AWS Control Tower and Spacelift operate in the cloud infrastructure management domain. AWS Control Tower gains the upper hand due to its comprehensive compliance and governance features.
Features: AWS Control Tower offers powerful compliance and governance capabilities with features like guardrails and single sign-on, automating account provisioning and aligning security policies with organizational standards. It also supports centralized authentication and detailed service control policies for multi-account management. Spacelift integrates well with Terraform and offers GitOps capabilities, modernizing infrastructure deployments and providing a pull request-based system for seamless workflow management. Automatic change detection and management enhance its efficiency.
Room for Improvement: AWS Control Tower could bolster integration options with more AWS functions and reduce the initial setup complexity. Users highlight a need for additional customizable security policies and better multi-region configuration support. Spacelift's improvement areas include deployment orchestration and stack dependencies, aiming to simplify major deployments. The lack of extensive features in the self-hosted version compared to SaaS, particularly in cloud integration, is noted.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: AWS Control Tower is widely used in public cloud settings, offering enterprise-grade support, though reaching higher-tier support may involve delays. Its seamless integration with AWS services enhances deployment capabilities. Spacelift supports both cloud and on-premises environments, consistently delivering excellent customer support. Its flexibility in varying infrastructure settings provides a robust support experience for technical issues.
Pricing and ROI: AWS Control Tower provides a flexible pay-as-you-go model, cost-effective for different businesses, with an excellent ROI from simplified account management and security enhancements. Spacelift, considered pricey, offers significant cost savings over tools like Terraform Enterprise, justifying investment through efficient infrastructure management and active team utilization.
AWS Control Tower offers the easiest way to set up and govern a new, secure, multi-account AWS environment. It establishes a landing zone that is based on best-practices blueprints, and enables governance using guardrails you can choose from a pre-packaged list.
Spacelift provides a sophisticated infrastructure management platform with key features such as Drift Detection and Terraform integration, simplifying complex deployments and enhancing user workflows through an intuitive interface.
Spacelift excels in modernizing infrastructure management by integrating smoothly with Terraform, using a pull request-based approach for visibility into logs. It automates change detection using GitOps from GitHub and supports AWS connectivity with credential management. Despite its strengths, some users find room for improvement in supporting smaller enterprises and offering more seamless cloud integrations with self-hosted versions. Handling of HashiCorp Vault secrets and cumbersome notification webhooks may require additional setup effort.
What are the most valuable features?In specific industries, Spacelift is primarily utilized for infrastructure management and deployment across platforms like AWS, Azure, and GCP. In banking architecture, it replaces Terraform Enterprise, ensuring secure and efficient operations. Projects like Google Fiber benefit from its capability to import and manage data effectively, engaging users with HashiCorp Language and GitHub for CI/CD integration.
We monitor all Cloud Management reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
