Google Compute Engine and SAP S4HANA on AWS compete in cloud services. SAP S4HANA on AWS appears to have the upper hand due to its superior real-time processing and advanced analytics.
Features: Google Compute Engine offers flexible virtual machine customization, preemptible VMs for cost savings, and seamless integration with Google services for automation. SAP S4HANA on AWS provides an in-memory database, real-time data processing, and comprehensive analytics capabilities, ideal for ERP systems in financial and manufacturing sectors.
Room for Improvement: Google Compute Engine could improve its user interface, simplify security settings, and enhance intuitive auto-scaling features. SAP S4HANA on AWS is criticized for its high cost, complex integration, and a need for a more modern GUI with better support for additional cloud providers.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Google Compute Engine offers straightforward deployment on public cloud infrastructure with community-driven support, though customer support can be inconsistent. SAP S4HANA on AWS provides multiple deployment options, including hybrid and private clouds, with generally reliable support, although the setup can be complex and requires careful planning for optimal integration.
Pricing and ROI: Google Compute Engine's pay-as-you-go model offers flexibility and cost-effectiveness, particularly in development and testing environments, benefiting from integration with other Google services. SAP S4HANA on AWS is more expensive with substantial initial investments, but large enterprises find the comprehensive service quality justifies the cost for robust, integrated solutions.
On a very good implementation, usually, if the scale of the business is large, the implementation can give a payback within six, seven, or eight months of implementation.
Although our investment was higher compared to the previous ERP system, we are able to derive ROI from SAP S4HANA on AWS.
We received the right support during our implementation and continue to benefit from it.
They have a support model available, with first-level support handling initial issues when I integrate the system.
AWS has been running probably 96% of Fortune 500 companies across the globe, so scalability is not an issue.
The product is versatile and can manage complexity beyond expectations.
As a finance controller, we have seen improvements in finance deliverables, SLAs in payables, and reconciliation timelines.
Having these integrations as a single source rather than working in silos would be beneficial for customers.
SAP introduced flexible workflows, which are even better if I want customized workflows for my documentation within the procurement domain.
The interface and interaction with the technical team require intensive training.
The initial setup required a higher investment, but the return on investment has justified the cost.
SAP is not cheap, with many hidden costs encountered during implementation.
In GCP, there's a custom configuration feature unlike AWS and Azure.
The costing and personnel planning integration are among the strongest areas of this solution.
From the finance side, we have enhanced our internal controls and reduced the timeline for closing the month from a year to just two days.
The configurations are quite comprehensive, and the product can handle many complex scenarios.
Google Compute Engine delivers virtual machines running in Google's innovative data centers and worldwide fiber network. Compute Engine's tooling and workflow support enable scaling from single instances to global, load-balanced cloud computing.
Compute Engine's VMs boot quickly, come with persistent disk storage, and deliver consistent performance. Our virtual servers are available in many configurations including predefined sizes or the option to create Custom Machine Types optimized for your specific needs. Flexible pricing and automatic sustained use discounts make Compute Engine the leader in price/performance.
SAP customers of all sizes can fully realize all the benefits of the SAP S/4HANA, on-premise edition on the AWS Cloud. With SAP S/4HANA, on-premise edition on the AWS Cloud you can:
We monitor all Infrastructure as a Service Clouds (IaaS) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.