Ignition Cloud Edition vs Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] comparison

Ignition Cloud Edition vs. Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]

Download the complete report

Helped 915,341 peers since 2012

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Categories and Ranking

Ignition Cloud Edition

Ranking in AWS Marketplace

4th

Average Rating

8.8

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Splunk Cloud [Private Offer...

Ranking in AWS Marketplace

500th

Average Rating

8.6

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Featured Reviews

Hassana Abubakar

Control Systems (Scada) Engineer at Mainstream Energy Solutions Limited

Cloud monitoring has transformed real-time plant control and automated preventive maintenance

There is always room for improvement, and at the moment, I am on the good side. I do not really have a bad side of it or anything that I would like to see changed; I love what I see and I love what I use. One feature that comes to my mind as missing in Ignition Cloud Edition is the user graphics in the user interface. The graphics in the user interface, such as the slider or the shapes for the equipment, can be improved upon. When I am selecting a tank, I should see a real tank, or when I am selecting a breaker, it should look like a real breaker in the field, or a valve or a sensor or a slider. Every other feature, such as the graphs and charts, are cool.

Read full review

Lakshman Kanuru

Associate manager at ValueLabs

Comprehensive log monitoring has improved proactive incident response and cost control

The best features Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] offers include the Ingest Processor, which allows me to filter out or stop data ingestion from the data source to reduce ingestion and storage licensing costs. I am currently exploring this good feature. Regarding my experience with the Ingest Processor, I have a consumer whose application forwards data into Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]. Unfortunately, when there is a restart, old duplicate data is also ingested alongside the current data. For example, the last 24 hours' data amounts to 15 to 20 GB, and when the application restarts, an additional 15 to 20 GB of duplicate data ingests. Consequently, instead of the expected 15 to 20 GB, I am looking at almost 30 to 40 GB of ingestion cost. By using the Ingest Processor, I can effectively stop the duplicate data ingestion into Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]. Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] has positively impacted my organization in many ways. For instance, if something goes wrong with an application I monitor, without Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only], notifications are unavailable, and support staff would not be notified, which saves time. I also have proactive alerts and predictive analysis, saving costs by preventing the ingestion of duplicate data into Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]. From a security standpoint, I have audit-related features to address issues or malicious attacks. Utilizing predictions and AI functions aids me in multiple areas of operations.

Read full review

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Pros

"Ignition Cloud Edition has positively impacted my organization by enabling sharing so that projects can be shared without everyone having to access them through manual file sharing."

"The best features Ignition Cloud Edition offers are the ability to set alerts on a system and access that remotely."

"What I love about Ignition Cloud Edition is the advantages and functionalities it has over other SCADA software."

"My main use case for Ignition Cloud Edition, even if it's just in my learning phase, was that it is a very interesting cloud platform, it was very much feasible, it can interface to multiple types of controllers and also with RTUs, and I see that its application can be used in other applications which is much more comfortable than other available platforms."

"Ignition Cloud Edition has had a very positive impact on our organization, especially in the way we access and use industrial data."

"Both the database and Ignition can be set up very easily without any hardware, and reliability and high availability are always there, built in."

"Ignition Cloud Edition has had a very positive impact on my organization."

"Ignition Cloud Edition has positively impacted my organization by allowing us to get more projects and also increasing our revenue."

More Ignition Cloud Edition pros

"Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] has positively impacted my organization in many ways, providing proactive alerts and predictive analysis that save costs by preventing the ingestion of duplicate data while also delivering audit-related security features and AI-driven predictions that aid multiple areas of operations."

"Despite its cost, I see value for money and a return on investment with Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]."

Cons

"Ignition Cloud Edition reflects that it is still missing some driver options and we require a more cost-effective solution, which is why I rate it an eight on a scale of one to ten."

"Ignition Cloud Edition can be improved in the sense that it doesn't come with some drivers in the Cloud version. For example, local device drivers are not included, and you always need a local Ignition Edge there."

"The way the historian is set up is not conducive to large deployments and it makes querying the data challenging."

"For someone considering Ignition Cloud Edition, I think it is not bad, but honestly, I see it as overpriced."

"I think Ignition Cloud Edition could be more intuitive on how to use it."

"My concern is about cybersecurity. Since it's a cloud platform, the chances of countering cybersecurity attacks will be a major concern."

"The pricing aspect of Ignition Cloud Edition is actually on the high side."

"The accuracy of Ignition Cloud Edition is not very great, and reliability also needs improvement."

"I did not receive an answer to my question regarding how these integrations with third-party tools help you."

"To improve Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only], the latest version 10.5 introduces a UI that feels somewhat difficult to navigate compared to earlier versions, making it uncomfortable."

See which vendors are best for you

Use our free recommendation engine to learn which AWS Marketplace solutions are best for your needs.

See recommendations

915,341 professionals have used our research since 2012.

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews

Construction Company

25%

Manufacturing Company

20%

Outsourcing Company

Comms Service Provider

No data available

Company Size

By reviewers

Large Enterprise

Midsize Enterprise

Small Business

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	7
Midsize Enterprise	3
Large Enterprise	3

No data available

Questions from the Community

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for Ignition Cloud Edition?

My experience with pricing, setup costs, and licensing was quite good, as it was straightforward based on how many machines, what kind of hardware we wanted to use, and how many users were needed.

What needs improvement with Ignition Cloud Edition?

Improvements for Ignition Cloud Edition should include the addition of more traditional PLCs-based drivers. I would also suggest that they might launch future Ignition Cloud Edition-based services,...

What is your primary use case for Ignition Cloud Edition?

My main use case for Ignition Cloud Edition is regarding the customer deployment of these Ignition Cloud Edition projects when they do not want to install on the on-premises servers. My main use ca...

What needs improvement with Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]?

I did not receive an answer to my question regarding how these integrations with third-party tools help you.Can Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]'s reporting functionality be improved, especially i...

What is your primary use case for Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]?

The major purposes for which my clients are using Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] seem to go beyond five.As a partner and integrator, I believe the biggest advantage of Splunk Cloud [Private Offe...

What advice do you have for others considering Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]?

If I had to rate Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] overall, from zero to ten, I would expect to elaborate a bit more on how these integrations with third-party tools help.I believe that the data en...

Tulip vs Ignition Cloud Edition

Comparisons

Compared 49% of the time

Insights Hub vs Ignition Cloud Edition

Compared 23% of the time

Cloud Rewind (formerly Appranix) vs Ignition Cloud Edition

Compared 14% of the time

Cognite Data Fusion vs Ignition Cloud Edition

Compared 14% of the time

More Ignition Cloud Edition Competitors

No data available

Product Reports

Ignition Cloud Edition

Download Ignition Cloud Edition product report

AWS Marketplace

Download Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] product report

Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] report

Overview

Ignition Cloud Edition is a scalable software solution designed to enhance operational efficiency through cloud-based data integration and real-time insights, providing businesses with powerful tools for better decision-making.

This fully-featured platform streamlines industrial processes and enables seamless deployment of applications across diverse environments. Its cloud infrastructure supports robust data management, helping users achieve greater scalability and flexibility. With Ignition Cloud Edition, enterprises benefit from cutting-edge connectivity and analytical capabilities tailored for optimal performance in dynamic industrial settings.

What are the key features?

Cloud Integration: Offers seamless access to cloud resources, eliminating the need for extensive on-premise hardware.
Real-Time Data Analytics: Provides instant insights to enhance decision-making capabilities.
Scalable Architecture: Allows businesses to expand operations easily without disrupting processes.
Remote Monitoring: Enables comprehensive oversight from any location, improving control and efficiency.
Easy Setup and Deployment: Facilitates rapid deployment, reducing time and cost investment.
Comprehensive Security: Ensures data protection with advanced security protocols.

What benefits should users consider?

Increased Efficiency: Achieves higher productivity by optimizing resource allocation and reducing downtime.
Cost Savings: Lowers operational costs by minimizing infrastructure investments.
Improved Scalability: Adapts to changing business demands, supporting growth seamlessly.
Enhanced Flexibility: Provides versatile access and control options, enabling agile responses to industry changes.
Better Insights: Delivers actionable analytics that drive informed business decisions.

Ignition Cloud Edition finds application in industries like manufacturing, energy, and utilities, where real-time data access and operational efficiency are critical. Companies in these sectors implement it to harness cloud power, optimizing workflows and improving safety standards while maintaining cost-effectiveness. Its adaptability to industrial environments makes it a preferred choice for businesses aiming to embrace digital transformation.

Inductive Automation

Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] provides comprehensive data analytics capabilities tailored for complex IT environments, enabling businesses to gain actionable insights efficiently.

Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] serves as a robust platform for advanced data analysis, assisting organizations in managing, visualizing, and interpreting large volumes of data. It enhances operational efficiency by offering seamless integration with existing systems, ensuring reliable and scalable performance tailored to meet specific business needs. Enterprises can leverage its capabilities for security monitoring, IT operations management, and application development support, all within a flexible cloud-based environment.

What are the key features of Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]?

Real-Time Insights: Provides immediate data analysis to ensure swift decision-making.
Scalability: Easily adjusts to growing data needs without compromising performance.
Integration Compatibility: Seamlessly connects with other platforms to enhance operational flow.
Enhanced Security: Offers advanced security features to protect sensitive data.

What benefits should users consider in reviews?

Increased Efficiency: Streamlines data processes, reducing operational overhead.
Cost-Effectiveness: Cloud deployment minimizes upfront infrastructure costs.
Improved Decision Making: Facilitates better business choices with precise data insights.
Security Assurance: Builds trust with robust security measures.

In industries like finance and healthcare, Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only] supports critical operations by ensuring secure data management and providing insights that improve service delivery. Retail businesses benefit from enhanced customer experience and targeted marketing efforts driven by data-driven insights.

Carahsoft

Ignition Cloud Edition vs. Splunk Cloud [Private Offer Only]