Imperva DDoS and F5 Advanced WAF compete in the network security category with a focus on protection against DDoS attacks and web application security. While both offer robust solutions, F5 Advanced WAF seems to have the edge due to its high-end features and customization capabilities, as highlighted by users in terms of detailed logging and attack signatures.
Features: Imperva DDoS is recognized for its ease of configuration, effective analytics, and intelligent data filtering. It excels in SQL injection prevention and integrates analytics with real-time threat monitoring. F5 Advanced WAF stands out for its stability and advanced threat detection. It offers a rich feature set that includes Local Traffic Manager (LTM) and Application Security Manager (ASM), which provide enhanced security and customizability. Users value its detailed logging and robust protection features.
Room for Improvement: Imperva DDoS could benefit from enhanced analytics, improvements in caching rules, and expanded third-party integration. Users also suggest better technical support response times and reporting features. F5 Advanced WAF requires a more intuitive GUI, improved reporting capabilities, and a more competitive pricing structure. Its complex feature set necessitates technical expertise for setup, which some users find challenging.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Imperva DDoS is often deployed in public cloud environments, receiving mixed reviews for technical support. They are noted for responsiveness but could improve initial support levels. F5 Advanced WAF, primarily used on-premises, also faces challenges in cloud deployments with users seeking better integration and deployment processes. F5 users are generally satisfied with customer service, though configuration complexity is a noted downside.
Pricing and ROI: Imperva DDoS is priced variably, considered cost-effective for medium to large enterprises, though extensive use can be expensive. Users acknowledge a high ROI, particularly for those frequently targeted by attacks. Conversely, F5 Advanced WAF is more expensive but seen as justified by its advanced features. Its pricing complexity, with potential add-ons, increases the total cost. Users suggest more competitive pricing to suit different business sizes while appreciating the comprehensive protection offered.
Subscription models offer clearer ROI due to a more competitive pricing scheme.
They know how much money they are losing while the system is down, so by increasing the possibility of not having a down website or web application, return on investment can be calculated easily.
If there is a bug, the support is usually understanding and resolves issues.
I have interacted with F5's support, and while I have no major complaints, they could improve.
I would rate the technical support of Imperva DDoS as ten.
99% of customers are using the cloud version of Imperva DDoS protection, so they just purchase the new license and scale as needed.
The stability of Imperva DDoS is very good, as it seems they have a lot of servers around the world.
Deployment training for F5 Advanced WAF is lacking and restricts growth by being inaccessible and costly for partners.
Maybe Imperva DDoS could use endpoints to get information about the attacks before they commence from the endpoint level or establish cooperation with endpoint vendors to share this information.
Subscription models have competitive pricing, while perpetual licenses involve an upfront higher cost.
The price is affordable and satisfactory.
I would rate the pricing of Imperva DDoS as five, where one is very cheap and ten is very expensive.
The perpetual license, despite an initial higher cost, lacks transparency regarding support expiration.
It contains the logic of both negative and positive security combined.
Imperva DDoS has User Behavior Analytics and Threat Intelligence on its board, and this helps us to be protected proactively.
F5 Advanced WAF is a web application security solution for financial and government sectors, e-commerce, and public-facing websites. It offers protection against various attacks, including botnets, web scraping, and foreign entities. The solution can be deployed on-premises or in the cloud and is often used with other security tools. Its most valuable features include DDoS and DNS attack protection, SSL uploading, anomaly detection, and the ability to input custom rules.
F5 Advanced WAF has helped organizations to expose more services to the public while providing an extra layer of protection, preventing revenue loss, and securing connectivity.
Imperva DDoS is a solution that offers protection for web applications and websites and all their associated business-critical data from cyberattacks. The cloud-based application delivery service helps improve user experiences by improving their performance. Through its security platform, Imperva DDoS also provides DDoS mitigation, a web application firewall, and a global load balancer, and includes a content delivery network — all designed to maximize performance.
Imperva DDoS Features
Imperva DDoS has many valuable key features. Some of the most useful ones include:
Imperva DDoS Benefits
There are several benefits to implementing Imperva DDoS. Some of the biggest advantages the solution offers include:
Reviews from Real Users
Below are some reviews and helpful feedback written by Imperva DDoS users.
PeerSpot user, Etienne W., CDN & Cybersecurity Engineer - Web performance & security at CDN Tech / Ecritel, says, “It is a good solution that allows us to protect websites. It is stable, scalable, quick and easy to use.” He goes on to explain, “WAF protection works almost out-of-the-box. The Anti-DDoS mitigation in less than 1s, I saw it many times in production, I can say it works. CDN has high performances, and the Smart Caching mode is really "smart" (you can do some efficient caching even if you're not a specialist). Its unique interface for managing security performance and ease of use are the most valuable features of this solution."
An IT Senior Manager at an outsourcing company mentions, “The most valuable features are DDoS protection. The Incapsula [Imperva DDoS] environment helps us monitor all the web activity. All the web activity is passed through their WAF cloud services, then that can help us to monitor those activities. That can help protect against DDoS hacking.”
Another PeerSpot reviewer, Ben D., Sales Executive at EVVO LABS, comments, "Imperva Incapsula [DDoS] has many valuable features. One, it protects the top 10 OWASP vulnerability, the open web application software platform, this is standard. Secondly, it protects against broken authentication. As well, it has remote execution of code."
A Solutions Architect at a financial services firm states, “The solution's most valuable aspect is that it is easy to configure. The solution keeps itself up to date itself and there's no customization that we need to do. It makes it extremely easy and cuts back on the amount of work required, and saves us on man-hours.”
We monitor all Web Application Firewall (WAF) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
