Sheila Doyle - PeerSpot reviewer
Policy Analyst at RCMP
  • 3
  • 161

Microsoft SharePoint (as RMS) vs OpenText Content Suite Platform - looking for recommendations

For an organization considering which platform to go with, realizing there are many factors involved, depending on the needs of the organization - for a Records Management System (as opposed to only a Document Management System) which would you suggest: Microsoft SharePoint or OpenText?

Adding in the fact that OpenText as well as some aspects of Microsoft but not neither is being used to its full extent, until further research, and all avenues have been explored thoroughly. Time, cost, retention and disposition capabilities (compliance), security, ease of integration, etc. These factors, as well as a few others (we will start with those) are crucial to moving forward. 

I'm speaking in general terms so I can relay the information to a general audience.

Thank you!


Details: Policy Analyst (Information Management/Technology), Government

PeerSpot user
3 Answers
User at FD
Top 5
Jun 22, 2021

Microsoft SharePoint is the flagship collaboration and content management product from Microsoft has over the years moved on to a much bigger role in the functionality and has now been used as an application development platform. It's now being used for developing department-level applications that have workflow capabilities, data storage, business rules.

So apart from the Content Management system, collaboration, document management, records management, it now supports application development as well.

Somewhat similar in nature is the usage of OpenText.

But as Microsoft SharePoint suffers from some inherent issues of data threshold and performance issues if asked to store and query data beyond 5000 records in a single query it hits low on performance.

Hope I have answered your queries.

Search for a product comparison in Enterprise Content Management
Toby Ward - PeerSpot reviewer
President at Prescient Digital Media
Top 5Leaderboard
Jun 21, 2021

Hi Sheila, 

OpenText is seen as a Records Management leader. SharePoint is not. However, it depends on what you need, and how you're using the records, etc. 

Now I am actually the local RCMP Block Watch captain for my block (and the adjoining block next to our school!), but I don't know exactly how records are being used or accessed. Or to what extent you're using other Microsoft products. 

If the RCMP were for example fully into Office 365 and already using SharePoint, Outlook, Teams, etc. then there might be a case to make for using SharePoint as an RM tool. But if you're looking purely at strict RM form and function, OpenText is a more mature product. 

Feel free to call if you want to discuss: 416.986.2226

WolfgangPichler - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior Consultant at pITsolutions
Jun 21, 2021

I would NOT recommend Microsoft Sharepoint for that.

From our point of view, IBM-Filenet is much better for these additional requirements -
even better than OpenText...

If you would like to exchange some details, please let me know

Learn what your peers think about Box. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: November 2022.
655,465 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Related Questions
Amar Yelane - PeerSpot reviewer
RPA Developer at DynPro Inc
Jan 20, 2022
Hi community members, In the process of transitioning from a legacy to a digital-first company, the scope of change may include people, systems, processes, and even attitudes and beliefs.  And at every level of change, a healthy transformation pipeline is needed. What are your tips and recommendations on how to build a healthy transformation pipeline?
See 1 answer
Shibu Babuchandran - PeerSpot reviewer
Regional Manager/ Service Delivery Manager at ASPL INFO Services
Jan 20, 2022
Hi @Amar Yelane ​, Hope the below points answers your query. Do let me know you views. Some Factors for Successful Digital Transformation1. OrientationEstablish a new perspective to drive meaningful change. If your organization is built on the “inside out” model, meaning that it is organized around your internal processes and functions, update to focus on customer needs, wants and priorities2. PeopleUnderstand customer values, expectations and behaviors. This requires digital transformation buy-in at all levels— all employees and leadership— so that the entire organization is aligned with digital goals and strategies.3. ProcessesAssess operational infrastructure and update (or revamp) technologies, processes and policies to support change. Start with the contact center, which is a key platform for delivering great customer experiences, and make it collaborative, unified, and intelligent4. ObjectivesDefine the purpose of digital transformation, aligning stakeholders (and shareholders) around the new vision and roadmap. Set goals for your digital transformation— what specific areas do you hope to improve through digital? What kind of metrics are you hoping to achieve? Setting quantifiable KPIs can help ensure that you meet your digital transformation objectives.5. StructureForm a dedicated digital experience team with roles/responsibilities/objectives/accountability clearly defined. Ensure the entire team is aware of objectives and processes so that you are centered on purpose.6. Insights & IntentGather data and apply insights toward strategy to guide digital evolution. Data can help you streamline experiences across customer journeys, no matter how they interact with your brand. Data can also help you evaluate the results— brand relevance, increased revenue, and more— of your digital transformation7. TechnologyRe-evaluate front and back-end systems for seamless, integrated and native customer experiences and, ultimately, employee experiences. Use technology to promote trustworthiness and meet ever-increasing customer expectations. Ensure your content and communications are platform-proof so that algorithm changes do not interfere with customer experiences8. ExecutionImplement, learn and adapt to steer ongoing digital transformation and customer experience work. Evaluate the state of your transformation frequently so you can make adjustments if necessary.
User at 2Five1
Jan 5, 2022
I'm considering using Sharepoint as an ECM tool. What are the benefits of using Sharepoint vs other ECM tools.platforms that are available?
See 1 answer
Andy Bretz - PeerSpot reviewer
Sr. Account Director at Spindustry Digital
Jan 5, 2022
Hello, there are a number of benefits:  1. SharePoint costs less - especially if your business is already using Office 365. You have access to SharePoint at virtually no additional cost in most cases.  2. SharePoint has built-in records management - if you need to save final, uneditable versions of files you can do this out of the box with SharePoint.  3. SharePoint security is exceptional - when you couple your SharePoint configuration with Active Directory you can control by user, by role, or by group, who has access, and what type of access to files.  4. SharePoint easily integrates with multiple file types - change names of word docs, play video files, catalog images, all from within SharePoint 5. SharePoint automatically catalogs multimedia files - any available metadata associated with images or videos is stored and indexed by SharePoint and can be used to find those files.  6. It's built by Microsoft, and backed by Microsoft. This is just one of the dozens of applications they support, and it's one of their flagship offerings. SharePoint is here to stay and you can find support easily. If you're ready to get started with SharePoint let me know. We're happy to consult with you on what it will take! 
Download Free Report
Download our free Box Report and get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: November 2022.
655,465 professionals have used our research since 2012.