Coming October 25: PeerSpot Awards will be announced! Learn more
2021-04-29T15:28:00Z
RR
User at Humana Inc.
  • 1
  • 732

What is the difference between Collibra Data Governance and Azure Purview?

I'm checking the following two products: Collibra Data Governance and Azure Purview.

And I'm looking for your inputs about the difference between them. What does Azure Purview offer that Collibra Data Governance doesn't?

Thanks in advance for your help!

1
PeerSpot user
1 Answer
Tom Kilburn - PeerSpot reviewer
President at TCC
Real User
Top 10
2021-04-30T17:01:35Z
30 April 21

These are actually very similar products - in fact, an ex-Collibra person I know had the impression that MSFT must have just looked at Collibra's application and essentially duplicated it.  At their core, both are essentially Business Glossaries and Data Dictionaries (Catalogs) with a bunch of window dressing.


In terms of where each may have an edge:


1.  Collibra's strength is as a collaboration platform.  So, their workflows are more developed to enable things like approval of terms, etc,, and capture the historical proposals/changes.  Although MSFT obviously delivers collaboration through Sharepoint, integrated workflows with Purview may take a while, even though the capability is clearly there and MSFT should not be under-estimated.  


I know some clients that want a DG tools-independent approach (i.e.  do not want to spend the money on a separate DG-specific toolset such as  Collibra, Alation, ERwin, Informatica), so they instead use Sharepoint and add something like Nintex to handle the workflows and it apparently works quite nicely.  It also should be noted that the out-of-the-box Collibra workflows are pretty basic, and clients will need to build their own for anything that is more involved or based on client-centric processes - this involves building swimlane workflows in Eclipse and importing them into Collibra.


2.  Microsoft's strength is in the potential integration of the data management tools required to *fix" data quality issues to deliver business outcomes through a governance process.  One of the three primary governance use cases is analytics, and Power BI is a very prominent player in the BI/dashboarding space, so one assumes that MSFT will have an advantage for APIs related to PBI and ingestion of related metadata.  MSFT also has DQ/DI (ETL) through SSIS to enable data profiling, etc.  Collibra did recognize this gap and purchase OwlDQ recently, but one guesses that it will be a year before this is actually integrated.


The single biggest issue on the technology side in Data Governance is integration (surprise! =).  This is the biggest area of weakness for Collibra, as their strategy has changed multiple times over the past couple of years, and the breadth of integrations that customers are looking for just aren't there (ERwin actually has an impressive story on that front).  This continues to haunt Collibra projects and means that a lot of time and money is spent on the technical side to build a foundation.  This inhibits clients from implementing programmatic components that drive business participation.  The related issue is that business sponsors and potential business participants come to see DG initiatives as technical infrastructure projects and do not view them as mission critical in the delivery of a digital transformation strategy, which is what they should be.  And once business leaves the table, it is very hard to get them back for a second round when they don't see the value.


Purview is able to work with any Azure cloud application data or on-prem SQL Server metadata (in addition to AWS cloud application data to some extent I believe), but their broader API strategy remains to be seen as it is still early days (launched in Dec. 2020).  If they take this as seriously as they are claiming however, expect MSFT to make gains in this area quickly, but don't trust the promises of any vendor: if you have specific sources to ingest, then ask for a reference customer and a demo of the integration actually working, no matter which vendor you are dealing with.


My final comment:  both good products, but remember that DG is all about growing a program based on documenting your internal business and data management processes.  As a result, my advice would be to choose the most cost-effective option that has the *existing* (not promised) APIs that you need for your sources, and use it to formalize these processes within a tool.  If you get this in order, you can change your tool over time.  The DG marketplace has evolved so that the "tool is the solution" approach is no longer valid, and people realize that the build of a DG Program is more about their own internal processes than it is about the purchase of technology.

Find out what your peers are saying about Collibra Governance vs. Microsoft Purview and other solutions. Updated: September 2022.
634,325 professionals have used our research since 2012.
Related Questions
YN
Research Assistant at a educational organization with 10,001+ employees
Sep 01, 2022
I work as a Research Assistant at a large Educational organization (10,000+ employees) Currently, I'm researching Data Governance tools.  Can you share some sort of feature comparison between Collibra Governance, Informatica Axon, IBM Data Governance, and ASG Enterprise Data Intelligence features (or some of those products) for Data Governance?
See 2 answers
Tracy Hautenen Kriel - PeerSpot reviewer
Architecture Sr. Manager, Data Design & Metadata Mgmt at a insurance company with 10,001+ employees
01 September 22
Besides features, don't forget to look at user experience and software performance. One of your choices is significantly lacking in both areas. You might consider adding erwin Data Intelligence Suite to your list. Something you might find interesting: Alation vs Collibra vs Quest (erwin) 2022 | Gartner Peer Insights  You can change the products you are comparing, seeing how others have rated the tools you are looking at.
Delmar Assis - PeerSpot reviewer
CEO at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
01 September 22
Hello Yegane, I recommend add Precisely Data360 Govern (Infogix Data360 Govern)
LY
User at Lixar
May 05, 2022
Hello community, I work at a Tech. company and I would like to compare  Microsoft Azure Purview with IBM Data Governance. Which one would you choose and why? Also, would you choose IBM Data Governance over other products for data governance? Thank you!
See 2 answers
Evgeny Belenky - PeerSpot reviewer
Director of Community at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)
04 May 22
Hi @Kelly Broekstra, @Tracy Hautenen Kriel, @Andrew Wandera ​and @Tom Kilburn, can you possibly assist @LindaYarema ​with this question? ​ 
Delmar Assis - PeerSpot reviewer
CEO at a tech services company with 51-200 employees
05 May 22
If I have to choose one, it's Purview. However, it's pretty new (just the beginning), has no complete capabilities and is not mature.  IBM is very complex and hard to implement. 
Related Articles
Manoj Narayanan - PeerSpot reviewer
Practice Director - Digital & Analytics Practice at HCL Technologies
Aug 12, 2022
What is a data mesh? For decades, entrprises have just stored and stored data without really having any ways of cataloguing making it difficult to use the same data for a good reason. The issues include difficulty in discovering relevant data, not being able to democratize data and use it for business strategies and most importantly not being able to trust the data. It is important to ensure ...
Aug 19, 2021
Organizations are in search of new ideas to remain relevant in today's data-driven world. Data is a key asset that can either make or break a go-to-market strategy and bring in the next big change. In this new normal e-commerce has benefitted the most and every business (big or small) is using platforms to get to the consumer with innovative products and services. What drives such behavior?   ...
Thomas Dodds - PeerSpot reviewer
Practice Director - Data Architecture & Governance at Agilarc LLC
May 11, 2021
All too often I hear talk of data culture and the conversation quickly encircles data technologies and tools. Technology and tools are not cultures. Culture is: “a way of life for a group of people--the behaviors, beliefs, values, and symbols that they accept, generally without thinking about them, and that are passed along by communication and imitation from one generation to the next.” [1] A ...
Related Articles
Manoj Narayanan - PeerSpot reviewer
Practice Director - Digital & Analytics Practice at HCL Technologies
Aug 12, 2022
How to operationalize a Data Mesh using Data Fabric
What is a data mesh? For decades, entrprises have just stored and stored data without really hav...
Aug 19, 2021
Data as An Asset
Organizations are in search of new ideas to remain relevant in today's data-driven world. Data is...
Related Categories
Download Free Report
Download our free Collibra Governance Report and get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: September 2022.
DOWNLOAD NOW
634,325 professionals have used our research since 2012.