, microsites and landing pages, omnichannel campaigns, and forms and marketing automation.

  • Management: The management features that Magnolia provides allow companies to access and manage their content, apps, and data in a single place. This is one of the biggest benefits of Magnolia: easy access to data. The features in this category include multi-source content, a unified user experience, AI federated search, automatic text classification and image recognition, multi-site management, automatic translation, concurrent editing, visual version compare, and custom workflows.

  • Delivery: Through features like the headless accelerator, Magnolia for eCommerce, SPAs/PWAs, Jamstack/Static Site Generation, digital signage, hybrid headless, and VR, AR & MR, Magnolia CMS helps companies deliver digital experience across all possible channels. Using a single interface for the delivery of personalized content allows organizations to save time while providing users with content that satisfies their individual needs.

  • Optimization: This category of features allows organizations that use Magnolia to learn from data about their performance and potentially improve it. Through personalization, A/B/n testing, analytics and insights, and SEO, Magnolia helps its users improve the digital experience they provide by discovering their weak spots and, based on insights, working to fix any issues.

Magnolia CMS Benefits

Magnolia CMS offers various benefits, including:

  • Educational resources
  • Easy personalization of web apps
  • Suitable for both small as well as larger companies and their clients
  • Free trial available
Sample Customers
Standard & Poor's, Roto-Rooter, Novartis, El Pollo Loco, Sépaq, Wawanesa Insurance, University of Akron, Ask.com, GreenSky, Ipsy, Oberlin College, BNP Paribas, Honda, Fairfax Digital, Aquent, Thomson Reuters Foundation, Nomura, Equinix, S&P Global, viaprinto
Ancestry.com, Migros, MOO, Al Arabiya, Alior Bank, Atlassian, Avis
Top Industries
No Data Available
VISITORS READING REVIEWS
Computer Software Company19%
Financial Services Firm13%
Comms Service Provider9%
Educational Organization9%
Company Size
No Data Available
VISITORS READING REVIEWS
Small Business21%
Midsize Enterprise17%
Large Enterprise62%
Buyer's Guide
Web Content Management
March 2024
Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft, Wordpress, Adobe and others in Web Content Management. Updated: March 2024.
767,847 professionals have used our research since 2012.

dotCMS is ranked 24th in Web Content Management while Magnolia CMS is ranked 6th in Web Content Management. dotCMS is rated 0.0, while Magnolia CMS is rated 0.0. On the other hand, dotCMS is most compared with , whereas Magnolia CMS is most compared with Liferay Digital Experience Platform, Adobe Experience Manager, WordPress, Drupal and Sitecore Experience Manager.

See our list of best Web Content Management vendors.

We monitor all Web Content Management reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.