Sep 24, 2018
Thank for your nice works. I am working on the similar type comparison between Fortescout, FortiNAC(Bradford) and ISE for a project in a healthcare organization.
Find out what your peers are saying about Hewlett Packard Enterprise, Fortinet, Cisco and others in Network Access Control (NAC).
Using Aruba ClearPass has resulted in less engineering time compared to other products we've used.
The investment is huge for enterprise clients, but Aruba ClearPass makes processes easier.
We assess Forescout Platform's device inventory for helping track vulnerabilities and ensure patch compliance through penetration testing.
We have saved resources and time, and we have also secured our network, confirming we have a return on investment.
Portnox is one level up, as their customer support is outstanding.
We have faced delays in the resolution of production issues after raising tickets, which impacts productivity.
If Aruba ClearPass is not working, then the organization is not working because this is the access control in the organization.
We have had experience with their technical support and must pay additionally for maintenance, support, and regional service.
They provide sessions to help with various questions.
They could do more to improve, not because of the product itself but because of the support they provide.
Fortinet FortiNAC's customer support is very good, as is typical from Fortinet.
I believe the scalability of ClearPass is rated as ten out of ten.
Everything will be handled when you add new users because all configurations are deployed from the beginning.
In our environment, ClearPass handles up to 100,000 users, which is better than some other NAC solutions like Fortinox that scale up to 25,000.
Scalability can be costly since a physical box needs to be installed for every site.
The pricing model makes it challenging as the cost is substantial due to the per-node licensing model.
I have experienced more than three years without zero downtime with Aruba ClearPass.
There are issues with some versions, especially in integrating with AD and SSL configurations over port sixty-three.
However, there are disadvantages when it is not on-premises, as every NAC suffers from it if it is not on-premises.
I would rate its stability as 9.5 out of ten.
The language and policy enforcement mechanisms are not clear, making it difficult to use the product effectively.
It is also better to improve threat intelligence for built-in threat detection and prevention.
A more streamlined menu of licensing options would be helpful.
It would help if during integration, an admin user could check the password or credential used, as they currently cannot see the password after it is entered and saved.
Forescout Platform could enhance its integration of AI to improve IoT and OT device security to better meet our needs.
Easier integration through APIs to automation platforms is something that would really help us when it comes to future requirements or future features that we're looking for from Forescout Platform.
Improvement in the interface design would make FortiNAC a better solution.
The graphical user interface (GUI) of Fortinet FortiNAC is very poor compared to competitors like Forcepoint and Cisco ISE.
Fortinet FortiNAC can be improved as the GUI is very poor compared to other competitors such as Cisco ISE.
Achieving the best price requires careful selection from a menu of licensing options.
We cannot mix in prices, and of course, prices are going higher.
Aruba ClearPass is a premium product with higher pricing, which seems unnecessary given its complexity.
Installing a physical box on each site can be expensive.
The overall pricing of Forescout Platform is reasonable for the functionality it provides.
The price of Forescout Platform is reasonable and not overly costly.
My experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing for Fortinet FortiNAC is that, as is typical from Fortinet, all their products have a very good licensing model and competitive pricing.
Fortinet FortiNAC is relatively cheap compared to other solutions.
In Aruba ClearPass, you can have control of all authentication in the company.
The ClearPass solution has reduced the amount of engineering time compared to previous solutions, making it more efficient for our purposes.
The most effective feature for us is the OnGuard feature.
Automated threat response helps manage potential breaches very much, because that's something that is very critical, especially to overcome zero-day attacks.
One of the most valuable features of Forescout Platform is its automation, particularly the ability to automate remediation of rogue devices on the network.
The most effective feature has been network access management, which has been crucial for our primary use cases in the organization.
I appreciate the feature where it can connect with different vendor equipment, regardless of the network devices from other vendors.
The best features Fortinet FortiNAC offers include great integration with other Fortinet products.
The main advantage of Fortinet FortiNAC is its integration with the entire Fortinet product portfolio.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Aruba ClearPass | 18.0% |
| Fortinet FortiNAC | 13.7% |
| Forescout Platform | 8.6% |
| Other | 59.7% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 44 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 25 |
| Large Enterprise | 34 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 30 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 10 |
| Large Enterprise | 45 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 30 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 14 |
| Large Enterprise | 14 |
Aruba ClearPass provides robust authentication and policy enforcement with seamless integration capabilities, enhancing security for corporate networks. It handles guest access, BYOD management, and offers dynamic segmentation and extensive network visibility.
Aruba ClearPass supports diverse environments through integrated device profiling, enhancing network and user security. Its intuitive GUI simplifies management while dynamic segmentation offers tailored user experiences. Though highly functional, users seek improvements in interface intuitiveness and simplified configurations. Streamlined integration, better support, and clarity in licensing are also desired to enhance user experience. Deployed primarily for network access control and wireless management, Aruba ClearPass ensures secure corporate network access with identity authentication, policy enforcement, and detailed visibility.
What are the core features?In healthcare, Aruba ClearPass manages secure access for medical devices and personnel, ensuring compliance and confidentiality. Schools utilize it for managing student and guest network access, while enterprises integrate it for consistent security across corporate environments.
Forescout Platform provides comprehensive device visibility and asset management without requiring agent installation. It strengthens network access control and endpoint compliance, integrating flexibly with zero-trust architecture.
Forescout Platform offers organizations a robust solution for maintaining network security by enabling detailed monitoring of connected devices and enforcing compliance policies across IT and OT networks. Effective in sectors like finance, healthcare, and manufacturing, it controls unauthorized access, authenticates, quarantines, and remediates noncompliant devices while supporting both on-premises and cloud environments. Notable for its third-party integration, easy configuration, and customizable threat responses, Forescout Platform aids in efficient security measure maintenance.
What are the key features?Forescout Platform finds widespread adoption across industries like finance, healthcare, and manufacturing. It is particularly valued for enforcing cybersecurity measures and maintaining compliance in diverse operational environments, handling network access and device management challenges efficiently.
Fortinet FortiNAC is integral for enhancing network access control by providing security, visibility, and control over IoT devices. Known for its user-friendly interface and powerful automation, it streamlines network management and access control while supporting policy enforcement and guest management.
Fortinet FortiNAC offers robust security by integrating seamlessly with Fortinet products, enhancing compatibility with external vendors, and allowing users to manage wired and wireless networks efficiently. Known for its ability to prevent unauthorized connections, it enhances network visibility and control, particularly in managing Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) and compliance. However, integration with non-Fortinet systems, better reporting capabilities, and intuitive interface improvements are areas for enhancement. Setup complexities, additional equipment needs for features like single sign-on, and improved support and documentation are noted challenges.
What are the key features of Fortinet FortiNAC?In education and healthcare, Fortinet FortiNAC is applied extensively to manage Wi-Fi access for non-domain devices, ensuring secure network access without traditional password-based systems. It integrates with Fortinet Security Fabric, offering endpoint profiling and posture assessments to ensure adherence to security standards. This implementation enhances BYOD management, allowing organizations to meet compliance and security requirements effectively across diverse environments.
