2020-02-13T12:46:00Z
SA
System Support Engineer at a engineering company with 11-50 employees
  • 10
  • 509

What are the biggest technical differences between Sophos UTM and Fortinet FortiGate?

I have around ten years of experience as a system support engineer for an engineering company. 

We are currently evaluating Sophos UTM and Fortinet FortiGate. What are the technical differences between the two. Which would you recommend?

Thanks! I appreciate the help. 

11
PeerSpot user
11 Answers
Janet Staver - PeerSpot reviewer
Tech Blogger
Real User
Top 5
2021-12-01T13:52:13Z
Dec 1, 2021

As a solution, Sophos UTM offers a lot of functionality, it scales well, and the stability and performance are quite good. The most valuable features for me are their web and email filtering. I would say that this solution is extremely user-friendly, and also very easy to manage for any integrator. For me, the setup was straightforward as well. Beyond providing general purpose firewall with built in VPN tunneling, it also offers advanced firewall scanning. One disadvantage of the solution for me, though, was that because the logs are not as clear as I would have liked them to be, I needed to purchase an additional piece of software. However, Sophos UTM is a cost-effective solution and has very helpful technical support.


On the other hand, FortiGate also has a lot going for it. What I like the most about it is that it has an attractive web dashboard with very easy navigation tabs; It can be managed and controlled using layer two wireless access points; When compared with other firewalls, building IPsec VPN and SSL VPN is much easier; I can configure virtual networks within the same firewall; And configuration of NAT and static routes are straightforward. FortiGate also has many security functions, such as application control, web filtering, IPS, antivirus, etc., that help companies protect their users. It helps optimize traffic from user to application via the hybrid WAN environment. The downsides of FortiGate are that it happens to include many bugs, and sometimes it can be a challenge to block content from a website with web filtering since web pages contain websites that consume other resources. Moreover, mobile device administration is complicated, and it does not seem to adapt to smartphone or tablet screens very well.


Conclusion: Although FortiGate provides several useful features, I chose to go with Sophos UTM because I primarily needed a solution for a number of use cases including firewall, web filtering, email filtering, and email encryption rather than for web application and protection. Simply put, UTM has all I need at an affordable price point and FortiGate had extras that just weren’t necessary for me.

Product comparison that may be of interest to you
Gonzalo Moreno - PeerSpot reviewer
Owner at supernovatel
Real User
Top 5
2020-02-17T14:08:07Z
Feb 17, 2020

In my opinion and as a result of years of experience:

- Both are great firewalls with excellent performance and a useful integration witch Active directory and LDAP

- Fortinet is easier to manage and have a nice way to configure routes but some times have throughput troubles as an example: in 2 years we need to make around 4 reboots in a 3 firewall deploy

- Sophos has a lot of nice firewall features (i mean without a license), some features like routes and VPN use to be a little difficult to configure but we never need to reboot any FW.

Mohsinoddin Mohammed - PeerSpot reviewer
Information Security Principal at Alkhorayef
Real User
Top 5
2021-01-04T08:48:37Z
Jan 4, 2021

Fortinet is easy to manage and it include secure SDWAN as well including many features with easy to configure.

AT
Owner with 11-50 employees
User
2020-02-17T09:18:10Z
Feb 17, 2020

I would have no doubt in recommending Fortinet. I do not know the Sophos UTM product specifically but in general, in companies, we have had unpleasant experiences with Sophos with customers. They typically declare performance values ​​that are overestimated in the field.

Narendra Singh - PeerSpot reviewer
Solution Architect at Brillbean Ventures Pvt ltd
Real User
2020-02-17T08:05:10Z
Feb 17, 2020

We replaced Fortinet with Sophos as our public-facing UTM in 2017 & since then the ride has been extremely rough. I would not recommend Sophos for any mission-critical environment.

Manjil Bhetwal - PeerSpot reviewer
Presales Engineer at a tech services company with 11-50 employees
Real User
Top 5
2020-02-18T10:21:13Z
Feb 18, 2020

Both firewalls are easy to deploy. But the issue you will encounter when performing troubleshooting. You will not get flexibility in troubleshooting through Cli in Sophos whereas, in FortiGate, we have much more control. Besides if you are deploying a firewall on a large scale where visibility, control, performance as well as the flexibility is important it is better to go with Fortinet rather than Sophos.

Find out what your peers are saying about Fortinet FortiGate vs. Sophos UTM and other solutions. Updated: November 2022.
653,522 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Richard Benfatto - PeerSpot reviewer
Networking Security Expert at SR Technologies
User
Top 5
2020-02-17T21:09:24Z
Feb 17, 2020

I would also like to elaborate on the reporting part in FortiCloud. There is no need to pay any extras. Every box connects to ForticCoud service, and if you want reports to be greater than 7 days (meaning to be kept longer than that in their memory system) then you have to pay. In the meantime, by default Forticloud will send daily emails with reports and once a week you will get 4 to 5 reports, with lots of granular information. These reports are all in PDF with color graphics. In reality, I would be happy to send you some of the reports as in words typed herein would be more than a book. The FortiGate appliance also comes with 10 endpoint security (Forticlient) licences. So you can put this endpoint protection software to servers or clients. It also has a two-factor authentication license included. With these boxes, you can also create VDOM (Virtual Domains, totally separate).

They can afford that as the hardware, as I mentioned before (ASIC) has the power to do that. In 3 years I have had 1 spam message entering my mail server, is that telling you something??? In my first reply, I did tell you that where I work now they purchase Sophos. Well, when the antivirus is set the CPU gets up to 90%. My Fortigate CPU is 0% and peaks during attacks. And I have had quite a few. They were attempting to break into the mail server. More than 2 million attempts in less than 2 hours. Have a look at NSS Labs site. FortiGate is a Rolls Royce, you cannot compare.

Here in Australia, where I work now, the decision was to go with Sophos, ONLY ON PRICE. Yes, great brains. Now they regret that big time. FortiGate is a much more powerful device, especially when it comes to being able to handle the traffic. Most of the models handle throughput via ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) which is nothing more and less than a customer semiconductor. So, this is handled via hardware. It may be initially more difficult to implement. Now, what does "difficult" mean? To me when there is an unknown, difficult comes up till you learn. So if you make a decision on price and because "it is the easiest" to install.

I would not touch Sophos. Simple as that.

it_user1136043 - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Manager at alfascan
Real User
2020-02-17T18:27:09Z
Feb 17, 2020

Sophos UTM is better by far. but it is more expensive

Nawaaz Toonah - PeerSpot reviewer
Operations Manager at Cybernaptics
Reseller
Top 5Leaderboard
2020-02-17T16:05:24Z
Feb 17, 2020

Done many installations of both Sophos and FortiGate, Sophos is the easiest to install and best in terms of features.
Reporting is free in Sophos while we need an extra subscription for FortiGate. Deep packet inspection, intrusion prevention advanced threat protection, web filtering, app control and email protection are key features of Sophos. Browsing is made safe with phishing protection and new functionality of ransomware protection. Sophos support is brilliant and community website from Sophos answers to all your questions and ease deployment.

Ronald Rosenbaum - PeerSpot reviewer
Managing Director at The IT Agency Pty Ltd
Real User
2020-02-17T06:58:16Z
Feb 17, 2020

I can’t really comment on FortiGate. We’ve been working with Sophos for years and like it’s integration with their endpoint.

PT
Manager - SCADA & OT SECURITY at a energy/utilities company with 10,001+ employees
Real User
2020-03-23T17:46:58Z
Mar 23, 2020

I will recommend the Fortinet being very aggressive in the firewall terminology.
Fortinet Devices are Multi-Utility Next generation Firewall which can give your facility of L2 as well as L3 functions along with transparent and NAT mode of Firewall.
Moreover it provides your the AV, IPS,Application Control, Web Filter etc. on Proxy as well Flow based inspection modes.
Their support line also very good. One must try it. Further if you have need of Monitoring Industrial Protocols then it is one of the best choice in market

Related Questions
MF
User at Sameh Electronics (SamehGroup)
Jun 6, 2022
Hi security and IT pros, Which firewall product would you choose for your company: FortiGate 200F or Sophos XG 310? Why this would be your choice? Thanks in advance. 
See 2 answers
MV
Consultant with 11-50 employees
May 25, 2022
FortiGate. Fortinet is in Gartner Leader Magic Quadrant (MQ).  Sophos is in Niche Player Quadrant if I remember right.  You can never go wrong picking a vendor in the Gartner Leader MQ. Show the Gartner MQ to your leadership to get them on board too.
fdiazm - PeerSpot reviewer
Product Manager at Entel Chile
Jun 6, 2022
Hi,  If I look at it only from the point of view of analytics and performance, I lean towards Fortinet, but if I look at it at the service level and with the possibility of being part of an even larger project, this is when I don't see competitors for Fortinet and I mean the component. of after-sales services, the local presence in my country has come from less to more, which makes the difference when choosing a partner to work with.
ID
User at Zm3
May 15, 2022
Hi community members, I'm considering replacing a Cisco ASA Firewall with Fortinet FortiGate FG 100F. This is in order to reduce the cost. Is this the right thing to do? What would be your advice? Please elaborate. Thank you for your help!
2 out of 8 answers
Luis Apodaca - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Support and Network Admin at Escuela Carlos Pereyra
May 9, 2022
Hi @Isaiah Dominic, ​I have a few questions:Does replace mean that you already have a Cisco device? What's the reason for replacing it if is working? So, I assume it's not working. In that case, I have the second question:I suppose you should have a configuration backup for using it, in case your device crashes. How much do you value all that job? Is the cost of the new different device worth it?  If you make the change you gonna need to config the whole thing from scratch!! Is it worth it?Both devices are good enough.I expect this could help you,  Good luck!
DanielValente - PeerSpot reviewer
Head of Platforms and Infrastructure at LOQR
May 9, 2022
Hi,  You are comparing a piece of old equipment with a true next-gen firewall.  Nevertheless, there is a specific use case where I did this exact exercise and went with Cisco ASA, if the main objective is to terminate IPsec tunnels, in this field (more close to routing) ASA is excellent.  But if you are looking for URL filtering application visibility, and easiness of management go with FortiGate, for sure.
Moderator
davidstrom - PeerSpot reviewer
Owner at David Strom Inc.
Download Free Report
Download our FREE report comparing Fortinet FortiGate and Sophos UTM based on reviews, features, and more! Updated: November 2022.
DOWNLOAD NOW
653,522 professionals have used our research since 2012.