AWS Secrets Manager vs Idira Secrets Management comparison

AWS Secrets Manager vs. Idira Secrets Management

Download the complete report

Helped 896,692 peers since 2012

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Categories and Ranking

AWS Secrets Manager

Ranking in Enterprise Password Managers

2nd

Ranking in Secrets Management Tools

3rd

Average Rating

9.0

Reviews Sentiment

6.8

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Idira Secrets Management

Ranking in Enterprise Password Managers

19th

Ranking in Secrets Management Tools

6th

Average Rating

7.2

Reviews Sentiment

5.9

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Mindshare comparison

As of June 2026, in the Secrets Management Tools category, the mindshare of AWS Secrets Manager is 39.9%, up from 39.1% compared to the previous year. The mindshare of Idira Secrets Management is 2.1%, up from 0.5% compared to the previous year. It is calculated based on PeerSpot user engagement data.

Secrets Management Tools Mindshare Distribution
Product	Mindshare (%)
AWS Secrets Manager	39.9%
CyberArk Secrets Management	2.1%
Other	58.0%

Secrets Management Tools

Featured Reviews

Mahadev Metre

DevOps Engineer at Paydoh

Consistent security and efficiency improvements optimize IT infrastructure with effective management

When creating AWS Secrets Manager, it should be automated using tools such as Terraform, Puppet, or Ansible. With Terraform code, you specify the encryption key, secret name, rotation policy, and secret replication. Human error occurs when feeding secret values manually, especially with large amounts of secrets to input. Secrets should never be protected only by IAM. They should be protected by multiple layers, such as IAM and one or two KMS keys. Additional security measures could be beneficial if necessary. The rotation policy is crucial because some secrets may become obsolete, require updates, or get compromised. With a weekly rotation policy, if unauthorized access occurs, the exposure is limited to seven days. The rotation policy can be customized according to needs.

Read full review

Ashish Pandey

Delivery Manager at Tech Mahindra Limited

Provides secure secret management with granular controls and professional support

The tool is very good, but the commercialized training, which is paid, could be improved. Regularizing those trainings as part of a global alliance between the customer, SI partner, and CyberArk would be more profitable, allowing relevant SMEs to be trained better. There are training courses available that sometimes provide coupons on a yearly basis. If those coupons increase from about 10 to 20 people, it would provide better opportunities for SI partners Tech Mahindra to train resources and gain visibility with customers. There are indeed paid training courses for partners, and while they shouldn't be entirely free, the coupons can make them free. Increasing those coupons would allow more resources to be trained rather than limiting them to just two or three.

Read full review

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Pros

"It's highly scalable, so I'd rate it a ten out of ten."

"AWS Secrets Manager plays a significant role in optimizing IT infrastructure security and efficiency."

"I would highly recommend AWS Secrets Manager for secret management in AWS."

"Integrating with other services was straightforward, especially within the AWS environment."

"The most valuable feature is usability, as it is quite user-friendly."

"The API is fine and works well."

"In summary, this is a good product and well suits our needs."

"The most valuable feature is the management of credentials."

More AWS Secrets Manager pros

"The granular controls of CyberArk Secrets Management are very niche in their development and very secure from the overall secret management perspective, offering high-level functionalities where we have control over user access, which can be tracked and monitored."

"It's vital for effectively managing and securing my credentials."

"The automatic rotation of the password is the top feature."

"The audit trails have been extremely important for us in helping our organization meet regulatory requirements."

"CyberArk Secrets Management is a critical solution for strengthening our security posture."

"CyberArk's support team is knowledgeable and helpful, consistently responding on time."

"One of the most important features for us is the system's performance, particularly its speed of retrieving secrets."

"With CyberArk Secrets Management, we were able to resolve the automatic change of the passwords based on timelines. We were also able to retrieve the passwords in an encrypted format by utilizing the CyberArk platform, which was not provided to us by UiPath."

Cons

"The sidecar feature has room for improvement."

"We occasionally have problems with rate limits, although that is a problem more generally with AWS."

"There is room for improvement in the pricing model."

"If you don't have enterprise support, then you will not be able to get through to them to get the help."

"The solution's initial setup process is complicated."

"We occasionally have problems with rate limits, although that is a problem more generally with AWS."

"It would be good if the AWS Secrets Manager were more customizable."

"If you add one more layer of security to AWS Secrets Manager, even the programmer will not be able to see the secrets."

More AWS Secrets Manager cons

"We did not have a good experience with technical support because their numerous processes caused delays in engaging, leading to project delays or issues with production."

"Improvements for CyberArk Secrets Management include enhanced documentation with more use cases and step-by-step integration guides."

"The password search feature and integration between different vaults could be enhanced. For instance, when updating passwords in both lower and higher environment vaults, improvement is required in search and upgrade functions."

"Implementation was complex and required professional services."

"There is room for improvement with better documentation and less need for CyberArk Secrets Management personnel to assist us with their presence."

"We occasionally experience incidents that delay password injection back into the script."

"Implementing it and ensuring seamless password rotations present challenges."

Pricing and Cost Advice

"I don't believe there is a license cost for the solution."

"We purchase a monthly license for the product."

"We've observed that AWS Secrets Manager pricing is based on a per-secret-per-month model. As a result, we prefer to divide our secrets into individual pieces to increase security and grant specific access permissions to certain secrets, systems, or individuals. However, this approach results in higher costs. Therefore, we have been exploring ways to combine our secrets into groups to reduce expenses and simplify management. Nonetheless, we acknowledge that this issue may not be related to the secret manager's functionality."

"The solution is expensive."

"The cost is somewhat high."

"It is in the middle. It is neither very cheap nor very expensive, so I would place it in the middle."

"CyberArk Secrets Management has a moderate pricing structure based on a per-tenant licensing model rather than a per-user account model like their PAM solution."

See which vendors are best for you

Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Secrets Management Tools solutions are best for your needs.

See recommendations

896,692 professionals have used our research since 2012.

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews

Financial Services Firm

13%

Computer Software Company

Manufacturing Company

Comms Service Provider

Financial Services Firm

17%

Comms Service Provider

12%

Insurance Company

10%

Marketing Services Firm

Company Size

By reviewers

Large Enterprise

Midsize Enterprise

Small Business

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	8
Large Enterprise	10

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	1
Large Enterprise	6

Questions from the Community

Which is better - Azure Key Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

Azure Key Vault is a SaaS solution. You can easily store passwords and secrets securely and encrypt them. Azure Key Vault is a great solution to ensure you are compliant with security and governanc...

Which is better - HashiCorp Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

HashiCorp Vault was designed with your needs in mind. One of the features that makes this evident is its ability to work as both a cloud-agnostic and a multi-cloud solution. As a cloud-agnostic sol...

What needs improvement with AWS Secrets Manager?

AWS Secrets Manager could not be better because there has been no frustration with the product.

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for CyberArk Secrets Management?

One of the CPL licenses costs around 60 to 80k GBP.

What needs improvement with CyberArk Secrets Management?

What is your primary use case for CyberArk Secrets Management?

The main use case for CyberArk Secrets Management is application integrations and the CI and CD part. In CyberArk Secrets Management, there are a variety of tools that they cover, one being the Cre...

Azure Key Vault vs AWS Secrets Manager

Comparisons

Compared 83% of the time

HashiCorp Vault vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 3% of the time

1Password Business vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 3% of the time

Idira Privileged Access Manager vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 2% of the time

More AWS Secrets Manager Competitors

HashiCorp Vault vs Idira Secrets Management

Compared 43% of the time

Thales SafeNet Trusted Access vs Idira Secrets Management

Compared 21% of the time

BeyondTrust DevOps Secrets Safe vs Idira Secrets Management

Compared 16% of the time

Bitwarden vs Idira Secrets Management

Compared 7% of the time

Microsoft Entra ID vs Idira Secrets Management

Compared 6% of the time

More Idira Secrets Management Competitors

Product Reports

Enterprise Password Managers

Download AWS Secrets Manager product report

Idira Secrets Management

Download Idira Secrets Management product report

Overview

AWS Secrets Manager offers key-value storage, credential management, and secure access permissions, streamlining the handling of API keys and secret information within the AWS environment.

AWS Secrets Manager integrates seamlessly with AWS services, supporting secure management of credentials and encryption with KMS. It enhances security and efficiency with automated secret retrieval, IAM roles, and version control. While its simplicity and cost-effectiveness are notable, there is potential for improvement in rate limits, integrating with platforms like Azure, and addressing small organization pricing. Its centralized approach benefits auto-scaling, secure card details, microservices, and databases.

What are the main features of AWS Secrets Manager?

Key-Value Pair Storage: Stores credentials securely.
Credential Management: Manages system-to-system credentials.
Rotation Configurations: Supports Lambda-based automatic secret rotation.
Seamless Integration: Works smoothly with AWS services.
API Key Handling: Secure management of API keys and secrets.

What benefits should users consider when evaluating AWS Secrets Manager?

Enhanced Security: Automated encryption and secret retrieval.
Cost-Effectiveness: Reduces risks and facilitates AWS integration.
Operational Efficiency: Simplifies credential management.

AWS Secrets Manager is implemented in diverse industries for managing sensitive information, facilitating secure operations for microservices, GoLang applications, and databases. It supports orchestration and dynamic secret retrieval, beneficial for automated scaling and secure data access during application runtime.

Amazon Web Services (AWS)

CyberArk Secrets Management provides credential rotation automation, integration with applications, audit trails, and access controls to enhance security and efficiency.

CyberArk Secrets Management is a comprehensive solution for managing credentials across multiple platforms. It automates password rotation and integrates seamlessly with CI/CD tools, AWS, and healthcare industries. Its audit trails ensure compliance, while granular access controls boost security. Although its documentation needs improvement and some integrations have delays and setup complexities, it remains a scalable and efficient option for credential management.

What are the key features of CyberArk Secrets Management?

Credential Rotation Automation: Automatically rotates credentials to reduce human error.
Integration Capabilities: Connects with applications and tools like Bamboo and GitLab.
Granular Access Controls: Provides enhanced security through detailed access management.
Audit Trails: Supports compliance and regulatory requirements.

What benefits and ROI should users consider?

Enhanced Security: Reduces risks with automated credential management.
Regulatory Compliance: Maintains adherence to industry standards like HIPAA.
Operational Efficiency: Supports seamless integration with existing tools.

CyberArk Secrets Management is widely used in industries like healthcare and finance for secure credential handling. In the healthcare sector, it supports HIPAA compliance, ensuring sensitive data protection. Financial institutions rely on its automation and integration capabilities to handle sensitive information efficiently, minimizing manual errors and enhancing operational security.

Idira

Sample Customers

Autodesk, Clevy, Stackery

Information Not Available

AWS Secrets Manager vs. Idira Secrets Management