IT Central Station is now PeerSpot: Here's why

What are the advantages of AppDynamics vs Dynatrace?

Team Lead Middleware Engineering at a insurance company with 501-1,000 employees

I'm looking into AppDynamics and Dynatrace. What are the advantages of each?

PeerSpot user
66 Answers

reviewer1644402 - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5LeaderboardReseller

DT starts do a sampling of monitoring transactions when the application is under heavy load. It does this in order to keep performance overhead low. 

AppD monitors 100% of transactions 100% of the time for a max of 4% of overhead.

BoykoVasilev - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5Real User

Hi there, 

we did an assessment between AppDynamics and Dynatrace last year (2020). The winner was Dynatrace.

Dynatrace is a one agent concept, AppDynamics is based on multi agent design. One agent is easy to manage and support. Less change requests, CAB approvals, etc. One agent save time.

Dynatrace license is based on Host Unit, DEM units. AppDynamics is based on agent / technology. It's possible to exchange the license from one license to another (for example 2 DB license for 1 Java agent license), but this must be part of your agreement.

During the PoC we got a fully functional license from Dynatrace for more than 6 months and limited license from AppDynamics. Most of AppDynamics functionality wasn't able to test.

During the PoC we got full support from Dynatrace (dedicated technical person) and basic support from AppDynamics (most of the recommendation was to read the user guide).

AppDynamics wasn't able to create synthetic monitor based on our scenarios.

Dynatrace was able to configure almost all synthetic monitors based on our scenarios.

KevinSmith1 - PeerSpot reviewer
Real User

At application level, they are quite similar in their features. What made the difference in our cases where we wanted to use an on-premises solution was the cost of the VMs, because the Dynatrace servers needed way more resource (CPU, RAM, Storage) than within the AppDynamics solution. 

However, it can all depend on your needs and environment. 

reviewer1644402 - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5LeaderboardReseller

DT is unable to show transaction lock on DB. It does show "wait time" but you need to have a separate DB diagnostic tool to see a transaction lock. 

AppD will catch a DB transaction lock out of the box.

Tjeerd Saijoen - PeerSpot reviewer
Top 5LeaderboardReseller

Appdynamics need more customization, Dynatrace has a one agent and customization is very simple. Personally I find Dynatrace better looking and the interface easier to understand but this is more a matter of taste. In problem resolution I find both equal to handle. If I look to customize Appdynamics is more open than Dynatrace.

Gary Sun - PeerSpot reviewer

AppDynamics provides a longer baseline period. 

It better helps us in decreasing false alerts and increasing the quality of health rules. 

DT's one agent is a "big guy" (disk space, etc), not every machine has the space for this big guy.

Buyer's Guide
AppDynamics vs. Dynatrace
May 2022
Find out what your peers are saying about AppDynamics vs. Dynatrace and other solutions. Updated: May 2022.
609,272 professionals have used our research since 2012.