

Barracuda SecureEdge and Zscaler Private Access compete in network security, providing secure access solutions. Zscaler Private Access has an edge due to its advanced features, while Barracuda SecureEdge offers competitive pricing and support.
Features: Barracuda SecureEdge integrates with existing security systems, delivers comprehensive threat management, and offers seamless compatibility. Zscaler Private Access provides zero trust architecture, seamless connectivity, and a robust security model that distinguishes it in this category.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Barracuda SecureEdge stands out for its straightforward deployment process and reliable customer service, ensuring a smooth client transition. Zscaler Private Access presents a more complex deployment due to its advanced architecture but maintains strong customer support, albeit with a steeper learning curve.
Pricing and ROI: Barracuda SecureEdge attracts with competitive pricing, offering strong ROI and efficient cost management. Zscaler Private Access has a higher price point but justifies this with significant value through enhanced security features and long-term benefits, reflecting a worthwhile investment for its capabilities.
Considering the security features and centralized management capability it provides, we feel it offers good value for the investment.
It has enhanced visibility into user activity and helped enforce consistent security policies across different locations.
I estimate that routing network administration and policy management activities require roughly 30 to 40% less effort than before, allowing our team to focus on higher priority projects rather than day-to-day maintenance.
The ROI is often cited around 289% over the three years of typical enterprises.
I have found Zscaler Private Access (ZPA) to be very effective at providing operational flexibility during my organization's transition to cloud environments.
Since we have a very small team, the ROI is around 20% to 30%.
The support team for Barracuda SecureEdge is responsive, knowledgeable, and helpful when troubleshooting issues.
The engineers have been able to provide useful guidance during troubleshooting and implementation activities.
The ticketing system is very efficient, and they provide support promptly.
The technical support for ZPA is excellent, rated ten out of ten.
We had regular calls, and the team was open and willing to assist us whenever required.
We lack specific root causes, and it's tough to relay information to users, considering multiple contributors such as phone numbers and internet service providers.
The centralized management platform makes it easy to manage growth without significantly increasing administrative effort.
The centralized cloud management makes it easy to support additional users, locations and security requirements.
Barracuda SecureEdge has good scalability because it is a cloud-based solution.
Zscaler ZPA has excellent scalability.
I rate the scalability of ZPA as ten out of ten because it's a cloud service and can scale as needed.
We need to deploy it and ensure it will be available in two different Availability Zones, but it's not something that can be done with automation, such as auto-scaling.
The platform has provided consistent performance for both security management and remote connectivity.
It has improved consistent performance for security connectivity and remote access.
Even during peak usage or mass remote access events, performance remains consistent, which is critical for an enterprise environment handling business-critical applications.
The architecture uses a global mesh of service edges with built-in fault tolerance and redundancy, providing an always-on experience.
We implemented a resilient solution with load balance to ensure stability, which has proven effective thus far.
If Barracuda's security team could provide some use cases on how to secure the remote access of contractors and remote users who are facilitating utilities like energy sectors and water treatment plants, it would give a very good edge to Barracuda's security team.
Compared to leading SASE vendors, Barracuda SecureEdge is still evolving and lacks some advanced features and integration depth that may require evaluating for large and global enterprises.
One area where I believe the product could be enhanced is in reporting and analytics, with more customizable dashboards and deeper insight for security and performance monitoring.
It complicates whitelisting, as we cannot determine which IP will be used, posing a challenge when needing to integrate with third parties.
I would appreciate seeing dynamic scaling implemented because it would be beneficial if an instance goes down to automatically start another one.
While Zscaler Private Access (ZPA) wants users to utilize their infrastructure for scale benefits, regulated environments such as government and investment banks need on-premises processing for regulations and low latency requirements.
My experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing is acceptable.
It is expensive.
Although the solution is costly, its features justify the price for securing the organization from various access types.
While it is a premium investment, the short payback period of about 11 months and consolidation of multiple point products make it very cost-effective in the long run.
The best features that Barracuda SecureEdge offers, in my experience, start with a Secure Web Gateway for internet traffic protection, Zero Trust Network Access, SD-WAN integration, Firewall as a Service, centralized policy and management, remote user security, work-from-home capabilities, branch connectivities plus cloud security, and application-level access control.
It simplified policy management, reduced the time spent on administration and gave us better visibility across all locations.
The best features Barracuda SecureEdge offers are its centralized cloud-based management, secure remote access capabilities, and ease of deployment.
Zscaler pre-tests websites and authorizes safe access, giving us a layer of security that we rely on.
Zscaler Private Access (ZPA) is much more secure than VPN because users are only allowed to access specific applications rather than the whole network.
Zscaler has allowed an easy, secure way for us to access our internal resources from outside.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Zscaler Private Access (ZPA) | 2.0% |
| Barracuda SecureEdge | 1.6% |
| Other | 96.4% |

| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 5 |
| Large Enterprise | 4 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 2 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 4 |
| Large Enterprise | 7 |
Barracuda SecureEdge is a comprehensive security platform designed to provide robust protection, streamline operations, and ensure compliance. It caters to businesses looking for secure and efficient network solutions.
Barracuda SecureEdge offers a range of tools to enhance security across your infrastructure. It integrates seamlessly with existing networks, managing risks through advanced threat intelligence. Known for its user-friendly experience, it aids businesses in maintaining security standards while optimizing network performance.
What are the essential features of Barracuda SecureEdge?In industries like finance and healthcare, Barracuda SecureEdge can be instrumental in meeting compliance standards while ensuring data integrity. Its deployment strategy aligns well with the requirements of sectors needing high security and regulatory adherence. Efficient threat detection and mitigation capabilities are crucial for these sensitive fields.
Zscaler Private Access enhances security by enabling access to specific applications without exposing entire networks. It is designed for scalability and flexibility, making it particularly suitable for cloud transitions and remote work environments.
Zscaler Private Access offers a comprehensive solution for modern security needs by ensuring secure remote application access. This is achieved through its advanced features such as micro-segmentation and AI capabilities. Organizations can integrate ZPA with existing security infrastructure, providing seamless operation during cloud transitions. Users benefit from policy-based access management and dashboards that enhance visibility and control. However, ZPA faces some challenges, including bugs, configuration difficulties with identity providers, and a limited rule customization capacity. Delayed support responses and annual price increases are also concerns that need addressing.
What are the key features of Zscaler Private Access?Zscaler Private Access is widely adopted across industries transitioning from traditional VPNs to more secure remote access solutions. Companies leverage it for secure network communication, accessing cloud resources like AWS and Azure, and integrating with internal systems. Local, customer, and cloud networks extensively use ZPA for secure internet access and as a modern replacement for older proxy technologies.
We monitor all Cloud Access Security Brokers (CASB) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.