2022-06-18T12:28:00Z
KK
Quality Executive at Dharampal Premchand Limited(DPPCL)
  • 6
  • 121

Which Email Security enterprise solution would you choose: Cisco Secure Email vs Forcepoint Email Security vs Barracuda Email Security Gateway?

Hello,

I work as a Quality Executive at a Consumer Goods company. 

At the moment, we're researching an email security solution. We have 1000+ users.

Among others, we've been looking at these products: Cisco Secure Email, Forcepoint Email Security and Barracuda Email Security Gateway. 

Which of those solutions would you recommend? Please explain its advantages.

Would you recommend any different enterprise product? Why?

I appreciate the help.

7
PeerSpot user
7 Answers
TO
Consulting Partner, Cyber Security Delivery - Africa at DeltaGRiC Consulting
Reseller
2022-06-21T07:35:12Z
Jun 21, 2022

Hi Kamal, 


Firstly, you would have to recognize that there is/are no fast and hard rules to choosing a final preferred product, what works well for company A may not work extensively well for company B. Reason being that: the efficiency of the Security capabilities provided by one tool can be amplified by another tool, particularly for secure email gateway. Hence, if you have an XDR that you intend to leverage with your final product of choice, you will notice that you could experience a greater ROI than having a bare SEG tool.


However, I will advise based on a few realities of today's market in Q3 2022.


1. From my perspective, It will make sense if you take advantage of the built-in protection capabilities from your cloud email provider (I assume you are using O365 or Google mail) rather than investing in a secure email gateway (SEG). 


2. Most forward-thinking organizations are shifting away from traditional SEG tools and moving towards ICES, in my opinion, you should ideally be looking for an email security solutions that use ML / AI-based anti-phishing technology for BEC protection to analyze conversation history to detect anomalies, as well as computer vision to analyze suspect links within emails.


3. Should you still choose to pursue SEG asides from an ICES, or you choose to go for an ICES, bear in mind that nothing beats doing a POC as it clearly should consider the security apparatus/investments you have already made in times past.


4. it will be best that you look for solutions that integrate directly into your cloud email via an API, rather than as a gateway, this will ease your evaluation and eventual deployment, besides it improving your detection accuracy, while still taking advantage of the integration of the bulk of phishing protection with the core platform


5. Without having an insight into your current email provider (cloud/on-prem) or other tools in your organization or budget, it will be difficult to give you a bit of precise advice.


Either way, all the best with your selection process, and wishing you a cyber-safe organization.



Product comparison that may be of interest to you
SC
Cyber Security Advisor - Director at Fort Net UK
MSP/MSSP
Top 5Leaderboard
2022-06-21T13:57:36Z
Jun 21, 2022

Tunde is absolutely right and is what I was trying to say in my first answer, Tunde did a better job though. AI based tools without a gateway can be installed in minutes, will pick up more malicious attachments, more content related bad stuff, provide better visibility and introduce controls for you staff to further improve the effectiveness. Typically these tools learn over time and therefore get better as you use them.


Don't forget to consider 3rd party risk by looking at DMARC, SPF & DKIM as well as domain impersonation

Remy Ma - PeerSpot reviewer
Network Security Services at ACE Managed Securty Services
Real User
Top 5
2022-12-12T07:19:15Z
Dec 12, 2022

Have you considered Proofpoint Email Protection? It’s not one of the options you listed, but I recommend Proofpoint for advanced email security to everyone.


Proofpoint Email Protection defends organizations against advanced email-borne threats, including spear phishing and business email compromise (BEC) attacks. Proofpoint provides inbound and outbound email filtering with industry-leading accuracy to protect users from email-based malware, ransomware, and other sophisticated threats. Proofpoint also helps organizations defend against targeted attacks that use spear phishing emails to bypass traditional security defenses. Proofpoint's  Email Protection solution is powered by the Proofpoint Global Intelligence Network (GIN), which processes billions of threat indicators every day to deliver real-time protection against the latest email threats. This combination of technology and intelligence makes Proofpoint Email Protection the most effective way to defend against advanced email-borne threats.

Remy Ma - PeerSpot reviewer
Network Security Services at ACE Managed Securty Services
Real User
Top 5
2022-10-06T02:45:31Z
Oct 6, 2022

I highly recommend Proofpoint Email Security. My organization has had a great experience so far. The solution completely lives up to its price point.


Proofpoint is an industry-leading email gateway, which can be deployed as a cloud service or on-premises. Apart from providing essential encryption and spam filtering, Proofpoint Email Security solutions also have specific controls to stop BEC attacks. That’s what impressed me because Business Email Compromise attacks have devastating consequences for businesses. Proofpoint has an in-built Advanced BEC Defense engine that’s powered by AI and machine learning. It analyzes multiple message attributes, like header data, sender’s IP address, and message body for red flags and urgency.


We use Managed Proofpoint Security. Managed email security providers like ACE MSS provide Proofpoint Email Security solutions in an end-to-end managed service. With managed email security, you no longer have to worry about managing encryption keys or sudden email attacks. You’ll have a dedicated team of security experts monitoring and analyzing all incoming and outgoing email traffic.

ED
Owner at Jolly Security Inc
Real User
Top 5
2022-06-21T20:32:22Z
Jun 21, 2022

Between the two? I prefer Cisco over Forcepoint. If budget is not a problem a hybrid Cisco Forcepoint multilayer. Or a hybrid Cloud + on-premises. 

Bur someone asked about three options...? Which was the third? Why was intentionally avoided Proofpoint and compared "Sharks" with "Piranhas" or Barracudas?

DM
Security Technician at Mercadona
Real User
2022-06-21T06:11:15Z
Jun 21, 2022

I only can recommend Cisco because it´s the only one with which I'd worked enough. I think it is powerful enough and has a lot of possibilities. In addition, to a great support team. 

Find out what your peers are saying about Barracuda Email Security Gateway vs. Cisco Secure Email and other solutions. Updated: January 2023.
670,331 professionals have used our research since 2012.
SC
Cyber Security Advisor - Director at Fort Net UK
MSP/MSSP
Top 5Leaderboard
2022-06-20T15:48:31Z
Jun 20, 2022

Top brands don't mean best or most cost-effective. My advice is to look a bit further before you make a decision.


Evidence suggests that most top brands are pretty good at detecting and blocking malicious attachments, best case letting through 1%, but can be worse than 50% when it comes to detecting malicious links in the text of the email. 


There are numerous less well-known vendors with lower-cost AI-based solutions that have a far better success rate, also providing employees the ability to report on suspect emails which auto-removes them from other staff members' inboxes until they have been properly assessed. Some will provide a visual risk score to the recipient to give them advance warning to be more cautious.


Combining this kind of capability with staff awareness products keeps your vendor list lower and further improves efficiency.


For around £2 GBP per user per month (less than $3) we provide different vendors depending upon the customer's environment but provided as a managed service. This allows our customers to outsource some of the monitoring and day-to-day management, spread the cost on a monthly basis, and flex how many licences they need on a monthly basis too i.e. if you drop 20 users don't pay for them but if you increase by 20 you don't need complex co-termination and pro rata discussions.

Related Questions
it_user434868 - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior Director of Delivery at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
Jan 24, 2023
Hi Everyone, What do you like most about Barracuda Email Security Gateway? Thanks for sharing your thoughts with the community!
2 out of 27 answers
AJ
Solution Architect at a tech services company with 501-1,000 employees
Sep 15, 2019
It is an excellent, intelligent solution that provides maximum security from email attacks.
KA
Deputy Manager IT Operations (Senior System Administrator) at a transportation company with 1,001-5,000 employees
Feb 6, 2020
The performance is good.
Miriam Tover - PeerSpot reviewer
Service Delivery Manager at PeerSpot
Dec 15, 2022
If you were talking to someone whose organization is considering Barracuda Email Security Gateway, what would you say? How would you rate it and why? Any other tips or advice?
2 out of 25 answers
AJ
Solution Architect at a tech services company with 501-1,000 employees
Sep 15, 2019
As far as advice to other organizations considering this solution, I would generally recommend the product. But it depends. I can recommend Barracuda as a user because I have not had any problem with it. But if your organization has a limited budget, you might want to consider going with Trend Micro. Trend Micro is also a very good product, and it is a little cheaper than Barracuda when it comes to pricing structure. But Trend Micro is also not as easy to implement and use as Barracuda. So you would have to determine whether Barracuda is worth investing in so that you save time and effort. Barracuda costs a little more, but it is easier to use, more user-friendly and has a little better reputation. On a scale from one to ten, with one being the worst and ten being the best, I would rate Barracuda Email Security Gateway as a seven out of ten. This rating is lower even though I am completely satisfied with this product as a solution. The big problem is not the product, but the support — which I consider a very important factor. If I can't get support on time or I have to work inconvenient hours to get live support, this ends up affecting our services. One other thing I think I should mention is that the reporting system for Barracuda is very good. Good reporting is important to the utilization of the product in an efficient manner.
KA
Deputy Manager IT Operations (Senior System Administrator) at a transportation company with 1,001-5,000 employees
Feb 6, 2020
I would rate this solution an eight out of ten.
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technology products and we want your vote! If there’s a technology solution that’s really impressed you, here’s an opportunity to recognize that. It’s easy: go to the PeerSpot voting site, complete the brief voter registration form, review the list of nominees and vote. Get your colleagues to vote, too! ...
Deena Nouril - PeerSpot reviewer
Tech Blogger
Aug 5, 2022
What is OWASP? The OWASP or Open Web Application Security Project is a nonprofit foundation dedicated to improving software security. It operates under an open community model, meaning that anyone can participate in and contribute to OWASP-related online chats and projects. The OWASP ensures that its offerings (online tools, videos, forums, events, etc.) remain free and are easily accessible t...
See 2 comments
Ben Arbeit - PeerSpot reviewer
Manager at a retailer with 51-200 employees
Jul 31, 2022
Thanks for this informative article.
Jairo Willian Pereira - PeerSpot reviewer
Information Security Manager at a retailer with 10,001+ employees
Aug 5, 2022
OWASP is nice, but very specific and currently limited. How about trying ISO-24772 for all?
EB
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
Mar 4, 2022
Hi community members, Here is our new Community Spotlight for YOU. We publish it to help you catch up on recent contributions by community members. Do you find it useful? Please comment below! Trending Top HCI in 2022 What are the main differences between XDR and SIEM? Articles Top 5 Ethernet Switches in 2022 SASE: what is it and what are the main benefits? Questions Che...
RC
Enterprise Architect at CDPL
Dec 15, 2021
Privacy Concerns in an RPA Implementation Program. The biggest concern we (as RPA solution implementors) have faced when interacting with clients and customers were: 1. Regulatory and Compliance issues. 2. InfoSec and Security issues. 3. Audit Issues. Regulatory and Compliance Issues: There is a huge penalty if the wrong data gets updated and emails are sent to customers by the regulatory...
TS
CEO at Rufusforyou
Sep 3, 2021
ICT is getting more and more complex: today I have several systems in Chicago, several more in Amsterdam and if you need to protect your environment you will need to check on-premises, the cloud at Amazon, and the cloud at Microsoft Azure.  Why is Performance related to security? For the following reasons:  Today we need more than one tool to protect our environment. You need anti-spoofing...
See 2 comments
SB
Regional Manager/ Service Delivery Manager at ASPL INFO Services
Sep 1, 2021
Very good insights about correlation for security with performance.
JD
Key Account Manager at ITRS Group
Sep 3, 2021
Interesting positioning and way of thinking, thank you very much for the article!
Product Comparisons
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
PeerSpot User's Choice Award 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technol...
Deena Nouril - PeerSpot reviewer
Tech Blogger
Aug 5, 2022
What is OWASP Top 10 in 2022
What is OWASP? The OWASP or Open Web Application Security Project is a nonprofit foundation dedi...
Download Free Report
Download our FREE report comparing Barracuda Email Security Gateway and Cisco Secure Email based on reviews, features, and more! Updated: January 2023.
DOWNLOAD NOW
670,331 professionals have used our research since 2012.