Coming October 25: PeerSpot Awards will be announced! Learn more
2021-05-08T14:52:00Z
SS
User at ana
  • 6
  • 110

What product would you recommend and why: SAP S/4HANA or Microsoft Dynamics NAV?

Hello, I'm looking for recommendations about the following two products: Microsoft Dynamics 365 and SAP S/4HANA. 

What would be your choice and why? Tnx.

6
PeerSpot user
6 Answers
MS
Sr IT/Business Consultant at Ottap
Real User
Top 20
2021-05-11T22:37:52Z
11 May 21

I concur with the other responders here. MS Dynamics 365 and SAP S/4 HANA are not in the same league. Will need more info about your requirements and budget. 


SAP S/4 HANA on-premise is expensive, but, in good hands will do well, especially on a really solid hardware config.... cloud-based is somewhat less expensive, but you cannot customize... 


MS Dynamics Business Central is less expensive but has most of what an ERP package should have... and in good hands, the recent versions are fairly stable....but the config has to be accurate and your connectivity must be stable, otherwise, it will be a horrendous experience... I would not suggest MS Dynamics NAV now... it better to look at Business Central...that is improved NAV on the cloud.

Product comparison that may be of interest to you
Gene Hammons - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at ProfitFromERP
Real User
Top 5Leaderboard
2021-05-10T15:33:22Z
10 May 21

So Microsoft Dynamics NAV is being replaced, as MS recodes the product for a cloud based deployment called Business Central (BC) - very low priced right now, almost entry level ERP pricing. There's also been some significant problems as not all the functions from NAV were included in Business Central from day one. Many clients found themselves with a 'not-ready-for-prime-time' product. We had a spectacularly failed implementation with a client who did not follow our recommendations and went with BC back in Dec 2019 - and they picked a very inexperienced partner because it was the technology group of the CPA firm that did their taxes (not a good reason for any ERP decision). 


We only work with proven implementation partners for that exact reason. 


SAP of course is a proven Tier One leader in ERP - but more costly - you'll need several people on staff to manage it, entry level costs are $3m - $5m with rollouts of more than a year. 


We have had success with another Microsoft product, the former Dynamics AX, now called Finance & Operation (F&O). In the hands of a good team we've launched some pharma manufacturers with F&O at a $1.2m price point while SAP estimates were in the $3m range. Again, a near Tier One application, they used outside consultants for support for the first couple of years, and brought in someone in-house and they expanded her department to two 18 months later - still far less than supporting SAP, but a big program with a lot of powerful options. 


The move from AX to cloud based F&O has not been as painful as Business Central and we haven't heard the horror stories - but also, F&O is so complex it's not handled by the average CPA firm or as a simple add on from the same Microsoft reseller that provides Office and Azure. 


Anyway - your budget may only cover Business Central, but there are cloud based ERP products that have been cloud based for 20 years, not 20 months. Your requirements may demand SAP  - or you may be referring to SAP Business One which is a mid market product (whole new set of issues there). 


But you're in an area where lots of companies bring in a software selection consultant because we've only scratched the surface here. As Daniel Robus recommends, you might need to look wider - because if you're looking to choose between SAP and Business Central - by definition, one of them doesn't belong in the same discussion. 

Muhammad Shaamel - PeerSpot reviewer
Sales Director at Orangekloud Inc
Real User
Top 5
2021-07-26T06:31:52Z
26 July 21

Adding on to other contributors' opinions, if you are spoilt for choice and understand the nuances of good architecture, ease of customization, viable budget to expend on deploying the ERP - Acumatica ERP is soon becoming a force to reckon with for the SMEs.


Microsoft D365 BC formerly Microsoft Dynamics NAV has become more robust and integrated and a joy to deploy and use within the acceptable budget one needs for ERP implementation.


SAP the old warhorse, engineered with the finest and well thought out design architectures true to all German products if deployed well is a wonderful and seamless experience but if the Systems Integrator doesn't do justice and is unable to tame the warhorse, this can be a disastrous run for all besides the bludgeoning costs incurred for deploying this fine piece of architecture.

Daniel Robus - PeerSpot reviewer
Go To Market Executive at #Liferocks Consulting
Real User
Top 5Leaderboard
2021-05-10T11:23:54Z
10 May 21

Hi - that is such a wide question which requires more information. They are both great products but they need to be implemented in the correct way. If you are working in the mining environment you will never be in trouble if you have SAP behind you. 


If you are looking at a general organsiation that might be growing and expanding but want to start small then Dynamics is a good option....



so, it depends. But there are even better options out there....so look wider.

SS
User at ana
User
2021-05-16T19:07:16Z
16 May 21

Thanks dear friends for responding. The cues forwarded are of immense value. I notice that the crux of all responses mostly relate to cost of acquisition, choosing right implementation partner, resource costs, look for additional alternatives & non comparability of between the two. While these are fantastic fundamentals, succinctly put across and are deeply appreciated, I seek for further knowledge from IT Magi with regards to few specific areas that are important to carry the search further. 


These are;Suitability for Commodity Oriented Manufacturing Company, with costing & treasury, customised sales Order/contract management, multiple methods of stock valuation, Product & Process costing, Costing & Financial P&Ls, Product Contribution Management, Price parity management, Multiple methods Margin/Realizations calculations, Mark to markets.


Hope this will help in focusing on suitable option that may be suggested between the two. Thanks in advance for taking out your precious time to respond to the ignorant.


Sunil


 

Gene Hammons - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at ProfitFromERP
Real User
Top 5Leaderboard
18 May 21

@Sunil Saraf So with the list of requirements, MS Dynamics Finance & Operation or SAP will probably be your contenders to evaluate. You may also want to look at cloud based NetSuite with the new FP&B (formerly marketed as Hyperion) module to see if that works for you. Your more expensive AX/SAP will handle everything more out of the box, but have added expense and complexity. NetSuite gives you the base and SuiteApps provide the remaining functionality. 
Your choice now is to find the program that best suits your business' internal culture and secure a good reselling partner to work with. 

PeerSpot user
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Community Manager
2021-05-10T05:43:39Z
10 May 21

Hi @Gene Hammons ​, @Antonio Lira ​and @Okay Akdeniz . Can you please chime in? Thanks.

Find out what your peers are saying about Microsoft Dynamics NAV vs. SAP S/4HANA and other solutions. Updated: September 2022.
635,987 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Related Questions
VK
User at Rostan Technologies
Jul 25, 2022
Hi peers, I would like to compare the pricing and costs of the following products:  Oracle Cloud (Oracle Fusion), SAP HANA and MS NAV. Can anyone assist and share this information? Thank you.
See 1 answer
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
25 July 22
Hi @SanilPrakashan, @Peter Haider, @Oleg Krivolapov, @Ali Mirnia, @reviewer1593270, @WilfredThomson, @reviewer1383855 ​and @reviewer1002447, Can you please help answer this @Vikash-Kumar's question by sharing your experience with those products? Thanks for sharing your knowledge with other peers. ​
Sep 27, 2021
Hi peers, Can anyone explain the main differences between SAP Business One (SAP B1) and SAP S/4HANA?  Also, do you have pointers to each product's reviews? Thank you.
See 2 answers
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
27 September 21
@Ricardo Mano, Here are the reviews by real users on IT Central Station: https://www.itcentralstation.com/products/sap-business-one-reviews and  https://www.itcentralstation.com/products/sap-s4hana-reviews
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
27 September 21
Hi @Shahzad-Islam, @VenkataM, @MuhammadWaqar, @Puneet, @Shankar Agarwal, @SanjeevKumar12 , Can you please chime-in here and share your expertise? 
Related Articles
DC
Marketing Manager at MIE Solutions
Mar 01, 2021
Shop floor management with improved capabilities is an important component of the manufacturing industry. This makes it vital for manufacturers to have centralized systems and the best ERP software is the ideal choice in this regard. The main purpose of shop floor management is to increase and sustain the production quality and efficiency. Today’s rising trend of digitization calls for ident...
Gene Hammons - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at ProfitFromERP
Mar 01, 2021
What don't they tell you about ERP? Turns out there's plenty left unsaid. There's actually an 80% marketwide failure rate measured by cost overrun, time to go-live and expected functionality - granted, getting the system up a month later isn't the end of the world, but a 2x budget overrun is no laughing matter.  CIO's have also expressed disappointment in having sufficient budget to finish th...
Gene Hammons, MBA - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at a consultancy with 1-10 employees
Nov 16, 2020
Over the past few months, political coverage reminded me of a Winston Churchill quote – “A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get it’s pants on”. Living in a world of competing politicians and contentious media, there were seemingly plenty of lies for both sides to yelp about. I thanked my lucky stars that in the business of ERP, we don’t deal in lies as the c...
Related Articles
DC
Marketing Manager at MIE Solutions
Mar 01, 2021
ERP Helps Improve Shop Floor Management & Productivity
Shop floor management with improved capabilities is an important component of the manufacturing...
Gene Hammons - PeerSpot reviewer
Director at ProfitFromERP
Mar 01, 2021
What They Don't Tell You About ERP
What don't they tell you about ERP? Turns out there's plenty left unsaid. There's actually an 80...
Related Categories
Download Free Report
Download our free SAP S/4HANA Report and get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: September 2022.
DOWNLOAD NOW
635,987 professionals have used our research since 2012.