No more typing reviews! Try our Samantha, our new voice AI agent.

GitLab [Private Offer Only] vs Redgate Flyway comparison

Why PeerSpot?
 

Comparison Buyer's Guide

Executive Summary

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:
 

Categories and Ranking

GitLab [Private Offer Only]
Ranking in AWS Marketplace
422nd
Average Rating
8.6
Number of Reviews
7
Ranking in other categories
No ranking in other categories
Redgate Flyway
Ranking in AWS Marketplace
20th
Average Rating
7.6
Number of Reviews
6
Ranking in other categories
No ranking in other categories
 

Featured Reviews

Anoop K Jayan - PeerSpot reviewer
Technical Lead at Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
AI-driven workflows have transformed our end-to-end development and collaboration processes
The built-in CI/CD integration in GitLab [Private Offer Only] is lacking. We are still depending on other packages. If GitLab [Private Offer Only] had some CI/CD integration internally, it would be beneficial. Because for CI/CD integration now, we are currently doing it with the direct server side. I think it is not that much integrated with the current scenarios of AI, that is AI agent-based or assistant-based coding patterns. Some more improvement is required in GitLab [Private Offer Only] for CI/CD integration along with AI platforms. AI integration is basically what we need, especially on the CI/CD side of GitLab [Private Offer Only]. The code assistant, such as a cloud code assistant, is making things with GitLab [Private Offer Only], but it is conventional. They are pulling the code and sending the thing. I think they can do some more integration, seamless integration with GitLab [Private Offer Only]. AI is consuming GitLab [Private Offer Only] with the older style. If AI were fully pluggable in GitLab [Private Offer Only], it would be beneficial. I think we could get some more time reduction, especially on the testing side and the code testing side.
Hassan F - PeerSpot reviewer
Full Stack Developer at DPL
Automated database releases have reduced errors and now save a full day of deployment effort
The best features that Redgate Flyway offers, if I had to pick a few that really stand out, would be multi-environment support. On the migrations tab, I do not need to go to an environment and change settings or anything. I simply change the branches of the environment and it shows me what is available and what has been run on a certain environment. The environment feature is very user-friendly and helpful, so I would keep it at the top of my list. The feature of changing branches on the migrations tab is very helpful. An example of how Redgate Flyway specifically helped with discrepancies is that previously we did not have any tool recording database changes. We work on an Agile Scrum pattern, so we have to do deployments frequently, within every two to three weeks or sometimes four weeks. Previously, we had code repositories for front-end and back-end, but for the database side, we did not have any repository. We were not saving database-related changes in any GitHub or AWS CodeCommit repositories. Every time, we have a Jira board where developers update their scripts. For example, if I work on a ticket and update a stored procedure, I must mention the stored procedure on the ticket. When deployment time arrives, the release manager must pull out or scan all the tickets and extract the objects. For example, if we deploy 10 Jira tickets from a sprint in the next release, we must go through all 10 tickets and see the post-deployments of their tickets. Then we extracted the objects from the development environment, deployed on stage, and then deployed on production. In this scenario, many objects and discrepancies occurred. Sometimes a developer or the release manager would forget the object to take to production. Now, after using Redgate Flyway, I have restricted access as the release manager of my team. I manage the release for my team and have restricted developer access to environments other than the development environment. If developers want to take anything to the next environment such as demo, staging, or production, they must make a script. When they create a script, it is in our record. Now, after using Redgate Flyway, we do not need to scan all the tickets on Jira or see the post-deployments of each ticket. We simply view the Redgate Flyway script showing what has been run from this to this version, and what pending deployments need to be run on production. In this way, it has helped tremendously. I can share that the migrations tab and branch changing helped my team in a specific situation during our second last sprint. Two developers were working on the same object, and one change needed to be deployed on stage while another change needed to be deployed on the demo environment, which is our QA level. Our QA and demo are the same environment, and then we have stage and production. We have three environments other than development. Previously, without Redgate Flyway, what could have happened is that we would take the stored procedure from demo if we needed to deploy it on stage and take it directly to stage. This was our previous practice where we would go to the database explorer, take the stored procedure, and move it to the next environment with the ticket. Now with Redgate Flyway, we have different versions of that stored procedure. We simply took the version of the stored procedure that needed to be on stage, and the second version that needed to be on the QA level remained there. Redgate Flyway helped in this case, and we have many cases.

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:
 

Pros

"With GitLab [Private Offer Only], I think you can save on time to market because it is a good tool to handle different branch strategies and manage pipelines."
"We have not faced any issues with GitLab [Private Offer Only]. It has been stable throughout our use."
"GitLab [Private Offer Only] acts as a repository management tool where I can store all my codes, especially my source code, and it helps us to create our own pipelines, automate our jobs through CI/CD, configure our own servers, enhance security in our codes, and improve our performance."
"The best advantage of GitLab from my experience is that the community is very big, so you can find everything easily."
"GitLab [Private Offer Only] is completely isolated from the internet, which allows us to have our own private repository since there is no need to share the source code."
"The top feature that makes me use GitHub and GitLab [Private Offer Only] is that we can have CI/CD integrated, we can also maintain versions and get pull requests, and these things are also very easy to implement, which is why we use it."
"We reduced the four to five-month development time to four to five weeks, a maximum of one month, and we are getting that much throughput with the same employee strength."
"Redgate Flyway has positively impacted my organization by maintaining consistency among developers."
"Redgate Flyway has impacted us very positively because we don't have to manually cover all those things."
"Redgate Flyway streamlines the process of database migration and significantly reduces the time for data migration from twenty to twenty-five days down to five to seven days, thanks to the initial time we took for learning."
"I have seen a return on investment with Redgate Flyway in that time was saved significantly for local development."
"Redgate Flyway has positively impacted my organization by enabling automated database migrations, so there are no manual updates to databases on each deployment to each environment."
"Now using Redgate Flyway, we do not need to do any of this procedure, so this whole process has been eliminated, almost a day is saved, and on release day there are 99% chances that the scripts will run successfully without issues."
 

Cons

"I would appreciate the benefits of the analytics features, but they are not available in our account or subscription plan."
"Unexpected delays happen often, although it has never failed us."
"The built-in CI/CD integration in GitLab [Private Offer Only] is lacking. We are still depending on other packages."
"There are disadvantages in GitLab [Private Offer Only]; we sometimes find challenges with lengthy CI/CD pipeline processes and the missing integration of AI, which, if implemented, could considerably speed up the deployment process."
"Sometimes, errors with migrations can be very disappointing, as often it requires deleting everything and starting over."
"Regarding the error mechanism, when we see a Redgate Flyway error in my Spring Boot application, it is very difficult to understand what went wrong."
"Particularly, the error handling mechanism or the force update or forced migration are things I would like to see improved; it is very hard to understand or debug exactly where this migration has failed, and I would not feel confident doing this in a production environment."
"I cannot say that it is highly secure, but the features are good."
"Redgate Flyway works well for small teams but presents conflict issues with larger teams due to version control."
"I would not recommend Redgate Flyway for any Microsoft-based solutions or .NET, as it is not compatible at all based on my experience."
report
Use our free recommendation engine to learn which AWS Marketplace solutions are best for your needs.
915,341 professionals have used our research since 2012.
 

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews
No data available
Construction Company
32%
Comms Service Provider
15%
Financial Services Firm
9%
Manufacturing Company
8%
 

Company Size

By reviewers
Large Enterprise
Midsize Enterprise
Small Business
By reviewers
Company SizeCount
Small Business2
Large Enterprise6
By reviewers
Company SizeCount
Small Business3
Large Enterprise4
 

Questions from the Community

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for GitLab [Private Offer Only]?
I do not go into the details of GitLab [Private Offer Only]'s pricing because my PM takes care of it as part of project procurement, billing, and all, so it is not in my hands. However, with the te...
What needs improvement with GitLab [Private Offer Only]?
I have not explored that far with GitLab [Private Offer Only] because you mentioned project management. I have not used GitLab [Private Offer Only] or GitHub for project management. I think if you ...
What is your primary use case for GitLab [Private Offer Only]?
I am involved in automation testing. We have utilized GitLab [Private Offer Only]'s continuous integration feature because our automation code is in the CI/CD pipeline. We have implemented it via G...
What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for Redgate Flyway?
My experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing is that we have independent work with a separation of roles. We have those maintaining things concerning databases and a team that manages pric...
What needs improvement with Redgate Flyway?
I choose a rating of nine out of ten for Redgate Flyway because the only point is that sometimes it does not automatically handle the schema versioning. If we write something wrong, it just execute...
What is your primary use case for Redgate Flyway?
My main use case for Redgate Flyway is that it is a migration version control tool. I prefer Redgate Flyway because instead of manually running SQL scripts on different environments like dev, QA, a...
 

Comparisons

No data available
 

Overview

Find out what your peers are saying about GitLab [Private Offer Only] vs. Redgate Flyway and other solutions. Updated: September 2026.
915,341 professionals have used our research since 2012.