Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall vs Tulip comparison

Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall vs. Tulip

Download the complete report

Helped 915,341 peers since 2012

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Categories and Ranking

Hillstone Networks Hillston...

Ranking in AWS Marketplace

460th

Average Rating

10.0

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Tulip

Ranking in AWS Marketplace

3rd

Average Rating

8.0

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Featured Reviews

reviewer2892591

Works

Centralized security has protected hybrid workloads and provides deep visibility into cloud traffic

Cloud-native automation and IaC: Terraform support, auto-scaling templates, and API maturity lag behind Palo Alto VM-Series and FortiGate-VM. Dynamically scaling in public cloud requires more manual effort. Third-party integrations and ecosystem: fewer native connectors with SIEM/SOAR platforms, CSPM, and third-party tools compared to market leaders. Documentation and training material: technical documentation and community resources (forums, tutorials, KB) are more limited, which lengthens the learning curve for new teams. SASE/SSE capabilities: the integrated SASE/ZTNA offering is less mature compared to the convergence already provided by Fortinet or Palo Alto. Centralized multi-instance management: managing large fleets of virtual appliances could be smoother; centralized management (HSM) works, but some users would like more granularity and automation.

Read full review

Prathamesh Kakde

Associate Software Engineer at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

Digital workflows have replaced paper on the shop floor and speed up regulated manufacturing

Definitely, AI in a regulated industry is something that is a concern of the clients. However, Tulip can stick to 21 CFR Part 11 strictly when it comes to Tulip's AI capabilities. Tulip has already started to look forward to compliance-related things. For example, Tulip's AI widget offers data reading throughout the site. It does not allow any AI to interact with external systems when we apply firewalls on it. In this regard, if Tulip continues in that way, they can definitely stick to the governance and security. As of now, I didn't face any issue related to their AI capabilities. It is working fine but not accurate, which is a red flag in a GXP regulated system. This is my feedback on their AI capabilities. This has been introduced into the latest LTS version and needs more hands-on experience. Before that, I cannot give a direct justification or feedback on their AI capabilities being reliable and accurate. However, at the extent that I have used them, they are accurate and reliable as of now. Tulip is an emerging platform and being a cloud-native MES, it has a lot to improve. According to me, traditional MES like FactoryTalk PharmaSuite has more complex features and user-oriented use cases and complexities that the application itself handles. However, when it comes to Tulip, all the things that matter are in the hands of a developer. That is something that Tulip can improve on. Tulip can switch to a traditional way of delivering in the pharmaceutical industry while keeping the cloud-native impact intact. One improvement that I can give an example of is that Tulip has application templates. Instead of templates, they can offer concrete applications to their pharmaceutical or any specific industrial client for their specific needs, such as a recipe designer and production management for a pharmaceutical client. Then production or material tracking or BOM tracking for a discrete client. In that way, I can see an improvement where Tulip can perform well.

Read full review

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Pros

"The most valuable aspect is the combination of traditional firewall functionality with cloud deployment flexibility."

"Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual Firewall provides advanced security for cloud and virtualized environments through next-generation firewall (NGFW) capabilities, including application visibility and control, intrusion prevention (IPS), antivirus protection, VPN services, threat intelligence, and advanced attack defense mechanisms."

"CloudEdge has helped us apply consistent security controls to our AWS workloads with our on-premises workloads."

"On balance, Hillstone CloudEdge is a solid and highly competitive solution within the virtual NGFW firewall segment."

"The best features Tulip offers include the fact that it is fairly easy to set up and allows you to connect things."

"One of the best features that Tulip offers is having a bunch of connections with third-party tools such as ERPs and specific quality tools, just to have correct traceability of what is the concern about one client or something similar."

"In a general sense, I can say a client saves 60 to 70 percent when it comes to Tulip compared to the traditional MES when it comes to money."

"Since using Tulip, my organization has positively transitioned from a lot of manual documentation for GMP compliance to digital, significantly reducing paperwork and now maintaining data retention within Tulip instead of manually."

"Tulip is a pre-configured tool where all fields and options are readily available on the Tulip platform, which impressed me when I evaluated it from a CSV perspective and development perspective."

"For projects that would take two to three days in other applications, Tulip allows us to complete them in one day."

"The best features Tulip offers are the low or no code features that enable users with no programming background to work on and build applications."

"Organizations should start using Tulip as soon as possible."

More Tulip pros

Cons

"Cloud-native automation and IaC: Terraform support, auto-scaling templates, and API maturity lag behind Palo Alto VM-Series and FortiGate-VM."

"The setup cost is more expensive with similar features."

"Additional automation resources for AWS would also be helpful."

"One area Tulip can be improved is addressing the issue that arises when multiple users use the same data tables for Tulip applications."

"Tulip can improve by providing additional features developers can use in the application."

"Tulip can be improved to have a lower entry point."

"I believe it is still at the beginning and not really advanced for the part I was using, so it could be improved."

"Tulip can improve with better or closer support in developing the applications, especially when we as a pharmaceutical company would have our specific requirements and needs that are mandatory for our industry."

"However, if you want a much larger version with better scalability and more UI features, you can consider other products."

"As of now, I didn't face any issue related to their AI capabilities. It is working fine but not accurate, which is a red flag in a GXP regulated system."

"One way Tulip can be improved is that the biggest challenge is if you already know programming. Tulip is extremely hard to set up because it doesn't follow standard programming rules."

More Tulip cons

See which vendors are best for you

Use our free recommendation engine to learn which AWS Marketplace solutions are best for your needs.

See recommendations

915,341 professionals have used our research since 2012.

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews

No data available

Construction Company

20%

Healthcare Company

15%

Outsourcing Company

13%

Comms Service Provider

12%

Company Size

By reviewers

Large Enterprise

Midsize Enterprise

Small Business

No data available

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	7
Midsize Enterprise	2
Large Enterprise	10

Questions from the Community

What needs improvement with Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall?

Additional automation resources for AWS would also be helpful. More comprehensive CloudFormation or Terraform examples, deployment templates, and guidance for high-availability architectures could ...

What is your primary use case for Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall?

We deploy Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall in AWS to protect workloads hosted inside our VPC. We use it to inspect north-south traffic, enforce access-control policies, secure communication bet...

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall?

The setup cost is more expensive with similar features.

What needs improvement with Tulip?

Tulip can be improved by offering better design and better functionalities. While making the application workable is really good, we should also focus on being great and user-friendly. Tulip is alr...

What is your primary use case for Tulip?

My main use case for Tulip is to fill up all the data which will be available from backend for the use of a warehouse. In a warehouse environment, I use Tulip by recording all the data, which made ...

What advice do you have for others considering Tulip?

Regarding Tulip's AI capabilities, I believe its accuracy and reliability of output is good. Whatever data we provide from the data perspective is displayed, and whatever UI is created is there as ...

Ignition Cloud Edition vs Tulip

Comparisons

No data available

Compared 47% of the time

GE Proficy Smart Factory MES vs Tulip

Compared 41% of the time

Stardog Enterprise Knowledge Graph Platform vs Tulip

Compared 12% of the time

More Tulip Competitors

Product Reports

AWS Marketplace

Download Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall product report

Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall report

Tulip

Download Tulip product report

Overview

Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall empowers businesses with robust security solutions optimized for cloud environments. Its advanced technology allows seamless integration and superior protection against cyber threats, making it a preferred choice for IT experts.

This advanced virtual firewall provides comprehensive security capabilities for cloud-native applications. Designed to cater to modern IT infrastructures, Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall ensures that businesses can maintain a secure, high-performance environment. It integrates smoothly into cloud platforms, ensuring seamless operation and enhanced threat detection. Businesses benefit from its user-friendly setup, centralized management, and real-time analytics, which deliver robust threat prevention and secure connectivity.

What are the key features of Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall?

Threat Detection: Offers real-time threat intelligence to identify and mitigate potential risks promptly.
Traffic Monitoring: Provides comprehensive insights into network traffic, ensuring optimal performance.
Scalability: Easily scalable to accommodate growing network demands without compromising security.
Centralized Management: Features a user-friendly interface for managing and configuring firewall settings across all connected devices.
Cloud Integration: Seamlessly integrates with major cloud platforms for streamlined operations.

What benefits and ROI can users expect?

Cost Efficiency: Reduces the cost of managing network security with streamlined operations.
Enhanced Security: Provides superior protection against cyber threats, ensuring business continuity.
Flexibility: Adapts to specific industry needs, offering customized solutions for different sectors.
Reduced Complexity: Simplifies security management with centralized controls.
Improved Performance: Ensures network efficiency and minimal latency, enhancing the end-user experience.

Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall is implemented across many industries, including finance, healthcare, and retail, where security and compliance are critical. It addresses sector-specific challenges by providing tailored configurations and advanced threat intelligence, ensuring data protection and regulatory compliance.

Hillstone Networks

Tulip is an innovative platform designed to enhance manufacturing operations by integrating core functionalities that streamline process management and data collection.

Tulip offers a dynamic approach to manufacturing tasks. By providing users with tools to build applications without code, Tulip optimizes production lines and enhances workforce efficiency. Users often highlight the platform's ability to aggregate real-time data for better decision-making and its ease of customization. Despite its strengths, feedback suggests there is room for improvement in areas like scaling application functionalities and expanding integration capabilities with third-party tools.

What are the important features of Tulip?

No-code Application Development: Enables users to create custom applications without requiring programming skills, facilitating rapid prototyping and deployment.
Real-time Data Collection: Allows for instant data capture and analytics, supporting informed decision-making processes.
Customizable Dashboards: Offers users the ability to tailor dashboards to specific metrics and KPIs, enhancing visibility into operations.

What benefits or ROI should users look for?

Increased Efficiency: Streamlines workflows and reduces bottlenecks, leading to improved productivity and operational efficiency.
Enhanced Data Accuracy: Real-time data updating ensures accurate and timely information, essential for precise analysis.
Scalable Improvements: Facilitates continuous improvement initiatives, enabling businesses to adapt and evolve practices effectively.

Tulip is particularly effective in industries like automotive, electronics, and pharmaceuticals where precise data tracking and process optimization are critical. It aids in quality control and compliance through its robust data analytics and reporting features, significantly benefiting these sectors.

Tulip Interfaces

Hillstone Networks Hillstone CloudEdge Virtual-Firewall vs. Tulip