Anyone have a good example of a Test Automation Business Case?

My company is looking into an SAP upgrade, and we have a very small staff. I am the lone SQA resource, and development takes on most of the testing. I have been tasked with looking into creating a business case for Test Automation. Any good templates exist, or examples to leverage while creating my own case? Any war stories and suggestions appreciated as well.  

I have looked at Panaya and Worksoft and Ranorex so far, with Tosca Testsuite up next. Trying to get a feel for best fit given our support limitations.  Thanks.

  • 30
  • 616
PeerSpot user
16 Answers
it_user437649 - PeerSpot reviewer
Product Manager SAP at Tricentis
Real User
May 4, 2016

Hi Greg,

When I am thinking about business case I think immediately about ROI.

I do not know if you have already used some tool to calculate it, I can advise you to look at our ROI Calculator http://www.tricentis.com/roi-calculator/, which could help you to understand your situation.

Automation of business processes can be done now even more easily with a new Tosca SAP Recorder. SAP Recorder allowing you to record your processes while interacting directly with SAP. This makes it super easy to create the right test cases for building up your regression testing portfolio. You can even create data driven test cases during recording as a valuable starting point for risk based testing.

This can be used to shift the creation of test cases from IT Department to business user. The execution (regression tests) will be done later on by IT. The result is clear, with limited IT budget you can fulfill the business requirements.

The integration with SAP Solution Manager can be also setup, it is not a case.

Have a look in ROI Calculation as a good starting point for your decision


Search for a product comparison in Functional Testing Tools
Presales Consultant at Oracle
Real User
May 4, 2016

A good business case will take into consideration the cost, time, the quality benefits if you were to test manually vs automation and the ROI if your company were to invest in automation. It would help if you had some comparisons to make e.g. how long it normally takes you to complete testing vs the time you would want to complete, how much you spend on testing (even if you don't have outside help, there's still cost of internal resources), have you encountered issues in production as a result of incomplete testing? Can you apply a monetary value to these issues?
List out all the current issues you're facing and align them to cost, time, quality.
Then list out the benefits of automation and align them to the issues you're facing.
Then talk 'dollars', e.g. if we spend x dollars on automation then we will save y dollars on re-work costs (as an example)
My first recommendation would be not to use a SAP upgrade as a launching pad for automation especially if you're the only one in QA. That's a major project to take on and automation tends to have a steep learning curve so you need to allocate sometime for everyone to come to speed with it.

it_user162282 - PeerSpot reviewer
Sales Engineer at Hewlett Packard Enterprise
May 5, 2016

Hi Greg,

I have the following article saved to my Bookmarks that references a lot of "Hard" and "Soft" considerations and tips for building a test automation business case: http://www.compaid.com/caiinternet/ezine/Galen1.pdf

From my experience for any team new to test automation there's a ramp up overhead which includes aspects such as learning new technology or procuring skilled resources, creating a test suite of robust scripts, and setting up the test automation lab infrastructure. This can create a type of break-even point, where initially test automation appears to cost more & take up more time than your manual testing efforts. Hence it's best to position test automation as an long term QA solution, rather than a quick win.

it_user357144 - PeerSpot reviewer
IT Professional (Business/Technical Analyst, Change/Release Management, Project Manager) at The281Group
May 5, 2016

There are a number of test automation business case slides on Slideshare (www.slideshare.net) you can look at. If you're a small company dealing with SAP and you've customized SAP you'll need test automation or you'll be 'winging it' on the upgrade. Also look at Original Sorftware (http://origsoft.com/). Their testing tools are reasonably priced. Also HP QA Center which is the old Mercury Interactive stuff may be able help. Also if the cost of testing is a factor you can, with the proper planning, oversight and management tools offshore your testing effort.

Hope this helps. If not give me a call or email.

it_user142806 - PeerSpot reviewer
Automation QA Specialist at a retailer with 1,001-5,000 employees
May 5, 2016

I would recommend UFT with BPT. This is excellent tool to modularize the automation testing in each department. You can start building the manual components and once you feel they built-ed good then you can start automating those manual components. You can easily drive excel data in the BPT Scripts. Let me know if you need any help in understanding of implementing BPT with excel driven data.
I have huge experience in implementing HP Product.

it_user346101 - PeerSpot reviewer
Principal Consultant with 51-200 employees
May 4, 2016

Hi, I have used an accelerated automation solution exclusively for SAP. This solutions automates your SAP transactions in few clicks and eliminates any development/coding efforts. It helped us to achieve complete end to end automation (500+ transactions) for our environment within few weeks time. It has built-in feature to update your scripts based on the changes in the applications. If interested, please let me know so I can explain further and provide demonstration for the same.

E: shakul@austeretech.com

Learn what your peers think about BrowserStack. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: May 2023.
706,775 professionals have used our research since 2012.
it_user279009 - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Professional Services with 1,001-5,000 employees
May 4, 2016

I worked on a test automation project with SAP for an international company for over 5 years. It was very successful. A VP of something stated it was the most mature QA automation in the company. We used HP's QTP (now UFT) and Business Process Testing (PBT). We have since developed our own very simple framework with an Excel front end allowing anyone, even non-technical people to develop automated scripts with a little training. So the BPT portion is not necessary. It not only saved the company $ but also increased the regression testing coverage. Well, there was no regression testing when we got there, manual or automated!

Interesting in today's QA environment that a company has to be convinced that automation is the right way to go. I get it - it is NOT a cheap endeavor but done correctly with the right tools, resources, processes and methodologies, it has been proven to be indispensable to any company that wants to run lean and mean and keep up with the competition. But Caroline has it right - you need to do your best to estimate an ROI. Hopefully you have strong manual test cases linked to requirements so you know your current test coverage and have good metrics regarding the resource hours for each test cycle. if you could automated 70% of your tests, how much time and effort would that save you? There is more to it but that is a start.

Feel free to contact me if you want to discuss further.


it_user371355 - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior Director, Software Development and Testing at Softcrylic
May 4, 2016

A good template for creating a business case for test automation is to present a case study with ROI, Pros and Cons of test automation. Start with how test automation in general can address your current pain points in testing and then create a hypothetical case study for ROI justification. Assuming there are 3 teams Team A - Completely Manual, Team - B - With 50% Test Cases Automated and Team C - With 100% Test Automation. Identify and compare how much time and cost it would take to complete a cycle of testing for these 3 teams, you can project Testing Cost Per Test Cycle and Testing Cost Over A Year and clearly show the ROI in test automation. One challenge you may encounter is to determine the time it takes to complete automated testing for every test cycle if you don't have any tests automated, but you can make some fair assumptions for your case study.

Test automation requires significant investment and engineering, but its benefits are worth the investment. One’s first impression is that automated testing, using the speed and flexibility of testing tools, must certainly speed up testing, increase software quality, and reduce the time to completion. Test Automation is not without its pitfalls; it may not be the least expensive or fastest approach to testing—in all situations. The challenge is to avoid the pitfalls, apply Test Automation intelligently, boost return on investment (ROI) and create a sustainable and scalable testing platform.

it_user437532 - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior Sales Consultant at TestPlant
Real User
May 4, 2016

It would help to learn about your requirements a little deeper. TestPlant is a great tool that can easily and efficiently help you automate your testing environment with minimal development resources. I'd love to connect for a quick chat and would be happy to create a custom demo for you to help build your case.

Please shoot me an email


it_user245676 - PeerSpot reviewer
Sr. Quality Assurance Software Lead at a healthcare company with 501-1,000 employees
May 4, 2016

Hi Greg,
First off, how well are you BPP mapped out and linked to requirements? Are all your test scenarios broken out to the BPPs? Or you guys just do ad-hoc. Some of the previous point made by other people make actually help you with the direction you need to go.

My suggestions might be biased since I come from the HP/AM(QC) and HP/UFT(QTP) world for SAP testing (I've not used other testing platforms). Also, HP licenses can get expensive so based on my initial questions of where you are with the test planning, you may want to go with a solution based on that and $$ available.

I would also suggest you guys do a nice breakout of your test plan if your planing is not robust before even thinking about a tool. Sometimes a tool can help drive that but I have done QA for a lifetime now and seen that even if you do a good plan on Word document, you have the foundation to help guide your test tool/alm tool needs.


it_user196434 - PeerSpot reviewer
User at a tech services company
May 4, 2016

You might take a look at saucelabs as they offer cloud based manual and automated record and playback testing of web applications. You'll have to determine if it is worth it based on what you are trying to do and how long those tests will be needed, etc.

it_user376134 - PeerSpot reviewer
Senior Automation Test Developer/Automation Test Architect at a computer software company with 51-200 employees
Real User
May 4, 2016

we should clarify the requirements first and then we can find the suitable tools.

1. you said "development takes on most of the testing", which type of testing they do? UI functional testing? Integration testing? unit testing? and I guess your company asks you to find the UI functional testing tools?

2. what is the type of the application under testing? mobile native application? browsers based? desktop application?

3. what is the budget? Your company likes the free tools or have limit budget? or do not care the money?

4. what is the expectation from your manager, from the development team?

it_user378180 - PeerSpot reviewer
SAP Consultant at KCA Deutag
May 4, 2016

Hi Greg, I use HP's UFT through SAP's Solution Manager. The tests are recorded, in VB script, directly from SAP and may be amended as required. All tests are administered and executed through Solution Manager and are linked directly to your Business Process documentation.

SAP offer 2 free UFT seat licences to Enterprise Support customers.

Happy to chat if you need more information.

Best Regards

it_user337821 - PeerSpot reviewer
Founder, Director at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
May 4, 2016

Hi, We provide a tool and service to automate testing of large applications. We have worked with large and complex applications. Our tool allows you to avoid having to maintain test-automation scripts or guide the software in understanding process flows. Our methodology allows you to concentrate on functional testing wherein we take on the onus of test-automation. Srirang

it_user243189 - PeerSpot reviewer
TeamLead at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
May 4, 2016

Probably you could also try with ECATT

it_user145347 - PeerSpot reviewer
Technical Leader with 501-1,000 employees
Real User
May 4, 2016

You can go with a simple approach using BDD (Behaviour Driven Development). You can write a simple business use case using Gherkin (a BDD language). The business use case can simply written in plain english using gherkin language and then can be automated using several languages for e.g. java/ ruby/ python etc. The advantage of using BDD (Given, When, Then statements) is that it is very close to the business domain and everybody from product owner to a technical writer/ Tester can easily understand what you are trying to achieve with the use case. for e.g. a simple business use case where a user logs in into the application, performs some action and then logs out of the application can simply be written as follows:

Feature: Login into the application and check product cart

Scenario: User logs in into the application, checks his product cart and then logs out

Given User "test_user" logs in into the application
And User lands up to the "product cart" page and checks it's contents
Then User logs out of the application

The above Given/ When/ Then statements then can be easily implemented into implementation code using java/ python/ ruby etc.

Hope it helps.


Related Questions
Quality Engineering Manager at Retail Insight
Apr 18, 2023
Hello community, I'm interested in using AI tools such as ChatGPT to assist in software testing tasks such as writing test cases and creating test data, perhaps driven by acceptance criteria. Does anyone have experience with this? Thank you.
See 1 answer
Owner at Technophia SRL
Apr 18, 2023
Hi Steve, ChatGPT can help in several ways from writing a Test Strategy to coding automated Selenium test cases. The most important thing is to provide a good context of what you need. You can ask "What do you need for..." and ChatGPT will guide you to provide the right context. The path to reach a good result is to iterate until you be satisfied with the work obtained. Good luck.
Development Specialist at a healthcare company with 1,001-5,000 employees
Jun 3, 2021
I'm working for a company with 1000+ employees and I'm exploring two products: Panaya and Tricentis.  How good is Panaya Test Dynamix in comparison with Tricentis?  Thank you!
2 out of 4 answers
Key Account Manager at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees
May 11, 2021
Panaya and Tricentis are both good. Could you share more info on your use case and what are your key selection criteria ?
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
May 22, 2021
@Jesús Antonio Santos Giraldo ​, can you please share more details about your case as suggested by @John ​so that our peers can assist you with your queston?
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technology products and we want your vote! If there’s a technology solution that’s really impressed you, here’s an opportunity to recognize that. It’s easy: go to the PeerSpot voting site, complete the brief voter registration form, review the list of nominees and vote. Get your colleagues to vote, too! ...
Related Categories
Related Articles
Ariel Lindenfeld - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot
Aug 21, 2022
PeerSpot User's Choice Award 2022
We’re launching an annual User’s Choice Award to showcase the most popular B2B enterprise technol...
Download Free Report
Download our free BrowserStack Report and get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: May 2023.
706,775 professionals have used our research since 2012.