

Netgate pfSense and Cisco Meraki MX are competing products in the network security category. While Meraki MX is advantageous for its ease of use and advanced cloud capabilities, pfSense stands out for its customizability and open-source model catering to hands-on users.
Features: Netgate pfSense offers open-source flexibility with customizable configurations, community support, and compatibility with open-source hardware. Cisco Meraki MX is known for its advanced cloud management features, auto VPN, ease of deployment, and centralized management.
Room for Improvement: Netgate pfSense users look for better central management and improved UI, along with a more robust API for configuration. Cisco Meraki MX requires improvements in granular security features and better non-Meraki device support, with emphasis on client VPN provisioning and system integration.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Netgate pfSense provides strong open-source community support and flexibility in on-premises implementations, with optional paid support for critical environments. Cisco Meraki MX excels in simple deployment through cloud-based management, providing robust support and simplifying operations without needing extensive in-house expertise.
Pricing and ROI: Netgate pfSense is cost-effective with a free open-source version and optional paid enterprise versions, serving budget-conscious users. Cisco Meraki MX, while more expensive, justifies its cost with integrated cloud features and centralized management providing value to enterprises investing in seamless IT operations.
I have seen a return on investment with Cisco Meraki MX because of the time saved through cloud management.
You can eliminate some positions because it manages itself.
It greatly helps out when I am moving away from the expensive MPLS circuits or MPLS hardware.
It's very favorable to have the inclusion of firewall, VPN, and router functionalities.
The total cost of ownership is extremely low when you compare it to a lot of the other devices or other gateway appliances that are available on the market.
There's a significant return on investment.
When we raise a ticket with Meraki MX, they instantly become available to support us for configurations or troubleshooting.
Cisco's TAC support for Cisco Meraki MX is excellent because no other OEM provides support at this level.
Cisco is one of the best vendors in the market.
The support is knowledgeable and responds quickly, so the questions are addressed professionally and accurately.
Snort requires you to pay extra for that help. It's a third-party plugin for pfSense.
When we're down, that's $8000 an hour on a $1500 firewall.
When you have hundreds of thousands of people it is very difficult to scale in Meraki.
The scalability of Cisco Meraki MX is rated 10 out of 10; you can scale up and scale down with no effort.
Cisco Meraki MX scales with my growing needs for my organization very well because they are easy to deploy.
Even with a jump from a 50 megabit to a 500 megabit internet connection and approximately 65 active VPN clients, our firewall operates smoothly without any strain.
pfSense is almost infinitely scalable.
The next step up now is to the 4100, which gives you an additional preconfigured WAN port that allows you to easily separate networks.
There have been no outages, no stability issues, and we have not found any vulnerabilities during security audits.
I have had zero downtime at all with Cisco Meraki MX.
I assess the stability and the reliability of Cisco Meraki MX as good, and I have experienced no downtime, crashes, or performance issues.
I've noticed a substantial improvement in stability and ease of use for upgrades and patching over the past year or two.
When I replace consumer routers with pfSense for small businesses with two or three employees, they are often amazed to discover the router can run for a year without a reboot.
Netgate pfSense rates a 10 for stability, and I have experienced no issues there.
It should automatically remediate and find out the issue and then resolve it on its own without interrupting the work of the employees.
Data is the only path, so optimization is essential.
An improvement would be to use Cisco Meraki MX as a software solution as well, which might reduce the cost.
Netgate pfSense is extremely feature-rich for our specific use scenarios.
Having a reseller portal of some kind that allows us to easily remotely access all the different pfSense gateways that we have out there (like Meraki does with their equipment) would be ideal.
I need to speak to someone immediately.
I get it for $25,000, a device that can connect up to 75-100 users, whereas in Meraki MX, it goes to 75,000-80,000 per access point.
The price could be reduced by around 30% to make it more comfortable.
If Cisco can make the pricing less, customers can purchase more licenses.
It also offers a free community version that can't be beaten.
The cost of the 3500 was closer to $4,000.
The total cost of ownership is so low because the license and the hardware are remarkably good.
Meraki MX is among those top solutions in their exceptional approach towards VPN-less, Zero Trust client access to office private networks.
Advanced security is the second tier of Cisco Meraki MX. It brings you the main next-generation firewalling features such as URL filtering, advanced malware protection, and threat protection.
Cisco Meraki MX API makes it really easy for me to automate a lot of changes over several thousand devices.
pfSense's flexibility is great. If you don't have the money to buy the NetGate hardware, anything works with it. You can toss it on any low-end piece of hardware or virtualize it if you choose to virtualize it.
In contrast, pfSense has a graphical user interface, which makes it all very straightforward and easy to use to set up some pretty sophisticated routing scenarios.
Netgate pfSense provides 100 percent visibility, enabling my organization to make data-driven decisions.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Netgate pfSense | 7.7% |
| Cisco Meraki MX | 3.5% |
| Other | 88.8% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 43 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 22 |
| Large Enterprise | 19 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 171 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 33 |
| Large Enterprise | 29 |
Cisco Meraki MX offers cloud-managed security with user-friendly setup and efficient management, enhancing VPN and firewall functionalities for businesses.
Cisco Meraki MX is known for its robust cloud-based network management, featuring AutoVPN, SD-WAN, and advanced security. Its centralized control over firewall, traffic shaping, and monitoring ensures excellent connectivity and security. The interface allows easy management by non-technical staff, offering remote access and seamless network performance through real-time alerts and troubleshooting. It supports global connectivity with minimal effort, addressing needs across small to enterprise environments. Despite its strengths, users point out areas needing improvement like load balancing, VPN features, more flexible logging, and session capabilities. Pricing, integration limits, and licensing need enhancement.
What are the key features of Cisco Meraki MX?In industries like retail, finance, and education, Cisco Meraki MX provides enhanced security and connectivity. Retail chains benefit from easy VPN setups for secure multi-site networking, while educational institutions find value in its ability to manage large campuses efficiently. Financial services leverage its robust security features to protect sensitive data, ensuring compliance and trust.
Netgate pfSense is an open-source firewall and router software known for scalability, cost-effectiveness, and community support. It includes customizable packages for varied network management needs, offering solid performance and straightforward management for diverse setups.
Netgate pfSense provides an impressive range of functionalities including firewall capabilities, VPN options, and extensive customization through packages. Its low resource usage and high availability make it viable for businesses of all sizes, especially when dealing with tailored network demands. Despite its strengths, users suggest improvements in ease of use, mobile compatibility, and support for plug-ins. Enhanced centralized management, better documentation, and additional security features are frequent requests.
What are the key features of Netgate pfSense?In education and healthcare, Netgate pfSense is employed for secure connectivity and efficient traffic management, accommodating distinct demands of remote access and content filtering. Organizations in these sectors often utilize features such as load balancing and VPNs to maintain secure and reliable network operations while integrating with services like Active Directory for streamlined identity management. Small to medium-sized enterprises benefit from its affordability and robust functionality, making it a go-to choice for managed service environments requiring effective network security and control.
We monitor all Firewalls reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.